What's new

Joe Root hits out at ‘substandard’ Lord’s pitch after England’s three-day Test win

Majestic_Inzi

First Class Star
Joined
Feb 9, 2007
Runs
3,970
Already crying, had they been playing aus they would have lost.

England’s bowlers will not thank Joe Root for it but their captain was highly critical of the Lord’s pitch after his side’s 143-run victory against Ireland. “I don’t like saying this but the wicket was substandard for a Test match,” Root said after Ireland were bowled out for 38. “It wasn’t even close to being a fair contest between bat and ball throughout the whole game.”

He admitted his team “weren’t at our best by any stretch” but, in what came across as a pretty clear dig at the Lord’s groundsman, Karl McDermott, Root said: “When you are getting scores like that, that tells a story in itself.”

McDermott, who took over the job only last December, has just over a fortnight to get his surface ready for the second Ashes Test. Root said he hoped the pitch would be better than this one. “We’ll have to wait and see if it is similar,” he said. “I don’t think it will be.”

If it is, England “will have to make sure we try to exploit it the best we can, to find a method to cope and score runs. The challenge will be the same for Australia as it was for us and Ireland this week. It will make for entertaining cricket if that’s the case.”

The blunt truth is that it was not only the pitch that was substandard but the batting too, since both teams were bowled out in the space of a single session. Root insisted “from a batting point of view, it’s hard to take too much out of it on a surface like that” and that “it’s hard for anyone to read too much into this in very extreme conditions”.

He did admit “we have got to be more precise about how we want to defend” and that he was personally responsible for “opening the door for Ireland” in the second innings, when he “stupidly” ran out Joe Denly.

Lurking in the background behind all this talk about the pitch, there is a suggestion that Root and the other players who turned out for England in the World Cup are exhausted. Root did not deny he was feeling “knackered” and said: “It’s been 10 weeks of hard cricket, of high emotion, of ups and downs. It does take a lot out of you.”

He did not want to make an excuse of it. “You have to suck it up and get on with it. It’s not been perfect but we’ve dealt with it pretty well. It’s hard to look too much into performances on there but mentally coping with it I think we’ve done all right.

“We’ve never been in a position where we’ve won a World Cup, so for half the side to be part of that and then very quickly adjust to Test cricket is unusual. You’ve never been in that position before, so it’s hard to know how you’re going to cope.”
Advertisement

Personally he had turned up at Lord’s “feeling extremely excited for the Test summer” and now its preface was over he felt “pleased we managed to find a way to win this game. There’s been so many different pressures and challenges thrown at us”.

There have but it is all about to get that much more pressured and that much more challenging again. The hard part is only just starting.

https://amp.theguardian.com/sport/2019/jul/26/joe-root-substandard-lords-pitch-england-ireland-test
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Phase 2 of England’s life after world championship, flat roads have been packed away.
 
Root is correct - no way should a minor counties attack bowl a side with thirty-odd test centuries out for a hundred, and no way should even a minnow side be out for 38 with movement off the seam lavish on day three. I really felt for Ireland yesterday.

Cricket is supposed to be about entertainment, not matches over in seven sessions.

Bring back Mick Hunt.
 
It's a new curator at Lord's.

I like seeing the ball slightly dominate bat in any format but this was excessive.
 
It's a new curator at Lord's.

I like seeing the ball slightly dominate bat in any format but this was excessive.

On the other hand, T20 is to blame for an inability to stay in and grind out runs. They a #11 could get ninety on it suggests that it was possible. I saw Gooch get 154* against the great West Indians on a worse track than this which in addition to the lavish seam movement had erratic bounce.
 
It was a good pitch with the sun out, but as the clouds rolled in on the 3rd day there definitely was too great of a shift in advantage to the bowlers. Ireland were helpless.
 
Pitch was fine, the sunday village batting by both sides was the main issue :facepalm:
 
It was a good pitch with the sun out, but as the clouds rolled in on the 3rd day there definitely was too great of a shift in advantage to the bowlers. Ireland were helpless.

Clouds have no effect on the pitch. The seam movement was there throughout.
 
Pitch was fine. 5 WC winning batsmen scored a grand total of 7! Let's face it, the players are still celebrating the WC win, and this Test match was perhaps a little too soon. Also a small point, Root shouldn't be complaining about the pitch, it's the same pitch England bowled Ireland out for 38! Did I mentioned the rain too?

Pitch was fine.
 
Clouds have no effect on the pitch. The seam movement was there throughout.

Clouds do have an effect on the pitch. Clouds ensure moisture remains within the pitch, making the pitch a bit softer compared to say when the sun is out and moisture evaporates leaving a dry and hard pitch.
 
If any watched 2nd days pitch report & heard the commentary during first 2 sessions , every one said good batting wicket . Wonder what happened ?
 
Clouds do have an effect on the pitch. Clouds ensure moisture remains within the pitch, making the pitch a bit softer compared to say when the sun is out and moisture evaporates leaving a dry and hard pitch.

It’s a fair point. The ball often does not swing under full overcast if it is cold. When the clouds clear and the pitch warms up, evaporating moisture can make the ball swing.
 
It’s a fair point. The ball often does not swing under full overcast if it is cold. When the clouds clear and the pitch warms up, evaporating moisture can make the ball swing.

Swing is uncontrollable due to weather, however batsmen must try to look for seam movement.
 
Swing is uncontrollable due to weather, however batsmen must try to look for seam movement.

By the batsmen you mean?

Funnily enough even master swing bowler Ian Botham couldn't tell whether a given ball would swing in given conditions.
 
Back
Top