What's new

Khaleel Ahmed vs Shaheen Shah Afridi

Shaheen's stats may prove that he is better at this stage but we can't say much as of now.
Khaleel is bowling on pattas, while shaheen is playing on low scoring uae pitches.
Secondly
Our U19 guys were able to thrash shaheen so i reserve my statement until shaheen plays outside UAE. As much as i have seen he doesn't move the ball much. He relies on pace variation.
 
You mean height?

Khaleel is decent at this point. He needs to bulk up a little and add increase the pace. Shaheen is bowling at 140k consistently.

At this point, Khaleel has a lot of catching up to do if he wants to be compared to Shaheen.

Both height and body mass. Shaheen looks stronger.

But disagree on the pace part. Khaleel has shown higher peak pace than Shaheen at the moment. But to be honest i dont know about the average pace comparison of these two.
 
Khaleel is another name in the long list of trundlers we have produced, why is he bowling so slow? It is not like he is incapable of bowling 140+, his current style of bowling may pay dividends in SC but not in England where the WC will be played.
 
Khaleel is another name in the long list of trundlers we have produced, why is he bowling so slow? It is not like he is incapable of bowling 140+, his current style of bowling may pay dividends in SC but not in England where the WC will be played.

May be Venkatesh Prasad paid a visit to Khaleel and taught him the advantages of bowling slow :nehra
 
Both height and body mass. Shaheen looks stronger.

But disagree on the pace part. Khaleel has shown higher peak pace than Shaheen at the moment. But to be honest i dont know about the average pace comparison of these two.

Khaleel has world class facilities available now and diet will not be an issue. There should be no excuses for not bulking up a bit.
Shaheen looked very frail during the U19 WC last year. But he surely has worked hard in the gym and you can see how his body responded.
 
How? Can you explain the similarities bw the two. I think both have bright careers ahead.

Bro, chill It's just a tactic to increase the number of pages.

Speak something controversial and escape, the thread will change into Faheem vs Pandya.:wahab2:vk2:inti

Speaking the truth, both are really good but, we'll see their worth at the world cup.
 
Shaheen looks physically stronger. Khaleel is a wiry kid who need to develop his upper body strength a bit more.It helps you when you want to push yousrelf.
 
At this point it feels like Shaheen is thrown into the deep end and he is coming up aces. Khaleel has been a support bowler and has been doing a decent job. Shaheen is leading at this point
 
Shaheen looks good. Want to see more of Khaleel.

At this point, Shaheen seems to have greater potential. He is taking bucket loads of wickets on UAE pitches.

Khaleel is a decent bowler who has potential. Can develop into a very good bowler if nurtured properly.
 
Shaheen is far ahead at the moment. He is on his way on becoming the bowling leader of the ODI side
 
I'd like to judge Shaheen once he has bowled in non-sub continent pitches. Need to see if he has the ability to swing which will truly make him a dangerous bowler in ODI and Test cricket. If he offers no swing then like Junaid and Aamir, he will eventually fade.
 
I'd like to judge Shaheen once he has bowled in non-sub continent pitches. Need to see if he has the ability to swing which will truly make him a dangerous bowler in ODI and Test cricket. If he offers no swing then like Junaid and Aamir, he will eventually fade.

There will no be worse conditions for fast bowling than the UAE.

He has exceptional height (Hasan lacks it), game awareness (Wahab never had), and the variation of the left-arm angle (always an added bonus because it is equally effective from either side of the wicket).

The kid has followed his predecessors with a great start but it remains to be seen if he can maintain his initial burst.
 
Shaheen's stats may prove that he is better at this stage but we can't say much as of now.
Khaleel is bowling on pattas, while shaheen is playing on low scoring uae pitches.
Secondly
Our U19 guys were able to thrash shaheen so i reserve my statement until shaheen plays outside UAE. As much as i have seen he doesn't move the ball much. He relies on pace variation.

Hasan Ali and Trent Boult went at 7 an over today. They bowled on the same pitch.
 
There will no be worse conditions for fast bowling than the UAE.

I know but if there is one thing I learned then its to take my time in judging players. We've had likes of Umar Akmal, Amir who made one hell of a impact but fell off dramatically - at one point they were potential world class. Hasan and Fakhar going through similar 'phase' too. We haven't had a consistent youngster come through the ranks in over a decade IMO.

