What's new

Would you include Gordon Greenidge in an all-time Test XI as an opener?

Harsh Thakor

First Class Star
Joined
Oct 1, 2012
Runs
3,520
Post of the Week
2
There could be few more enthralling sights in cricketer or sport seeing Gordon Greenidge dissecting a bowling attack to pieces.Even the great Viv Richards has not treated a cricket ball with more contempt who held a bat like a bludgeon.Few batsmen ever combined destructive power with the technical correctness of Gordon ,like a bulldozer and surgeon rolled into one.Gordon blended the power of a boxer with the methodolgy of an architect.Rarely has an opening batsmen so clinically reduced opposing bowlers to dust,in the manner of a combing operation..Rarely have any batsmen blended attack and defence in such clinical execution.



What was remarkable was the speed with which he scored his runs and centuries and impact on the game.No opening batsmen or few batsmen came so close to emulating Barry Richards in full gear.In the view of Alec Bedser Greenidge batted more like Bradman than anyone he saw ,puling even the full length deliveries.Ted Dexter felt he was technically the best batsmen he ever saw.Whether cutting,driving,puling or hooking Greenidge would embezzle like a circus acrobat performing.





In 1984 at Lords when scoring an unbeaten 214,Greenidge took batting domination to regions of divinty or sublime,going blistering barnacles from the word go.That day English bowlers were reduced to complete submission,like a military troupe heading for abject surrender.In the manner of an army batallion launching a most scathing but organized or most clinical assault to grind its opponents to dust,Greenidge took his side home to famous win at cricket's mecca.I hardly have an adjective which could do justice to the sheer virtuousity of Greenidge's innings. in terms of intensity and technical skill. that day.In that series he averaged over,82 scoring another double century at Manchester.To me from 1984-87 Greenidge was the best batsmen in the world.



I can also never forget his contemptuous treatment of English bowlers when scoring 3 centuries in 1976,including a 134 out of 211 on almost difficult wicket at Leeds.I doubt any opening batsmen hit a cricket ball harder than Greenidge did in 1976,in England.On turning tracks in India.at his best in Australia averaging around 30.revelled averaging over 47 with 7 centuries.Rarely has any overseas opener displayed as much solidity or all-round skill as Greenidge in India .Sadly he was not at his best in Australia or against them averaging around 30.In New Zealand at his best he was a revelation scoring a double century in 1987.In 1st class cricket his 273 not out against Pakistan at Eastbourne in 1974 revealed batting skills at metaphysical proportions.Finally I have to mention his match-winning 226 scored-against Australia at Barbados in 1991.



In ODI's Gordon was amongst the 3 best batsmen of his time,and best opening batsmen.Responsible for West Indies wining the finals of the Benson and Hedges world series cup in Australia in 1979-80 .He held the record for the fastest century in al the county cricket competitions.



How did Greenidge compare with his contemporaries or other greats?Many cricketers selected Gordon in their all-time teams as an opener like Mike Brearley,Waqar Younus,Dean Jones or Alan Donald.Even if statistically or technically on the same pedestal Greenidge may have won more games than Sunil Gavaskar,with his great attacking instinct or ferocity.Greenidge averaged more than even Viv Richards in test wins and had a greater percentage of scoring centuries in match-wining games than Viv.Almost 70% of his aggregate runs contributed to winning causes in test matches and 14 of his 18 test centuries were scored in wins Imran Khan ranked Gordon amongst the best he ever bowled to and close to Viv..Greenidge got more votes in to be chosen for an all-time XI than either Barry Richards or Geoff Boycott.To me it was almost a dead heat between Sehwag,Gooch and Gordon.I would have Gordon accompanying Gavaskar in the 1980's and arguably accompanying Barry Richards in the 1970's.After Bary Richards no opening batsmen blended attacking agression with such technical precision.Hos final average of 44.58 and aggregate of 7558 runs in 108 tests and 184 innings not have done justice to his true stature

I would atleast place Greenidge amongst the 50 best cricketers of all.Unfairly John Woodcock,Geoff Armstrong and Cristopher Martin Jenkins have excluded Greenidge in their selection 100 best cricketers.Arguably Greenidge may rank above Gooch,Sehwag and Boycott or even David Gower and Clive Lloyd.Arguably only,Trumper, Hobbs,Hutton,Gavaskar and BarryRichards rank ahead of Gordon as an opening batsmen.
 
Not in an all time XI for me, well below the top tier of Hutton, Hobbs, Gavaskar, Trumper, Sutcliffe, Richards

Top 50-100 player of all time
With Boycott the best opener of the 70's, 80's although the two were seperated quite a bit
 
Not in an all time XI for me, well below the top tier of Hutton, Hobbs, Gavaskar, Trumper, Sutcliffe, Richards

Top 50-100 player of all time
With Boycott the best opener of the 70's, 80's although the two were seperated quite a bit

Inspite of having 14 match-winning centuries of his 18 overall and scoring 70% of his aggregate runs in winning causes?Was he not the closest to Barry Richards and a better match-winner than Boycott or Gavaskar?
 
