Sidilicious
T20I Debutant
- Joined
- Jun 21, 2013
- Runs
- 6,207
I don't agree about mentally strong.Though you make some good points about poorer Mumbai teams winning title.Its all relative in the end. Also having great system is not the same as having great facilities.
I believe, thats part of it. If you have a great system, that by itself will lead to great facilities. Also, the winning mentality is part of the Mumbai system. Every year, a Mumbai Ranji team is expected to win a Ranji campaign. A seasoned Mumbai player has 8-10 Ranji titles under his belt.
For players from other teams (especially those not from Karnataka, TN and Delhi) winning, or even making it to the final is a big deal.
Another thing to note, is due to the cricket culture in Mumbai, even though they might not produce International class players for India, but they will always produce players just one level below. The interesting question is whether such players - the great domestic players - come from good talent, or are a result of a great system.
I would say that the system surely helps. Because if you look at other states with a good system (not as great as Mumbai, but still decent ones) - Delhi, Hyderabad, TN, Karnataka - they've usually been the other top performers.
Finally, we need to give it to Mumbai, though. They have produced two of the greatest talents in world cricket. So, there is talent in Mumbai, just as there is in other states. But Mumbai has been excellent in harnessing and finishing those talents in such a manner, that even if the talents are not International class, they will always make champion cricketers.