Shaheen just needs to do what he is doing now but for sure look to develop. His PR team seem on their game - hopefully a county contract can be secured.
 
Fluke wicket for Afridi. :vk

Not happening for this thread so far is it. I think our fans love fighting over mediocre cricketer's. Shaheen is ahead atm but let's see what future holds. By the way what's happening to those india u19 bowlers who outbowled Shaheen in world cup?? Looked great mavi and nagarkoti but have since dissapeared.
 
Not happening for this thread so far is it. I think our fans love fighting over mediocre cricketer's. Shaheen is ahead atm but let's see what future holds. By the way what's happening to those india u19 bowlers who outbowled Shaheen in world cup?? Looked great mavi and nagarkoti but have since dissapeared.

Indian selection panel is one of the worst in history at the moment, they are sticking with only seniors, thankfully these young bowlers have IPL to perform and multi-crore salaries to fall back on. The World Cup 2019 team should have been filled with youngsters like Mavi, Nagarkoti and Batsmen like Shaw, Ishan Kishan, Sanju Samson etc.
 
What I can say with certainty at this point is that both these lads are growing far quicker than I expected them to. It's mighty impressive to see how much they have grown as bowlers in the handful of matches they have played so far.
 
Excited to see these two opening the bowling at the world cup, for their respective teams.

This thread is going to be bumped a lot. Exciting times really, for the players and the fans.
 
Stats after both have played 6 ODIs.

Wkts:
KA: 11
SA: 13

Avg:
KA: 24.00
SA: 17.61

Eco:
KA: 5.07
SA: 4.88

SR:
KA: 28.3
SA: 21.6

4fer/5fer:
KA: 0/0
SA: 2/0
 
Stats after both have played 6 ODIs.

Wkts:
KA: 11
SA: 13

Avg:
KA: 24.00
SA: 17.61

Eco:
KA: 5.07
SA: 4.88

SR:
KA: 28.3
SA: 21.6

4fer/5fer:
KA: 0/0
SA: 2/0

Keep in mind the opposition so far as well:

SSA: Afg, Bang, Ind, NZ, NZ, NZ (6 matches total)

KA: HK, Afg, Wi, WI, WI, WI, WI (6 matches total)

This makes SSA's start look even better compared to KA's.

However it is early days, should reserve judgement until after the world cup. KA may well pull ahead.
 
Keep in mind the opposition so far as well:

SSA: Afg, Bang, Ind, NZ, NZ, NZ (6 matches total)

KA: HK, Afg, Wi, WI, WI, WI, WI (6 matches total)

This makes SSA's start look even better compared to KA's.

However it is early days, should reserve judgement until after the world cup. KA may well pull ahead.

Need to also remember I think it was 5 or 6 dropped catches already off Afridi’s bowling.
 
Khaleel doesn't look anything special. Shaheen is much better at this stage, although we have to give them enough of a sample size to properly judge.
 
If you analyse the U19 WC game last year, Mavi, Porel and Nagarkotti outbowled Afridi who went for 61 runs in 10 overs. So we hv better bowlers than Afridi in domestics but selectors decided to give Khaleel a go who is clearly an inferior bowler.

Reason - Well, we know why.
 
If you analyse the U19 WC game last year, Mavi, Porel and Nagarkotti outbowled Afridi who went for 61 runs in 10 overs. So we hv better bowlers than Afridi in domestics but selectors decided to give Khaleel a go who is clearly an inferior bowler.

Reason - Well, we know why.

Excellent logic. So Shaheen gave runs in one game make them other bowlers better then him. They say you learn something new everyday.
 
If you analyse the U19 WC game last year, Mavi, Porel and Nagarkotti outbowled Afridi who went for 61 runs in 10 overs. So we hv better bowlers than Afridi in domestics but selectors decided to give Khaleel a go who is clearly an inferior bowler.

Reason - Well, we know why.

Shaheen is playing for his national team whereas guys like Porel, Nagarkotti and Mavi are not even in team management's plans thanks to IPL legends like Thakur and Kaul who keep getting selected.