Please come here [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=139595]Ab Fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] [MENTION=65183]freelance_cricketer[/MENTION] Was not Greenidge in the Barry Richards class and the best match-winning opener of his time?Atleast merits a place in 100 best cricketers of all which Writers like Woodcock,Jenkins and Armstrong denied?
 
No.

First All-time XI

Jack Hobbs
Sunil Gavaskar

Second All-time XI

Len Hutton
Barry Richards

Third All-time XI

Graeme Smith
Mathew Hayden

Then you will have Greenidge, Sehwag, Gooch, Boycott, Cook and so on.

His batting does reminds me a bit of Sehwag and Gayle mixed in it. He hits the bowl hard like Gayle does and those cut shots reminds of Viru.
 
No.

First All-time XI

Jack Hobbs
Sunil Gavaskar

Second All-time XI

Len Hutton
Barry Richards

Third All-time XI

Graeme Smith
Mathew Hayden

Then you will have Greenidge, Sehwag, Gooch, Boycott, Cook and so on.

His batting does reminds me a bit of Sehwag and Gayle mixed in it. He hits the bowl hard like Gayle does and those cut shots reminds of Viru.

Read Richard Sydenham's book where Greenidge has won more votes for an all-time XI than Barry Richards or even Hobbs.Sydenham himself chose Gordon in his all-time XI.Greenidge was after Barry Richards the most outstanding match-winner as an opener.
 
As much as I rate Sunil Gavaskar as a great test opening batsman , but if given a choice between Gavaskar and Greenidge for an opening slot - I would go for Greenidge.

Let me explain - individual batting averages alone don’t win you matches , take the case of Gavaskar and Greenidge , yes Gavaskar averages about 5 runs higher in every test innings - but if you can score 45 on average at the strike rate and destroying the confidence of the opposition bowling attack with your stroke play like Greenidge could , I would take that over 5 extra runs scored any day.

Greenidge even with an average of 5 runs less could put his team in a dominant and match winning position , where as Gavaskar clearly wasn’t that kind of batsman and not to discredit him because he clearly saved many matches from certain defeat for his team..
 
Read Richard Sydenham's book where Greenidge has won more votes for an all-time XI than Barry Richards or even Hobbs.Sydenham himself chose Gordon in his all-time XI.Greenidge was after Barry Richards the most outstanding match-winner as an opener.

Of course, he will. He grew up watching him and back then there was a bit of Western obsession in cricket.

Btw, I will chose Graeme Smith and Virender Sehwag over Barry Richards and Sunil Gavaskar as the most outstanding test match-winners as openers because of their legendary match winning knocks Vs England, Australia and Pakistan, Australia, Sri Lanka respectively.

Matthew Hayden and Alastair Cook are also up there for their legendary performance in 2001 India tour and 2012 tour respectively.
 
Last edited:
Inspite of having 14 match-winning centuries of his 18 overall and scoring 70% of his aggregate runs in winning causes?Was he not the closest to Barry Richards and a better match-winner than Boycott or Gavaskar?
Gavaskar was a tier above shown by their averages. All of Sutcliffe, Hobbs, Hutton, Gavaskar have fantastic records, moreso that Greenidge.
Richards is debatable for obvious reasons, but was shown to be a class above on the 1st class scene
Boycott has a better average despite playing in a weaker team within more bowler friendly conditions, so I rate him better. Close debate though h
 
Read Richard Sydenham's book where Greenidge has won more votes for an all-time XI than Barry Richards or even Hobbs.Sydenham himself chose Gordon in his all-time XI.Greenidge was after Barry Richards the most outstanding match-winner as an opener.

Must be a shocking book of Hobbs is rated below
Probably the 2nd greatest bat of all time and def the greatest opener
Hutton is also clearly above Greenidge
Can u define match winner to me?
 
Must be a shocking book of Hobbs is rated below
Probably the 2nd greatest bat of all time and def the greatest opener
Hutton is also clearly above Greenidge
Can u define match winner to me?

Batsmen who turns complexion of a game most or very impactful-Greenidge was the more attacking than Boycott or Gavaskar.
 
