What's new

[VIDEOS/PICTURES] Mohammad Rizwan is arguably the best keeper in the world

That will be his downfall. He needs competition

Ups and downs are part of everyone’s life. I just expect well respected cricketers to deal with the game respectfully and do the right thing. I respect Australian cricket for this. For a long time, i believe they’ve really honoured the game by playing it the right away except for the sledging part which could be down to culture no judging. Rizwan and Babar must show more intent with the bat being senior and capable batters. If they attack and fail it’s forgiven, but not trying cannot be justified.
 
Ups and downs are part of everyone’s life. I just expect well respected cricketers to deal with the game respectfully and do the right thing. I respect Australian cricket for this. For a long time, i believe they’ve really honoured the game by playing it the right away except for the sledging part which could be down to culture no judging. Rizwan and Babar must show more intent with the bat being senior and capable batters. If they attack and fail it’s forgiven, but not trying cannot be justified.
PK players generally fall away if there isn't the competition. Our WKs in particular only perform when there is someone breathing down their neck. Moin Khan was awful as WK until RL Came, and even then his WK only improved to the level of FC players, Kami was good until he had no competition and then his love for food and a finger injury made him into a joke and although Sarfi was good throughout his career, he would have been even better if Riz had put on some more heat.
 
they’re just winding you up best to ignore them. they are all trolls been watching them for a while best not fall for it. Rizwan is doing a good job for his country
They actually believe what they write. The problem is that the wreck any intelligent debate with their hate and my personality, as it is, cannot let that to go by. Watch them squeal as I take them on at their own game.
 
I think Bari deserves a mention here. Though he was a poor bat.

It's so difficult to compare keepers across eras because the game has changed so much.

In the era of WK batsmen it's definitely Rizwan. We have only really had Rizwan, Sarfraz and Kami.

In terms of pure gloves work Rizwan is solid also.
 
PK players generally fall away if there isn't the competition. Our WKs in particular only perform when there is someone breathing down their neck. Moin Khan was awful as WK until RL Came, and even then his WK only improved to the level of FC players, Kami was good until he had no competition and then his love for food and a finger injury made him into a joke and although Sarfi was good throughout his career, he would have been even better if Riz had put on some more heat.

Yes for sure.
I think same applies to Pant. Right now some have already crowned him as GOAT Bharatiya wk batsman in tests and he’s getting out playing silly shots.
 
South africa

Odi: Henrich Klaseen 43 avg, 116 SR, 4 centuries, 57 games. He doesn't prefer to play test but in fc he avg 46, has 12 centuries.

Odi: Butler 39 avg, 11 centuries, 117 SR, test Jamie smith, 9 test, 42 avg, 1 century. Jamie smith made it to icc test team of the year.


Test: Pant: 42 avg 6 test century, Odi: Rahul 49avg: 7 odi centuries.

Rizwan Test: 40 avg, 3 centuries all in home den, 0 overseas centuries.

Odi 41 avg, 3 centuries, 83 games, 88 SR.

Yet somehow Rizwan is the best? Okay.

Rizwan’s most impressive achievement is that he's found a way to be statistically better then aussie keepers because even though Carey won a wtc for his country, Carey plays on bilo bounce pitches while rizzu before aqib played on phattas. It's good that on these Aqib pitches rizzu avg 19.
Nowadays, Rizwan is the best “wicket keeper only” for these guys. Wait for a little 50 and then they will also add “wicket keeper batsman” to his title of being the best
 
Nowadays, Rizwan is the best “wicket keeper only” for these guys. Wait for a little 50 and then they will also add “wicket keeper batsman” to his title of being the best
What even is best wicket keeper? I can only think of Mark Boucher being an exception because he was godly behind the stumps.

Don't get me wrong their have been great keepers like Dhoni who had that throwing ability, Sanga who would typically run pre maturely to give himself more room to dive and catch edges etc.

But they were all proper batsmen. Boucher is the only exception where I wouldn't mind playing him at no 8 just for his glovework alone.
 
Nowadays, Rizwan is the best “wicket keeper only” for these guys. Wait for a little 50 and then they will also add “wicket keeper batsman” to his title of being the best
No. Generally accepted. Only some moron that knows as much about cricket as Stevie Wonder would debate this.
 
South africa

Odi: Henrich Klaseen 43 avg, 116 SR, 4 centuries, 57 games. He doesn't prefer to play test but in fc he avg 46, has 12 centuries.

Odi: Butler 39 avg, 11 centuries, 117 SR, test Jamie smith, 9 test, 42 avg, 1 century. Jamie smith made it to icc test team of the year.


Test: Pant: 42 avg 6 test century, Odi: Rahul 49avg: 7 odi centuries.

Rizwan Test: 40 avg, 3 centuries all in home den, 0 overseas centuries.

Odi 41 avg, 3 centuries, 83 games, 88 SR.

Yet somehow Rizwan is the best? Okay.

