Yea was a pretty poor call from Misbah to push for Chacha
Misbah had no vision that's his issue, it's always quick fixes with him which does harm.
For example Mickey's vision
1) Recognises Fakhar is useless when he made his debut at no 4 in t20, Decided to make him open in all formats and dubbed him X factor, Aka saw potential beyond stats.
2) Create a lineage of backups even if some backups were questionable.
For hafeez and Malik, Haris sohail, then brought on shadab and Nawaz which granted failed but were experimented with, Then in 2023 despite having zero control, comvinced the team to bring on agha and saud as potential allrounders for the no 4 and no 5 position before rizzu decided to replace agha.
3) Similarly for sarfi's eventual retirment he cited Rizwan, Kamran Akmal, Yes in hindsight it didnt work and rizwan coming in caused so much harm but atleast the hoal was to build a team of 30 pool players.
4) Same for wahab and shaheen was cited as the eventual left handed successor. Alot of players like faheem etc were tried and tested.
5) also cited babar azam as a potential no 3 in all formats whereas previously he was batting at 4 and 6.
6) Got hafeez to discard his opening ego and bat at 4.
^^ Mickey by no means is perfect but he kept experimenting and experimenting and had backups upon backups which sometimes worked like Fakhar, Haris sohail, Agha salman, Imad Wasim, Amir and sometimes did not aka rizwan, shadab, Nawaz
He’s now pushing Irfan Niazi as the next Misbah project. You should be able to read through the lines with him
Whereas Misbah has zero vision, he chooses quick fixes not realising half the time this cannot work.
For example
1) Decided to take Muhammad irfan on the basis of Aussie bouncy pitches, didn't take into account that Even if Irfan succeeded he obviously due to age cannot participate in upcoming cups, he'd be injury prone.
In his career he also choose zulfiqar Ali Babar who made his debut at 37, again why? Ali was the worst spinner he was decent but dude wasn't making it to wc 2015 lol.
2) Decided to make rizwan and babar the opening duo on the basis of consistency because the dude looks at stat sheets and has no clue how impact works. Falhar's best score of 91 in t20 is at opening and it's a game pakistan dominated.
3) rather then developing a finisher and grooming one, he decided to take an already aged cricketer who obviously wouldn't function as a finisher long term or as an allrpunder. Chacha has not performed since 2020 lol.
Since Misbah came, the lack of experimentation and team building has gone down the drain.
The only relevant things in pakistan cricket that are working like Fakhar zaman at odi opening, Babar at 3 in odi, Shaheen's success uptil 2022 before his injury and regression, or agha salman performing whenever given the opportunity are all thanks to mickey really.
Nothing Misbah suggested has worked beyond B to c string success.