Batsman at opening position (min 5000 test runs ) sorted by Strike Rate.
[table=width: 500, class: grid, align: center]
[tr][td]Player [/td][td]Span [/td][td]Mat [/td][td]Runs [/td][td]Ave [/td][td]SR [/td][td]100 [/td][td]50 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]V Sehwag [/td][td]2002-2013 [/td][td]99 [/td][td]8207 [/td][td]50.04 [/td][td]83.1 [/td][td]22 [/td][td]30 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]DA Warner [/td][td]2011-2020 [/td][td]84 [/td][td]7205 [/td][td]49.68 [/td][td]73.16 [/td][td]24 [/td][td]30 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]ST Jayasuriya [/td][td]1994-2007 [/td][td]90 [/td][td]5932 [/td][td]41.48 [/td][td]65.84 [/td][td]13 [/td][td]25 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]CH Gayle [/td][td]2000-2014 [/td][td]99 [/td][td]7028 [/td][td]43.11 [/td][td]60.71 [/td][td]15 [/td][td]36 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]ML Hayden [/td][td]1994-2009 [/td][td]103 [/td][td]8625 [/td][td]50.73 [/td][td]60.1 [/td][td]30 [/td][td]29 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]GC Smith [/td][td]2002-2014 [/td][td]114 [/td][td]9030 [/td][td]49.07 [/td][td]59.85 [/td][td]27 [/td][td]36 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]JL Langer [/td][td]1993-2007 [/td][td]65 [/td][td]5112 [/td][td]48.22 [/td][td]57.91 [/td][td]16 [/td][td]18 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]ME Trescothick [/td][td]2000-2006 [/td][td]76 [/td][td]5824 [/td][td]43.78 [/td][td]54.51 [/td][td]14 [/td][td]29 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]MJ Slater [/td][td]1993-2001 [/td][td]74 [/td][td]5312 [/td][td]42.83 [/td][td]53.29 [/td][td]14 [/td][td]21 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]HH Gibbs [/td][td]1998-2008 [/td][td]68 [/td][td]5242 [/td][td]47.22 [/td][td]52.28 [/td][td]14 [/td][td]21 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]GA Gooch [/td][td]1978-1995 [/td][td]100 [/td][td]7811 [/td][td]43.88 [/td][td]49.96 [/td][td]18 [/td][td]41 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]CG Greenidge [/td][td]1974-1991 [/td][td]107 [/td][td]7488 [/td][td]45.1 [/td][td]49.1 [/td][td]19 [/td][td]34 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]AJ Strauss [/td][td]2004-2012 [/td][td]97 [/td][td]6741 [/td][td]40.85 [/td][td]49.03 [/td][td]20 [/td][td]27 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]AN Cook [/td][td]2006-2018 [/td][td]154 [/td][td]11845 [/td][td]44.86 [/td][td]46.93 [/td][td]31 [/td][td]55 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]JB Hobbs [/td][td]1908-1930 [/td][td]58 [/td][td]5130 [/td][td]56.37 [/td][td]46.65 [/td][td]14 [/td][td]27 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]DL Haynes [/td][td]1978-1994 [/td][td]116 [/td][td]7472 [/td][td]42.45 [/td][td]44.7 [/td][td]18 [/td][td]39 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]MS Atapattu [/td][td]1997-2007 [/td][td]79 [/td][td]5317 [/td][td]43.22 [/td][td]44.62 [/td][td]16 [/td][td]17 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]SM Gavaskar [/td][td]1971-1987 [/td][td]119 [/td][td]9607 [/td][td]50.29 [/td][td]43.97 [/td][td]33 [/td][td]42 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]G Kirsten [/td][td]1993-2002 [/td][td]84 [/td][td]5726 [/td][td]41.79 [/td][td]41.61 [/td][td]14 [/td][td]28 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]MA Taylor [/td][td]1989-1999 [/td][td]104 [/td][td]7525 [/td][td]43.49 [/td][td]41.48 [/td][td]19 [/td][td]40 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]WM Lawry [/td][td]1961-1971 [/td][td]67 [/td][td]5234 [/td][td]47.15 [/td][td]39.18 [/td][td]13 [/td][td]27 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]L Hutton [/td][td]1937-1955 [/td][td]76 [/td][td]6721 [/td][td]56.47 [/td][td]37.94 [/td][td]19 [/td][td]31 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]MA Atherton [/td][td]1990-2001 [/td][td]108 [/td][td]7476 [/td][td]39.14 [/td][td]37.63 [/td][td]16 [/td][td]45 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]G Boycott [/td][td]1964-1982 [/td][td]107 [/td][td]8091 [/td][td]48.16 [/td][td]35.53 [/td][td]22 [/td][td]42 [/td][/tr]
[tr][td]JG Wright [/td][td]1978-1993 [/td][td]80 [/td][td]5260 [/td][td]38.11 [/td][td]35.34 [/td][td]12 [/td][td]23 [/td][/tr]
[/table]
Gooch's higher SR is pretty surprising.
 
Close, but I’d go for Barry Richards and Victor Trumper.

So Greenidge is the second best Hampshire county opener of the 1970’s!
 
No, nowhere near all time x1.
I am not even sure if he is amongst the top 10 openers of all time.
Openers who were better than him(in no particular order)
1.Gavaskar
2.Hobbs
3.Hutton
4.Simpson
5.Edrich
6.Cook
7.Sutcliffe
8.Boycott
9.Gooch
10.Sehwag
11.Smith
12.Hayden
13.Barry richards
14.Glenn turner
15.Arthur Morris
16.Saeed anwar
He shouldn't even be in a conversation about all time x1.
 
