What's new

Is Sachin Tendulkar really the epitome of cricket integrity?

R

Railu Katta

Tape Ball Star
Joined
Nov 6, 2016
Runs
733
We often hear that cricket is a gentleman's game and how Tendulkar was an honest man. But is that really the truth? Was his career blemish free?

I would disagree because he was caught ball tampering and then he also gave a false statement to protect Harbhajan.

A ball tamperer is definitely not the epitome of integrity to me!! Please discuss.
 
That would be Rahul Dravid, most people would consider Rahul ahead in that matter.
 
SandyB said:
That would be Rahul Dravid, most people would consider Rahul ahead in that matter.
Click to expand...

I agree but why is it that in the media it's always the ball tamperer that gets all the adulation. Dravid was a better human being and a better cricketer than the ball tamperer.
 
Yeah lets ignore that ball scratching incident :srt
 
Too bad we didn't have dozens of cameras back in the 80/90 decade, a lot of the so called greats would be much less great(er) today. Of course everyone knows who they are & what they did, heck the Windians beat the daylights out of them, when they used the same tactics.
 
Last edited:
Railu Katta said:
I agree but why is it that in the media it's always the ball tamperer that gets all the adulation. Dravid was a better human being and a better cricketer than the ball tamperer.
Click to expand...

Sachin was was never convicted of ball tampering. While Dravid was convicted of ball tampering. This is hilarious.
 
Hitman said:
Sachin was was never convicted of ball tampering. While Dravid was convicted of ball tampering. This is hilarious.
Click to expand...
Sachin was shown to be clearly lifting the seam with his fingers in the footage.
 
As for giving a false statement to protect Harbhajan, how does anyone know that what he said is false? :))
 
Ball tampering should be allowed anyways. Even the English used mint in 05’ to get reverse swing. But you don’t hear that do ya?
 
ManFan said:
Sachin was shown to be clearly lifting the seam with his fingers in the footage.
Click to expand...

That's not even the point I was making. Will get to that later. It was about the OP making laughable claims about his hero being a saint and accusing others of doing things for which his hero was himself convicted of.
 
hahahhaha after all he is human....but one thing i found strange and a bit sorry to say but tnedulkar should have congratulated pakistan on CT win.not related to his career though.
 
DRsohail said:
hahahhaha after all he is human....but one thing i found strange and a bit sorry to say but tnedulkar should have congratulated pakistan on CT win.not related to his career though.
Click to expand...

I don't think he can because of political pressure currently between two countries.
 
Railu Katta said:
We often hear that cricket is a gentleman's game and how Tendulkar was an honest man. But is that really the truth? Was his career blemish free?

I would disagree because he was caught ball tampering and then he also gave a false statement to protect Harbhajan.

A ball tamperer is definitely not the epitome of integrity to me!! Please discuss.
Click to expand...

Both allegations are false.
 
Yes he is

He played almost 2 and half decades cricket and hardly involved in any allegations if not any

A true roll model in and off the field

I would have select amla too,his gesture to not endorse any alcohol brand on his jersey was prodigious.Later many cricketers followed the way
 
Its remarkable how a boring individual like him got so much fame, money, adulation.

Kohli is a lot more interesting and marketable.
 
Savak said:
Its remarkable how a boring individual like him got so much fame, money, adulation.

Kohli is a lot more interesting and marketable.
Click to expand...
Unfortunately, this notion that acha bachas are the epitome of cricket was head strong in those days and still today. More than anything, it was Sachins run making that drew worldwide audiences. He was so smooth at the crease and the only Indian cricketer who was world class in the 90’s. That’s why I love cricketers like Kholi or Warne. Guys who aren’t afraid to go the extra mile to succeed. Sachin for all his numbers was just that, numbers. Not as impactful as a DK or Richards, not as tough as a Border or Waugh, not as exciting as a Lara or Akram but simply Kallis with the hint of Indian flare for 24 years.
 
Is the most ironic event ever taking
Place on this thread right now :))

Pakistani fans taking a moral high ground on ball tampering...and just to be clear alleged ball tampering in this case.
 
blue_champion said:
Is the most ironic event ever taking
Place on this thread right now :))

Pakistani fans taking a moral high ground on ball tampering...and just to be clear alleged ball tampering in this case.
Click to expand...

When and where did any Pakistani poster deny ball tampering? Fact of the matter is tendulkar is a cheat that got caught tampering the ball. I am sorry if it hurts your feelings but it's the truth.
 
