We’re actually on the same page—I’m just trying to push toward clarity. You’re saying one day some players will replace them, but how does that day actually arrive? What steps does Pakistan cricket need to take to develop players who can play the modern game?
It will happen, it’s the circle of life.
Babar and Rizwan still have 4-5 years left and by the time they are on their last legs, Pakistan will have another batch of players and there will be a couple of them who will be of good quality, like Babar and Rizwan were.
Pakistan produced Miandad, Inzamam, Yousuf, Younis and then Babar. They will produce more batsmen too, maybe not as frequently as other countries but they still will.
Same goes for WKs too. Sarfaraz replaced Akmal who replaced Moin/Latif. Rizwan replaced Sarfaraz and someone will replace him across formats but that someone is not Haris.
If people are tired of Babar and Rizwan, that is fine. There is no denying they have been underwhelming and for very long, but, you can’t force inferior players down our throats just because you are tired of them.
We have seen enough of Haris since 2022 to come to the conclusion that just like Azam Khan, he is not good enough to replace Rizwan as Pakistan’s WK.
Similarly, you watch Farhan bat and the way he moves his feet makes it glaringly obvious that he isn’t someone who can replace Babar.
Pakistan must accept that for all their faults and shortcomings, Babar and Rizwan still make the team on pure merit. We cannot deny this. That doesn’t mean that we should neglect their failures or not demand them to improve.
Let me put it this way — Pakistan has not yet reached a point where they can drop both of them and expect the team to be stronger. It will happen one day, but not today.
PCB will die on this hill and it will die very soon. They will both be back very soon and rightly so.