No, nowhere near all time x1.
I am not even sure if he is amongst the top 10 openers of all time.
Openers who were better than him(in no particular order)
1.Gavaskar
2.Hobbs
3.Hutton
4.Simpson
5.Edrich
6.Cook
7.Sutcliffe
8.Boycott
9.Gooch
10.Sehwag
11.Smith
12.Hayden
13.Barry richards
14.Glenn turner
15.Arthur Morris
16.Saeed anwar
He shouldn't even be in a conversation about all time x1.

while I agree that he shouldn't be in the convo, he is better than Edrich, Cook, Hayden, Sehwag, Turner, Anwar amongst those blokes
 
Batsmen who turns complexion of a game most or very impactful-Greenidge was the more attacking than Boycott or Gavaskar.

They made more hundreds, and surely the number of runs, more than the speed, defines the impact in the vast majority of situations
 
while I agree that he shouldn't be in the convo, he is better than Edrich, Cook, Hayden, Sehwag, Turner, Anwar amongst those blokes

Maybe better than edrich,turner or anwar but i dont see how he was better than a revolutionary player like sehwag or even hayden and cook.
 
Maybe better than edrich,turner or anwar but i dont see how he was better than a revolutionary player like sehwag or even hayden and cook.

He has more rounded records than Sehwag, Hayden who have huge weaknesses in swinging conditions. Cook is close but for me the poor tail end to his career spoils it, only seen as an ATG due to longevity which I don't rate. Could see an argument for him being better than Greenidge though for people who value longevity
 
Not in an all time XI for me, well below the top tier of Hutton, Hobbs, Gavaskar, Trumper, Sutcliffe, Richards

Top 50-100 player of all time
With Boycott the best opener of the 70's, 80's although the two were seperated quite a bit

I'd go with that.

Personally find these discussions cringe worthy and disrespectful.

We should celebrity unique style.of every great cricketer instead of downplaying them with such comparisons.

Greenidge is iconic.
 
No, nowhere near all time x1.
I am not even sure if he is amongst the top 10 openers of all time.
Openers who were better than him(in no particular order)
1.Gavaskar
2.Hobbs
3.Hutton
4.Simpson
5.Edrich
6.Cook
7.Sutcliffe
8.Boycott
9.Gooch
10.Sehwag
11.Smith
12.Hayden
13.Barry richards
14.Glenn turner
15.Arthur Morris
16.Saeed anwar
He shouldn't even be in a conversation about all time x1.

I still disagree with you.Very few openers ever dominated bowling more or were aesthetically as complete.The game is not all about mere statistics.Wish to remind everyone that Greenidge averaged above 50 in seaming English conditions,which is remarkable.He averaged more in overseas tests than at home unlike many openers.72% of his runs came in wins and 14 of his 18 centuries were in winning causes.In ODI's he was an epitome og consistency.He has 4 double hundreds to his name unlike many batsmen,let alone openers.Greenidg .for a period even overshadowed Viv.

He alos although statistically not as good as Boycott or Gavaskar,he won more games than both of them.No opener played more like Barry and technically he was better than Gooch or Sehwag,Compare the bowling Gordon faced compared to Sehwag and performances against the moving ball.Greenidge was chosen in an all-time XI more than Boycott or Barry.

Kindly read the article of Mark Nicholas in Cricket monthly quoting Dexter and Bedser on Greenidge.Averaging around 45 in his ear is the equivalent of averaging around 51 today,.
 
I'd go with that.

Personally find these discussions cringe worthy and disrespectful.

We should celebrity unique style.of every great cricketer instead of downplaying them with such comparisons.

Greenidge is iconic.

Welldone,put it beautufully.Gordon was a genius.
 
They made more hundreds, and surely the number of runs, more than the speed, defines the impact in the vast majority of situations

Compare averages and no of centuries in wins.Greenidge beats Boycott and Gavaskar.I feel Gooch and Greenidge are almost equal.agree?Gooch better against genuine pace,Gordon better against the swinging ball.
 
while I agree that he shouldn't be in the convo, he is better than Edrich, Cook, Hayden, Sehwag, Turner, Anwar amongst those blokes

Counting all factors Hobbs,Barry,,Hutton,Gavaskar,Sutcliffe are ahead.It is touch and go between Gooch,Sehwag,Hanif Mohammad and Boycott but Geoff could be very selfish,even if better.Turner did not equal Greenidge in International cricket nor did Anwar.Also remember Greenidge played in ,a more challenging era than Sehwag.
 
Compare averages and no of centuries in wins.Greenidge beats Boycott and Gavaskar.I feel Gooch and Greenidge are almost equal.agree?Gooch better against genuine pace,Gordon better against the swinging ball.