Whatever the issue, Sachin was never involved in Fixing and doping. Ball tampering was an allegation at that time even with the video available. Lying for Bhajji shouldn't be counted, since any teammate or patriot would've done that. Knowing about Azhar fixing shouldn't be included in the crime, since Sachin wasn't the one fixing.

All in all, he was indeed a true gentleman of the game.
 
Railu Katta said:
When and where did any Pakistani poster deny ball tampering? Fact of the matter is tendulkar is a cheat that got caught tampering the ball. I am sorry if it hurts your feelings but it's the truth.
Click to expand...

Ok and the point you are trying to make is???

Firstly did tampering the ball give Sachin an advantage in what he accomplished? I don’t think so unless you have a unique take on it.

Now coming to him being the epitome of integrity...is there something that happened recently, I missed that triggered you?

Anyway we are able to separate our cricketing heroes from their on field and off field shenanigans...even the most hardcore of Sachin fans criticized his Rajya Sabha attendance...it is not like we are blindly going to ask him to be the prime minister and save us.

So Again I fail to understand the purpose of this thread.

If your intention is to straightforward to just troll and have a couple of laughs at the expense of
Someone who may get offended then ok
Power to you...apart from that don’t see the purpose of this.
 
ahmedzee said:
Whatever the issue, Sachin was never involved in Fixing and doping. Ball tampering was an allegation at that time even with the video available. Lying for Bhajji shouldn't be counted, since any teammate or patriot would've done that. Knowing about Azhar fixing shouldn't be included in the crime, since Sachin wasn't the one fixing.

All in all, he was indeed a true gentleman of the game.
Click to expand...

blue_champion said:
Ok and the point you are trying to make is???

Firstly did tampering the ball give Sachin an advantage in what he accomplished? I don’t think so unless you have a unique take on it.

Now coming to him being the epitome of integrity...is there something that happened recently, I missed that triggered you?

Anyway we are able to separate our cricketing heroes from their on field and off field shenanigans...even the most hardcore of Sachin fans criticized his Rajya Sabha attendance...it is not like we are blindly going to ask him to be the prime minister and save us.

So Again I fail to understand the purpose of this thread.

If your intention is to straightforward to just troll and have a couple of laughs at the expense of
Someone who may get offended then ok
Power to you...apart from that don’t see the purpose of this.
Click to expand...

It doesn't matter if he achieved anything from the ball tampering. It's a form of cheating and hence he's a cheat. They can use other examples to talk about cricket integrity i.e. Misbah.
 
Lol... Tendulkar was punished for cleaning the ball without Umpire's permission and not ball tampering. That is the fact of the issue. ICC even released a press statement about this.

Creating a mountain out of a molehill or to be more precise, creating a thread out of nothing.
 
Oligochaetes said:
Lol... Tendulkar was punished for cleaning the ball without Umpire's permission and not ball tampering. That is the fact of the issue. ICC even released a press statement about this.

Creating a mountain out of a molehill or to be more precise, creating a thread out of nothing.
Click to expand...

Correct.
Even the other allegation is false.
 
He was clearly guilty of tampering, got into scuffles with his captains albeit behind closed doors, apparently cared more for his personal records than his team's results and he has never been a consistent walker.

Definitely not the "epitome of integrity" but he was no crook either. One of the more well-behaved cricket superstars.
 
Yes, he was one of the great gentleman to play this game. Imagine, playing for Two and half decade and yet people resorting to half cooked allegations to implicate you. One of the greatest on and off the field. Absolute gem of a person.
 
1.Tendulkar was acquitted to Ball tampering charges.Thats the ICC ruling.Anything wont change that.

2.Who lied and who didnot lie in the Bhajji case isnt known.

people questioning Sachin's acquittal by icc must remember that the icc also acquitted Inzy and the Pakistani team of tampering charges in 2006.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Out of the blue, without any context, we are discussing the integrity of a cricketer like SRT on a Pakistani discussion forum.

I have seen it all.
 
Oligochaetes said:
Lol... Tendulkar was punished for cleaning the ball without Umpire's permission and not ball tampering. That is the fact of the issue. ICC even released a press statement about this.

Creating a mountain out of a molehill or to be more precise, creating a thread out of nothing.
Click to expand...

aniket1911 said:
Yes, he was one of the great gentleman to play this game. Imagine, playing for Two and half decade and yet people resorting to half cooked allegations to implicate you. One of the greatest on and off the field. Absolute gem of a person.
Click to expand...

cricketjoshila said:
1.Tendulkar was acquitted to Ball tampering charges.Thats the ICC ruling.Anything wont change that.