In my opinion Shaheen is a better bowler at the moment. Also I don't know why Khaleel is bowling at 130-135k range. He used to bowl above 140k in domestic cricket. :inti
 
If you analyse the U19 WC game last year, Mavi, Porel and Nagarkotti outbowled Afridi who went for 61 runs in 10 overs. So we hv better bowlers than Afridi in domestics but selectors decided to give Khaleel a go who is clearly an inferior bowler.

Reason - Well, we know why.

You can’t judge a player by his performance in one match. No doubt the Indian pacers are talented but you can’t say they are better than Shaheen based on one match.
 
Shaheen is playing for his national team whereas guys like Porel, Nagarkotti and Mavi are not even in team management's plans thanks to IPL legends like Thakur and Kaul who keep getting selected.

In my opinion Shaheen is a better bowler at the moment. Also I don't know why Khaleel is bowling at 130-135k range. He used to bowl above 140k in domestic cricket. :inti

Even Shaheen will play in PSL...that has nothing to do with the topic we are discussing here. Issue is not premier leagues, even Khaleel played for Delhi Daredevills. The problem is our national selectors are ignorant.
 
India have found the next Zaheer Khan in Khaleel Ahmed: Karsan Ghavri

Aggression, guile and raw pace coupled with variety has made Khaleel Ahmed tick all the right boxes required for a genuine fast bowler. Ever since India sprung a surprise by introducing the prodigious left-arm pacer from the small town of Tonk in Rajasthan at the Asia Cup this year, Khaleel has shown good promise.

In the Asia Cup this year, Khaleel snapped three wickets in his debut ODI against Hong Kong and added one more against Afghanistan in the Super Four stage. In six ODIs – two in the Asia Cup and four versus West Indies – he has claimed 11 wickets, while in the recently-concluded T20Is against the 20-year-old took three wickets.

Being fast-tracked into the senior Indian side after impressing in white-ball cricket for India A speaks of Khaleel’s skill, believes former India left-arm pace bowler Karsan Ghavri.

“Khaleel Ahmed is a bright prospect for India. He’s got good control of his line, length and has good accuracy. He’s been able to swing the ball with that kind of speed which is very important because pace is not everything. If Khaleel can generate speed and swing consistently, he’s even more dangerous,” Ghavri told CricketCountry. “He has got the ability to swing the ball both ways – the in-swinger, out-swinger – and he’s got a good bouncer and generates good speed. He’s a very versatile bowler and can do well for India provided he looks after his body and stays away from injuries.”

India have been on the lookout for a genuine left-arm quick ever since Zaheer Khan retired in 2012. There have been a fe who have auditioned for the role – the likes of Saurashtra’s Jaydev Unadkat and Punjab’s Barinder Sran, mainly – but none could impress the way Khaleel has since since he marked his run-up in Dubai.

With the 2019 ICC Cricket World Cup next year, Khaleel looks to have entered the big stage at the right time and with his strong showing in the sub-continent, he looks an asset for next summer’s showpiece event in England.

Ghavri, who bagged 109 wickets in 39 Tests, reckons India have found the next Zaheer. “Yes, to a certain extent. Zaheer Khan was a very good fast bowler for India. If somebody has taken more than 200 wickets [Zaheer took 282 wickets in 200 ODIs], he has to be good. After a long time after Zaheer Khan, India has found another good left-handed fast bowler,” the 67-year-old said.

Khaleel’s next assignment is the series against Australia where he has been named in the T20I squad. Ghavri feels the move will not help the bowler flourish.

“The T20 format is a totally different format altogether because the bowlers or the batsmen hardly get any time to settle down. For Khaleel, the real format for him is Test cricket or may be, even a 50-over game because there, you have a good chance of settling down,” he said.