That is a dumb statistic, as it could also be indicative of a player that does well primarily when his team mates have already succeeded. Given that he played for one of the GOAT teams alot of his runs are going to come in wins
 
Greenidge is an all time great of the game but not in the top 2 openers of all time.

I'd probably go with Hutton and Gavaskar.
 
There is an interesting selection policy for best XIs.
Do you pick your best two openers to open the batting? Or do you pick a better batsman, who spent most of their career at number 3 to open instead?

Logically any number 3, let alone someone in contention for an all time XI team, could open the batting if required.
 
There is an interesting selection policy for best XIs.
Do you pick your best two openers to open the batting? Or do you pick a better batsman, who spent most of their career at number 3 to open instead?

Logically any number 3, let alone someone in contention for an all time XI team, could open the batting if required.


I know this is philosophy of a lot of people but for me it's always been very awkward to imagine great #3 batsmen as openers. Just doesn't feel right.

Every batting position is unique in a way. Guess we should respect players based on their batting positions. Not fair on openers if they are replaced by #3s.

It's just a matter of one batting position for us but it is a whole different job and batting experience altogether for the cricketers.
 
Happy Birthday Gordon Greenidge (70 years): 5 Most Memorable Knocks of the West Indies Legend


Never in the game has there been a more destructive opening batsmen who not only revolutionised the game, but also sent chills down the bowlers’ spine with his flamboyance. Personifying that trait in word and spirit was Cuthbert Gordon Greenidge (born Cuthbert Gordon Greenidge). Born on May 1 in 1951 in the St. Peter Parish of, Barbados, the former West Indies cricketer with his naturally attacking game ripped apart even the best of the bowling attacks.

Greenidge had a legendary career in the first-class cricket, in which he scored a whopping 37,354 runs in 523 matches that include 92 hundreds and 183 fifties. He made his international Test debut for West Indies against India at Bangalore in 1974 and in a successful career in the long format of the game, he scored 7,558 runs from 108 matches that included 19 hundreds and 34 fifties.

In One-Day cricket after debuting against Pakistan at Birmingham in 1975, Greenidge scored an impressive 5,134 runs in 128 matches that include 11 hundreds. He retired from international cricket in 1991 and took up coaching assignment of the Bangladesh national cricket team in 1997.

As the legendary cricketer celebrates his special day, here’s a look at some memorable knocks:

107 vs India (1974)

Playing against India, Greenidge had a dream debut as he went on to score 93 in the first innings followed with a sublime 107 in the second innings in Test cricket. His knocks were crucial as the visitors won the Bangalore Test by 267 runs.

134 vs England (1976)

During the West Indies tour of England in 1976, the visitors could only make 211 in the first innings at Manchester. Greenidge scored 134 in the first innings, while the hosts folded theirs for 71. He went on to score 101 in the second innings. The West Indies eventually went on to win the Test by 425 runs. Greenidge scored 592 runs in the five-match series that included three centuries and two fifties.

100 vs Pakistan (1977)

During the Pakistan tour of West Indies, he replicated a similar streak against the visitors. He plundered 536 runs in five Tests to give his side a 2-1 win. In the fifth and final Test at Sabina Park, Greenidge scored a superb century in the first innings and the hosts won the match by 140 runs.

214 (not out) vs Eng (1984)

Scoring against his favourite team that too in their own backyard, Greenidge fell cheaply for 1 in the first innings at Lords. But he came back with a blistering double hundred in the second innings and with the help of Larry Gomes’ unbeaten 92, the duo guided the visitors to a nine-wicket victory.

226 vs Australia (1991)

The legendary opener’s supreme knock came under pressure that was the last milestone of an impressive career. Playing in what would be his penultimate Test match, Greenidge’s marathon 226 in the second innings took the game away from the Australians at Bridgetown. The West Indies won the match by nine-wickets.

https://www.news18.com/cricketnext/...knocks-of-the-west-indies-legend-3694049.html
 
Happy Birthday to the great, Gordon Greenidge.

Not only an impactful test opener but a great ODI opening batsman too.
 
Please come here [MENTION=7774]Robert[/MENTION] [MENTION=79064]MMHS[/MENTION] [MENTION=132916]Junaids[/MENTION] [MENTION=139595]Ab Fan[/MENTION] [MENTION=131701]Mamoon[/MENTION] [MENTION=65183]freelance_cricketer[/MENTION] Was not Greenidge in the Barry Richards class and the best match-winning opener of his time?Atleast merits a place in 100 best cricketers of all which Writers like Woodcock,Jenkins and Armstrong denied?

No, because he had a mediocre record against Lillee. Averaged low thirties IIRC.

I’d go for two of Hobbs, Hutton and Gavaskar.
 
I tell a lie, he averaged 59 against Australia in WI, and 31 away.
 