2.Who lied and who didnot lie in the Bhajji case isnt known.

people questioning Sachin's acquittal by icc must remember that the icc also acquitted Inzy and the Pakistani team of tampering charges in 2006.
Click to expand...

ipl_fan said:
Out of the blue, without any context, we are discussing the integrity of a cricketer like SRT on a Pakistani discussion forum.

I have seen it all.
Click to expand...

Is he above criticism. He wasn't a saint and you can clearly see in the video that he was tampering with the seam. He was a cheat and got caught. I'm sure there would be more incidents of this if we had cameras like we do today.
 
What the hell happened? OP got woken up from deep sleep and created a thread thinking its 2001????
 
If you can find less than 5 major incidents in a 24 year career, then that means he was pretty good.
 
Hasan123 said:
Amla, Dravid, and Williamson.
Click to expand...

SA tampered with the ball under Amla's captaincy. He was either aware or unaware, and both put him in bad light.

If he was aware, then it shows that he is not the man of integrity that he is portrayed to be. If he was unaware, then it sums up what an embarrassing leader he was.

Which is probably true to be fair, he was a joke of a captain who chickened out because he couldn't handle the pressure being the softie that he is.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mamoon said:
SA tampered with the ball under Amla's captaincy. He was either aware or unaware, and both put him in ad light.

If he was aware, then it shows that he is not the man of integrity that he is portrayed to be. If he was unaware, then it sums up what an embarrassing leader he was.

Which is probably true to be fair, he was a joke of a captain who chickened out because he couldn't handle the pressure being the softie that he is.
Click to expand...

Cmon this is a bit harsh.
[MENTION=129948]Bilal7[/MENTION]
 
Railu Katta said:
Is he above criticism. He wasn't a saint and you can clearly see in the video that he was tampering with the seam. He was a cheat and got caught. I'm sure there would be more incidents of this if we had cameras like we do today.
Click to expand...

You are saying he is tampering.Means Zilch.He was never convicted of tampering no matter how much whine.
 
Mamoon said:
SA tampered with the ball under Amla's captaincy. He was either aware or unaware, and both put him in bad light.

If he was aware, then it shows that he is not the man of integrity that he is portrayed to be. If he was unaware, then it sums up what an embarrassing leader he was.

Which is probably true to be fair, he was a joke of a captain who chickened out because he couldn't handle the pressure being the softie that he is.
Click to expand...

He's rarely been involved in any controversy and he wasn't charged with any ball tampering.
 
Proactive_ said:
Nope.

[UTUBE]NHwYq-N8HU4[/UTUBE]

Funny how BCCI threw a hissy fit at ICC's ruling of the most obvious case of ball tampering in history.
Click to expand...

Doctored video. The real version of the video is somewhere on yideo. Will post it soon.
 
Railu Katta said:
Of course he's gonna deny it. He's a cheat that caught and all cheats deny deny deny....
Click to expand...

When did he deny any of it? He simply refused to speak on the matter. The previous video posted was a doctored one, made probably by a fan like yourself.
 
Hitman said:
When did he deny any of it? He simply refused to speak on the matter. The previous video posted was a doctored one, made probably by a fan like yourself.
Click to expand...

Yes so him refusing to talk means he's innocent. I salute your logic and reasoning skills.
 
Railu Katta said:
Yes so him refusing to talk means he's innocent. I salute your logic and reasoning skills.
Click to expand...

When did I ever say he is innocent? I was speaking specifically of the doctored video.You were the one claiming that he was denying in that video. He simply chose to not speak on that matter.
 
but he has never tried to present himself as epitome of integrity. that was the job of groupies like Harsha Friedman Bhogle.
 
Pete Rose said:
but he has never tried to present himself as epitome of integrity. that was the job of groupies like Harsha Friedman Bhogle.
Click to expand...

This. I don't ever remember him pretending to be a saint. For a man who played for 24 years, he was relatively controversy free and rarely lashed out at anyone in the media.
 
I think Courtney Walsh was someone who played the game squeaky clean. Lol at someone suggesting Pollock.
 