Rizwan’s most impressive achievement is that he's found a way to be statistically better then aussie keepers because even though Carey won a wtc for his country, Carey plays on bilo bounce pitches while rizzu before aqib played on phattas. It's good that on these Aqib pitches rizzu avg 19.
He is the best WK. No one comes close to him on spinning tracks and excellent when standing back. You are confusing WK batsman with Wicket keeping. Riz is a solid batsman, but he is our best player of spin and all round solid player. Now let's discuss his replacement- the guy whose name is advocate has forgotten and a guy that you advocated but can't even get into the A team on a regular basis 😅😅😇
 
He is the best WK. No one comes close to him on spinning tracks and excellent when standing back. You are confusing WK batsman with Wicket keeping. Riz is a solid batsman, but he is our best player of spin and all round solid player. Now let's discuss his replacement- the guy whose name is advocate has forgotten and a guy that you advocated but can't even get into the A team on a regular basis 😅😅😇
Saud shakeel is Pakistan's best player of spin and saim + fakhar in odi play spin better then rizwan.

Secondly why do you switch the topic towards asking who rizwan's replacement is in Pakistan when the topic is about proving why rizwan is the best keeper via glovework.

I asked what metrics you're using and you still can't answer.

For example I'm claiming bpucher is the best wk in terms of glovework all time because he has the most number of stumping, catches, boundary saves etc.

You just cry nonstop without presenting any arguments.
 
Amazing player in tests, good in Odis but extremely mediocre in t20s.

On wicketkeeping skills alone he is the best in the world.

A keeper averaging 40+ in tests along with great keeping abilities is an invaluable asset.

In odis, he can play run a ball innings and is a good chaser. In wc 2023 he played an amazing innings vs SriLanka, even in Asia cup he did well against Bangladesh.

He lacks the 5th gear and will never be able to smash bowlers at will even when he is full set.
 
Very dependable batter but really needs to work on finishing which is where he is still poor and most of his criticism is a result of that.
 
Saud shakeel is Pakistan's best player of spin and saim + fakhar in odi play spin better then rizwan.

Secondly why do you switch the topic towards asking who rizwan's replacement is in Pakistan when the topic is about proving why rizwan is the best keeper via glovework.

I asked what metrics you're using and you still can't answer.

For example I'm claiming bpucher is the best wk in terms of glovework all time because he has the most number of stumping, catches, boundary saves etc.

You just cry nonstop without presenting any arguments.
OK. I think Saud is very good player of spin and he maybe be better, but Riz is also an excellent player of spin. He is our best WK- he is amongst the best WKs in the World( in my opinion the best). Where does that leave you guys. In your desperate hate, you want to drop amongst the few World class players we have. That makes a lot of sense to guys that have little or no knowledge of cricket but not to real PK cricket fans.
 
I don’t understand all this hate or undue criticism of Rizwan. Yes don’t big him up but he is a decent wicket keeper batsman for sure averaging 40 plus with the bat in all three formats. His keeping is tidy if not supreme (rarely drops catches or misses stumpings) + made runs in South Africa and against Windies. He is not supposed to carry the batting and it is not his fault if the rest of our batting currently sucks.
 
OK. I think Saud is very good player of spin and he maybe be better, but Riz is also an excellent player of spin. He is our best WK- he is amongst the best WKs in the World( in my opinion the best). Where does that leave you guys. In your desperate hate, you want to drop amongst the few World class players we have. That makes a lot of sense to guys that have little or no knowledge of cricket but not to real PK cricket fans.
None of this is relevant.

You're on a forumn so if you'll claim that he's the best wk(by gloverwork) people will ask you why?

You need to stick to the point rather then diverting topics or making assumptions over and over.

3x this has happened that you've diverted the topic towards arguing for potential replacements.

Secondly when it comes to replacements Pakistan need to start investing and looking for one anyone. Rizzu is 32-33, he has around 3 to 6 years of cricket left in him give or take. If he goes past 38 he'll be a liability anyway.
 
None of this is relevant.

You're on a forumn so if you'll claim that he's the best wk(by gloverwork) people will ask you why?

You need to stick to the point rather then diverting topics or making assumptions over and over.

3x this has happened that you've diverted the topic towards arguing for potential replacements.

Secondly when it comes to replacements Pakistan need to start investing and looking for one anyone. Rizzu is 32-33, he has around 3 to 6 years of cricket left in him give or take. If he goes past 38 he'll be a liability anyway.
As I said it makes no difference what you and your Mochi friend say. Riz isn't going anywhere and is the best WK in international cricket. His WK to spinners is a work of art at times, and he is very good to pacers( with the weakness i have pointed out before)
 
Nowadays, Rizwan is the best “wicket keeper only” for these guys. Wait for a little 50 and then they will also add “wicket keeper batsman” to his title of being the think Rizwan should sayg to ko Rana ji maaf karna, ghalti maarey

Nowadays, Rizwan is the best “wicket keeper only” for these guys. Wait for a little 50 and then they will also add “wicket keeper batsman” to his title of being the best
I think Rizwan should say to you:

‘Mujh ko Rana ji maaf karna, ghalti maarey se ho gaye!!’

Please see my other post ..
 
Back
Top