Tribute to Gordon Greenidge on turning 70-How great a batsman ?

On May 1st we celebrated the 70th birthday of one of the greatest batsman of all time. It is also thirty years since this cricketing colossus retired from the game with a fitting finale. On his day Gordon Greenidge took batting domination to magnitude rarely surpassed and looked the ultimate epitome of perfection. Possibly no batsman in his day hit a ball harder as Gordon, who held a bat like a club. Few batsman ever executed more dazzling pull or hook shots, with Gordon posessing the ferocious power of a tiger.Greenidge was also technical correctness personified displaying exemplary balance, footwork and head positioning. At his best he would crucify bowling attacks like a tiger tearing flesh but still displayed the grammar of an English professor. and solidity of a boulder. Few opening batsman dissected opponents in such clinical fashion, or bissected the field with such impetuosity, or treated a cricket ball with such contempt. Often Greenidge reminded me of a combustion engine or an army performing a combing operation when he desecrated opposition. In full flow I have rarely seen a cricketer so majestic with the pugnacity of a lion. Gordon’s intensity resembled the smouldering of iron in a coal fire. .Gordon’s very arrival on the crease could ignite a spark or even convert it into a prairie fire like few batsman.




Greenidge's life story is most touching when one reads about his school day sin England, where he migrated at the game of fourteeen.Most acutely he was a victim to the wrath of racism prevailing and was time and again bullied. At first he was even excluded from the school cricket team. It was the very suffering that mustered the adrenalin in Gordon to come out of adversity bad soon he gave glimpses of his glittering potential in school cricket. It is ironic that Greenidge chose to play for West Indies, after his upbringing in England and integrating so much to the English way of life.His autobiography ‘The man in the middle’ is a must-read for all sports lovers.

In 1974 when playing for Hampshire against the touring Pakistan team Greenidge took batting virtuosity to regions of the sublime scoring an unbeaten 273. It was reminiscent of a sculptor carving a monument.


In his very debut in India at Bangalore in 1974-75 he proved his mettle scoring 93 and 107 on a turning track. However he was hardly impactful for the remainder of the series.

Greenidge sadly did not come to terms with the ferocity of the pace of Denis Lillee and Jeff Thomson in 1975-76 in Australia, and became a victim of sledging and psychological intimidation. In his autobiography Greenidge attributed the blame for West Indies 5-1 defeat to the bad umpiring.Neverthless the setback was blessing in disguise for Gordon as it lit the spark of vengeance within him and taught him important lessons. It is significant how in his autobigroaphy Gordon recounts how only from penetrating the depths of despair can glory be achieved.

In 1976 in England Greenidge was simply a revelation. I can’t remember an opening batsman with such a blistering strike rate till then playing in England in attest series. Even if eclipsed by Viv Richards who was a virtual incarnate of Bradman in that series,Greenidge revealed skill of an overseas opening batsman at a magnitude not seen for decades in England, with the exception of Barry Richards. His 134 out of 211 at Leeds would rank amongst the best ever innings on bad wicket by nay batsman let alone an opener. I doubt till then nay overseas batsman hit a cricket all harder than a Gordon,who reminded one of an executioner punishing a convict.Greenidge's batting was the fulcrum on which Viv Richards capitalised and gave a platform for their offensive .He amassed 592 runs at an average of 65.77 with three centuries.The 3-0 triumph on that tour was one of West Indian cricket's most defining moments.


In 1977 playing against Pakistan at home Greenidge topped the averages,being a model of consistency. His batting prayed an important role in shaping a West Indies 2-1 win in a hard fought series. Rarely has an batsman combated the fiery Imran Khan at his fastest on fast track as Gordon did at Kingston.I can’t forget Imran’s word stating how difficult it was to bowl to Geenidge.Gordon scored 536 runs at an average of 53.6.


In Packer cricket he underlined why he was ranked so highly when he scored a whirling 140 in 1977-78.In several junctures he gave flashes of the reserves of talent he endowed ,taking the likes of Dennis Lillee and Imran Khan to the sword. He averaged only around thirty five, but against pace that was most hostile.


He lost form from 1979-80 to 1983 in test cricket, even if scoring the occasional fifty.
In 1983 against India at home he made a blistering return to for, ressurecting his best days. He averaged over 78, scoring 393 runs with big hundreds at Barbados and Antigua. On the 1983-84 tour of India he scored match-winning 194 at Kanpur, but was inconsistent in the remaining tests.

In 1984 at home against Australia he was an epitome of consistency/ and gave the impetus to a triumphant West Indies team. Ironically his run aggregate and batting average was exactly what it was against India a season ago ,at home. .I wonder whether this has ever happened before in history of test cricket. Duplicate figures as against India of 393 runs at 78.60.