Railu Katta said:
That's actually a great suggestion. No ball tampering, and no false statements. Definitely the most honest Pakistani cricketer.
Click to expand...
misbah's acheivements are too small to make him a representative of cricket integrity.
The first requirement of becoming a representative of cricket is that the player has to acheive something remarkable.Sorry if it hurts:misbah4
 
Oh look another let's bash Tendulkar thread, it's like you guys are obsessed with a man who retd a few years now.
 
jagatk said:
Oh look another let's bash Tendulkar thread, it's like you guys are obsessed with a man who retd a few years now.
Click to expand...

Nothing but insecurity. Can't take it how much he is respected and revered by the rest of the world.
 
Now PP is a court ? I did not read all the above threads. But if Sachin is accused of ball tampering, it could be only that test from 2001.He has some issue with Indians in 2000/01 episode. Infact, India should have pulled out of that tour after that incidient. SA cricket board worked out some plans and the tour continued after recognising that test as forfeited test as something. That match referee Chris Broad was the same guy in the gatting shakur rana episode. He refused to walk even after getting out. His son stuart, has the same genes - considers himself eternally NOT out. And this broad's word is taken for granted. He is the same as the old generation of egoist/vain cricketers like Lilley. When the source is trash, the news becomes trash. Simple.
 
Last edited:
jeeteshssaxena said:
misbah's acheivements are too small to make him a representative of cricket integrity.
The first requirement of becoming a representative of cricket is that the player has to acheive something remarkable.Sorry if it hurts:misbah4
Click to expand...

jagatk said:
Oh look another let's bash Tendulkar thread, it's like you guys are obsessed with a man who retd a few years now.
Click to expand...

Hitman said:
Nothing but insecurity. Can't take it how much he is respected and revered by the rest of the world.
Click to expand...

ind_win said:
Now PP is a court ? I did not read all the above threads. But if Sachin is accused of ball tampering, it could be only that test from 2001.He has some issue with Indians in 2000/01 episode. Infact, India should have pulled out of that tour after that incidient. SA cricket board worked out some plans and the tour continued after recognising that test as forfeited test as something. That match referee Chris Broad was the same guy in the gatting shakur rana episode. He refused to walk even after getting out. His son stuart, has the same genes - considers himself eternally NOT out. And this broad's word is taken for granted. He is the same as the old generation of egoist/vain cricketers like Lilley. When the source is trash, the news becomes trash. Simple.
Click to expand...

LOL the lengths you will go to defend a cheat. He tampered with the seam and therefore he's a cheat. It's not a bashing thread; it's a discussion, but you indians get triggered when someone points out the truth about tendulkar not being the saint that he's portrayed to be. :kp
 
Railu Katta said:
LOL the lengths you will go to defend a cheat. He tampered with the seam and therefore he's a cheat. It's not a bashing thread; it's a discussion, but you indians get triggered when someone points out the truth about tendulkar not being the saint that he's portrayed to be. :kp
Click to expand...

Who said he is a cheat? The authorities on the matter said he was not.

Its pretty clear that pakistanis like you just get burnt because of his success and the reverence he gets. :Srt
 
Hermoine Green said:
How many times this dude will be discussed? :)

It's proven.
Click to expand...

By whom, the actual competent authorities judged him not guilty and all your chest thumping about his purported guilt changes not one bit how he is viewed by his fans or other unbiased neutrals.
 
Sachin was one of the true gentleman of his era.He was rarely involved in controversy despite playing for 24 years.
 
Did we just go back to 2007?

No he isn't

There are many others. Amla, BMac, Dravid.... to name a few.
 
He said Eff off to a newbie Saqlain when he got him out in Sharjah...NOT A GENTLEMAN
 
I never said he was a bad role model but he's not the saint that indians will make him out to be. He was a cheat, selfish and had scuffles and tantrums at his own players.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

atreus
  • Article Article
Viv Richards and Sachin Tendulkar — are they really far apart statistically?
Replies
7
Views
449
atreus
atreus
Dr_Bassim
Did Sachin Tendulkar play against average teams or all-time great teams?
2 3 4
Replies
278
Views
7K
mominsaigol
mominsaigol
mominsaigol
Why do some Test greats struggle in White-Ball cricket and vice versa?
Replies
65
Views
1K
kron
K
Devadwal
[VIDEOS] Inzamam-ul-Haq accuses the Indian team of ball-tampering in an ICC T20 World Cup 2024 match against Australia
2
Replies
119
Views
4K
Romali_rotti
Romali_rotti
Bhaijaan
Childhood cricket memories becoming vintage nostalgia : A bittersweet realisation of the passage of time
Replies
44
Views
1K
Bhaijaan
Bhaijaan
Back
Top