What's new

Was Irfan Pathan snubbed from IPL 2025 commentary panel for carrying personal agendas against certain players?

Bhaag Viru Bhaag

Senior Test Player
Joined
Aug 20, 2013
Runs
27,745
The official commentary panel for the IPL 2025 was revealed on Friday and the name of former India allrounder Irfan Pathan – a regular feature in the past – has been missing. Now, a report claims that Pathan has been snubbed following complaints from a number of India cricketers who believe his critical comments aimed at them are personally motivated.

According to MyKhel, one player even blocked Pathan’s number on his phone reportedly irked at hearing the latter’s comments on him during the Australia series.

“Otherwise, his (Pathan’s) name would have been there. It’s been happening for the last two years as he was carrying his personal agendas against certain players and that didn’t go down well with the system," a source was quoted as saying by the website.

Pathan isn’t the first high-profile commentator to have been punished after complaints from the player. In the past the likes of Sanjay Manjrekar and Harsha Bhogale have lost out on commentary duties due to complaints from India cricketers not happy with their on-air views.

In 2020, Manjrekar was reportedly dropped from BCCI commentary panel for India’s ODI series against South Africa. The decision was taken following a series of controversial events in 2019 including a spat with fellow commentator Bhogale, taking dig at Sourav Ganguly and calling allrounder Ravindra Jadeja as a “bits and pieces player".

“I have always considered commentary as a great privilege, but never an entitlement. It is up to my employers whether they choose to have me or not & I will always respect that. Maybe BCCI has not been happy with my performance of late. I accept that as a professional," Manjrerkar had posted on X following the decision.

Just days before the start of IPL 2016, Bhogale was removed from the commentary roster without explanation.

“I still don’t know why I am not doing the IPL. I can accept the fact that people don’t like me. But I genuinely hope it isn’t because cricketers have complained about what I have to say," Bhogale wrote on his Facebook page following the development.

 
Who are these cricketers who refuse to accept criticism? And who was that cricketer who blocked Irfan after the Australia series? :inti

bill-hader-watching.gif
 
Serves irfan right. Guy was very immature.

My favourite commentator from India is Harsha Bhogle. The fact he never played cricket and the way he commentates i just love it
 
Serves irfan right. Guy was very immature.

My favourite commentator from India is Harsha Bhogle. The fact he never played cricket and the way he commentates i just love it
From the OP:

Pathan isn’t the first high-profile commentator to have been punished after complaints from the player. In the past the likes of Sanjay Manjrekar and Harsha Bhogale have lost out on commentary duties due to complaints from India cricketers not happy with their on-air views.

I think some of these Indian cricketers like Rohit and Kohli. They just can't accept criticism. Recently, there were reports that Rohit was unhappy with Gavaskar's criticism. :inti

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I may be wrong but I feel it's an Indian problem in general. Their fans also cannot digest criticism I've noticed.
Yes, that's true. They expect everyone to blindly praise India, and anyone who holds up a mirror is instantly labeled anti-Hindu or Pakistani. When they run out of arguments, they resort to derailing discussions. :facepalm :inti
 
Good riddance. Irfan will now have to find other ways to fit in. Atleast he won't be desperately trying too hard via the commentary box anymore.
 
Serves irfan right. Guy was very immature.

My favourite commentator from India is Harsha Bhogle. The fact he never played cricket and the way he commentates i just love it
Well, he was also snubbed by Star before due to some cricketers don't like criticism..
 
This thread is not for discussing the IPL or its matches because we have plenty of threads for that. Instead, this thread is about cricketers who are upset over criticism from Irfan Pathan, including the one who blocked him after being criticized during the Australia series. :kp

Can anyone guess who that cricketer might be? :inti
 
This thread is not for discussing the IPL or its matches because we have plenty of threads for that. Instead, this thread is about cricketers who are upset over criticism from Irfan Pathan, including the one who blocked him after being criticized during the Australia series. :kp

Can anyone guess who that cricketer might be? :inti
Was it Kohli? Or Rohit?
 
Serves irfan right. Guy was very immature.

My favourite commentator from India is Harsha Bhogle. The fact he never played cricket and the way he commentates i just love it

Harsha also faced some heat for comments on Virat in the past.
 
Why can't he be allowed personal likes or dislikes?

I think it’s beyond players. BCCI has a certain way of doing things. Irfan did nothing wrong but it’s just the way it is with BCCI. They’re a mysterious shadow organisation.
 
Why can't he be allowed personal likes or dislikes?

He had personal issues with players and he used the commentators box to spread that propoganda. Same with Manjrekar and Srikanth.

Gavaskar is a very vocal critic. Yet he doesn't bring personal agendas.
 
Just like some of the Indian posters here? They also can't stomach any criticism (even constructive ones). :inti
There’s a thin line between criticizing a player and targeting a player with bias. Sanjay Manjrekar, Irfan Pathan, and Robin Uthappa fall into the first category, they often criticism based on their personal likes and dislikes. On the other hand, Sunny G and Ganguly fall into the Second Category They don’t hesitate to call out a player, no matter how big the name, if the performance isn’t up to the mark.

Just a few days ago, Ganguly strongly criticized Rohit Sharma’s Test performances and his captaincy. Sunny G has also openly criticized both Kohli and Rohit on several occasions.

Harsha Bhogle tends to go a bit soft, almost like he’s giving the players a gentle massage.
Personally, I like Ravi Shastri and Sidhu.

Irfan Pathan once took a dig at Dhoni when his brother wasn’t picked, saying something along the lines of, “Age is just a number for some, and not for others,” when MSD was in the team.
 
Serves irfan right. Guy was very immature.

My favourite commentator from India is Harsha Bhogle. The fact he never played cricket and the way he commentates i just love it
I would rather listen to a child throwing a tantrum in a flight than Harsha. In fact, I would rather listen to my neighbours get at it and never get any my entire life than listen to Harsha Bhogle. The man is so poor but I’m actually surprised people actually rate him. India has some decent commentators but Harsha is far from being one of them.
 
Back
Top