.It was in England in 1984 that Greenidge took batting to dimensions of magnitude only geniuses did. In that period I personally rate Gordon as the best batsman in the world. In the 2nd test at Lords his unbeaten 214 in match winning chase in the fourth inning s had overtones of a hurricane or combing operation of an army. I have never witnessed a more clinical display of attacking strokeplay, resembling a computerized machine or a surgical operation..Greenidge simply went blistering barnacles. Every scoring stroke further tightened a noose on the opponents, like a neck being strangulated by a rope. Arguably the best innings ever by a West Indian batsman in England in a test match. At Old Trafford he scored 223, which was more sedate than the knock at Lords but still revealed batting prowess of the highest degree. He average 81.71 with an aggregate of 572 runs. In that series. Above all Greenidge was arguably the most defining character in West Indies triumphing 5-0 and now being ranked as the bets test team of all time.


Gordon was not at his best in Australia in 1984-85, apart from the odd big score
.In 1986 in Pakistan Greenidge gave a revelation of his great skill on turning tracks with match-winning knock in the 2nd test at Lahore.


In 1987 in New Zealand Gordon scored a brilliant 211,which took batting mastery to region s of the sublime.

On the 1987-88 tour of India Greenidge scored a masterly 141 at Calcutta ,and displayed his great technical maturity on turning tracks.

Against Pakistan at home he only gave occasional flashes of his brilliance. In 1988 in England he looked past his best apart from a classical 103 at Lords.
. He again failed in Australia in 1988-89 .He relatively failed in home series in 1989 against India and 1990 against England.

In the 1991 Frank Worrell trophy at home he ressurected himself in a Muhammad Ali style manner in the 4th test at Barbados ,scoring a match-winning 226.The manner he compiled that innings could be a separate chapter of a book. Spirit of vengeance was simply taken to a boiling point, like a phoenix rising from the Ashes. It was reminiscent of some alien spirit infused within him. Above all it won West Indies the test and the title of unofficial world test champions.Noone could have been a better example of cometh the hour,cometh the man.


In one day cricket Greenidge was amongst the three best batsman of his time .In 1979-80 he top scored in the finals Benson and Hedges triangular world series cricket tournament and earlier was the leading scorer in the 1979 prudential World cup. In many ways Gordon was the architect of the West Indies triumph sin triangular tournaments in Australia on five occasions in his time, as well as one day series in India .

Few batsman ever had a greater penchant for hitting sixes as Greenidge .In One day country tournaments in the late 1970’s he had the record scores for all of them.


Overall Greenidge scored 7558 run sat an average of 44.72 and 18 centuries. In 108 tests and 184 innings. However more than mere statistics it was his contribution towards the stature of West Indies cricket into the greatest cricketing superpower of all time. Gordon was an integral par of a combustion engine. With Desmond Haynes he constituted the best opening pair ever in test cricket. In ODI cricket Greenidge scored 5134 runs with 11 centuries at an average of 45.03

It is noteworthy that in winning causes in test matches Greenidge averaged above 54, which is more than Even Viv Richards in tests won.14 out of Gordon's 18 test centuries were in winning causes and around 60 % of his run aggregate, In his day in terms of match winning percentage in tests in run aggregate and centuries Greenidge was the best West Indies and opening batsman of his time. In that respect he even overshadowed the great Viv Richards.



No opening batsman was closer to Barry Richards in blending technical skill with attacking agression.Greenidge possessed the power of a bomber plane fused with the skill of a surgeon. Former great batsman Ted Dexter ranks Greenidge as technically the best batsman he ever saw and so did the late Alec Bedser. Arguably if you assess technique ,Greenidge may have even been a more consummate batsman than Viv Richards or Brian Lara.


One pitfall in Gordon was his relative lack of success in Australia on five tours .It is also debatable whether Gordon would have been prolific facing his own team's lethal pace attack. I doubt whether Greenidge chased records or did justice to his true potential. It is possible that playing for such a powerful team did not completely keep the adrelanin flowing. I have strong conviction that Gordon would have averaged around 50 if he did justice to his full potential.



To me between 1984-87 Greenidge earned the title of the best batsman in the world, eclipsing even Viv Richards, Gavaskar,Miandad or Border..I would select Greenidge as a opener in my World test eleven if the 1980's as he won more games than the record -breaking Gavaskar and was more consistent than Graham Gooch..Fittingly in Richard Sydenham's selection of 100 all-time test xi's, 26 former cricketers have chosen Greenidge. He has overshadowed even the likes of Barry Richards or Jack Hobbs in capturing votes for selection.


I think most unjustly Greenidge has been excluded from the selection of 100 best cricketers of all time by adjudicators in books like Cristopher Martin Jenkins, John Woodcock and Geoff Armstrong.

Amongst opening batsman to me only Jack,Hobs,Len Hutton,Sunil Gavaskar ,Victor Trumper and Barry Richards rate ahead of Greenidge ,who I rate virtually on par with Graham Gooch.No opening batsman won more test matches for a side as Gordon. An all-time great batsman without question. Without doubt Greenidge was one of the architects in shaping West Indies into the best test side of all time.

Sadly after his retirement in 1991 West Indies cricket lost it's mantle or citadel .It reminded one of the fall of a great empire which was unable to ressurect it's glory. After retirement Greenidge served as a coach for teams like Bangladesh.


His moments of cricketing glory would carve a permanent niche in a cricket museum and memories flicker forever like an inextinguishable flame. Even for youngsters today watching his video tapes is like a lesson of a coaching manual. Characters like Gordon are an embodiment of the spirit of the Afro-American race which launched a moral crusade for dignity.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">We honour Gordon Greenidge on <a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/ICCHallOfFame?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#ICCHallOfFame</a>, one of the greatest openers that ever played ✨<br><br>More &#55357;&#56573;️ <a href="https://t.co/lF1xXv4fJv">https://t.co/lF1xXv4fJv</a> <a href="https://t.co/PPaUbTT4ir">pic.twitter.com/PPaUbTT4ir</a></p>— ICC (@ICC) <a href="https://twitter.com/ICC/status/1397590938646614017?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">May 26, 2021</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
I believe only 2 places are up for a discussion for the ATG Test XI.

1. Gavaskar
2. ***********
3. Bradman
4. Tendulkar
5. Sobers
6. ***********
7. Gilchrist



In my opinion, Greenidge is legendary and is part of a genuine discussion on who gets to go out there to open alongside Sunny Gavaskar.

Personally speaking, i am.a fan of his batting and would really love to see them pair up.
 
I believe only 2 places are up for a discussion for the ATG Test XI.

1. Gavaskar
2. ***********
3. Bradman
4. Tendulkar
5. Sobers
6. ***********
7. Gilchrist



In my opinion, Greenidge is legendary and is part of a genuine discussion on who gets to go out there to open alongside Sunny Gavaskar.

Personally speaking, i am.a fan of his batting and would really love to see them pair up.

Greenidge is a great ODI opener too :vk
 
My ATG test XI:-

Gavaskar
G Smith(c)
Bradman
Tendulkar
S Smith
G Sobers
Gilchrist (wkt)
Wasim
Warne
Marshall
McGrath
 
Nah , Gavaskar and Hutton for me , Greenidge has a stronger argument for one day XI
 
Openers by Tier :-

Tier 1 - Hobbs

Tier 1.5 - Gavaskar, Hutton

Tier 2 - Sutcliffe

Tier 3- Greenidge, G Smith, Hayden, Sehwag, Gooch , Boycott, Cook, Merchant, Hanif

Tier 3.5 - Haynes, Kirsten, Warner, Anwar, Taylor and many more
 
Gordon averaged 17 in Pakistan and 30 in Australia so while a great opener, not sure whether he can be put in the same category as Gavaskar or Hutton.
 
No, no. His partner Desmond Haynes would have a better chance of getting in an ATG test side then GG. Muddy Nazar was a good opener as well albeit very boring to watch:usman Lets not forget the dashing Saeed Anwar too who is worthy of consideration.
 
It's interesting to see the Sehwag comparisons and then people are shocked when they see GG's SR of around 50. All very normal.

The Sehwag/GG comparisons are made because there were days when GG did thrash an attack to all parts. He could do it. And at times, he might go on all out attack. And there are several well remembered innings in that style.

But it wasn't his normal batting style. He was a "proper" opener with a great defence who just had a bunch of gears and the lurking threat that he could take the bowling apart.

Cricket was slower then, batting for draws more normal. WI drew a lot of matches due to strong batting. They didn't draw them by having a happy go lucky thrasher at opener.

It wasn't possible in those days before oversized bats and body armour to bat that way for any length of time and have success. Certainly not as an opener.
 
Openers by Tier :-

Tier 1 - Hobbs

Tier 1.5 - Gavaskar, Hutton

Tier 2 - Sutcliffe

Tier 3- Greenidge, G Smith, Hayden, Sehwag, Gooch , Boycott, Cook, Merchant, Hanif

Tier 3.5 - Haynes, Kirsten, Warner, Anwar, Taylor and many more
Hobbs shouldn't be far ahead of Hutton , Hutton faced better bowlers and his ashes reclaimation after 2 decades was a Legendary achievement , his record even after he came back from a 7 year war and the war time injury is far too flawless for Hobbs to match
 
Greenidge was very versatile in batting , could play a sehwag esque 214 out of 242 and then a test later make 230 out of 425 , all in English conditions as an opener
 
Yeah, the bowlers had it easy in that era.

I found it a little bit more enjoyable to watch- but I was just a boy. Caught the end of the era when Viv & Richie Richardson didn't wear helmets and there was a touch more fear from quicks.

You still see it though occasionally, if a quick has a Johnson like period.
 
Back
Top