“In a T20 match, you just bowl four overs and hardly get time to settle down. If he gets himself in for a 50-over match or in Tests, it will be better for him. I am sure he will eventually get that spot, but he should be playing in the longer version of the game. Khaleel should have been named in the ODI squad and Test squad, rather than the T20I series. The team management should watch Khaleel perform in the 50-over game and if his performances are good, then automatically he graduates to Test cricket.”

https://www.cricketcountry.com/arti...er-khan-in-khaleel-ahmed-karsan-ghavri-764630
 
Pretty even ATM.
But shaheen will end up far better bowler than khaleel.
Due to bowling culture in Pakistan :ba
 
Had I not played for India now, it would have been very late: Khaleel Ahmed

Khaleel Ahmed the left-arm pacer, feels it has taken him longer than expected to live his dream of playing for India. As part of India’s 2016 Under-19 World Cup squad, the 20-year-old fast bowler from Tonk, Rajasthan had to wait over two years to be rewarded an India berth. In between, he was part of IPL franchise Delhi Daredevils but never played a game. Even for his state team of Rajasthan, Khaleel wasn’t a top preference.

Finally, it was during the 2017-18 Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy where Khaleel made a big impact, taking 17 wickets in ten games at an impressive economy rate of 6.76 runs per over and was subsequently named in India’s Asia Cup squad earlier in September.

“If I had not played for India now, then it would have been very late. I fear at an older age, my body wouldn’t have been able to exert as much as I can now,” Khaleel told Times of India in an interview. “I couldn’t sleep during the Syed Mushtaq Ali tournament. I would check the clock all night and waited to get back on the field, bowling fast and taking wickets. I couldn’t let this opportunity go like I did in Ranji Trophy.”

Known for working closely with former India fast bowler Zaheer Khan, Khaleel revealed watching his idol bowl in the nets for a big source of inspiration. “I worked on my bowling. I went to the NCA but there were no specialist bowling coaches. I had chats with Zaheer Khan at Daredevils but felt I shouldn’t be calling all the time. I observed him in the nets and tried to copy things in my hometown,” Khaleel said.

Khaleel has since come a long way. Making his India debut during the Asia Cup, Khaleel picked up 3 for 48 against Hong Kong in a game where India were almost given a scare by the Associate nation. Then, in the final two ODIs against West Indies, Khaleel bowled two fabulous spells of 3 for 13 and 2 for 29. The kind of potential he has shown in such short time, Khaleel might as well have ended India’s search for the next premier left-arm seamer.

Khaleel has received plenty of thoughts and advices, one of them coming from former Pakistan fast bowler Shoaib Akhtar, who asked him to reduce his jump. “I did reduce my jump earlier to get the ball swinging in to the batsman. But Bharat Arun (India bowling coach) doesn’t force me to do things. He only works on those things which would suit my physique and ability. I am happy with that. I figured I had to increase my body mass to bowl consistently at pace, Khaleel said.

“I bowled well during my U-19 days and even after that, I wasn’t getting wickets. I couldn’t figure out the right length. In my head, I marked the lengths Zaheer used to bowl and worked on it.”

https://www.cricketcountry.com/news...ould-have-been-very-late-khaleel-ahmed-765015
 
Shaheen Shah has only played 2 FC matches so far. he'll be sitting on a bench in the nzl test series and will play in South Africa test series. But I fear he may get bogged down like Shadab because lack of 4 day cricket experience
 
Finally, it was during the 2017-18 Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy where Khaleel made a big impact, taking 17 wickets in ten games at an impressive economy rate of 6.76 runs per over and was subsequently named in India’s Asia Cup squad earlier in September.

Contrary to what some fans here believe Khaeel is in the team because of his performances in domestic cricket. :inti
 
Contrary to what some fans here believe Khaeel is in the team because of his performances in domestic cricket. :inti

Mustaq Ali is a domestic T20 tournament and not first class/list A. IPL is 100 times better in quality than Mustaq Ali trophy. Hence he couldnt replicate his good Mustaq Ali form in IPL where he went for plenty.
 
Mustaq Ali is a domestic T20 tournament and not first class/list A. IPL is 100 times better in quality than Mustaq Ali trophy. Hence he couldnt replicate his good Mustaq Ali form in IPL where he went for plenty.

He keeps cribbing but it doesn't change the fact that IPL revolutionized Indian LOI teams

"The focus on the New Zealand tour is more about four-day cricket and I think we are playing really good white ball cricket. I have seen this on the A tour over the last two-and-a-half years. We have been really competitive and building a very good bench strength. The IPL really helps in that department."

The above comments are from Rahul Dravid of all people. And arm chair oldies think they know better.

https://www.firstpost.com/firstcric...ifferent-conditions-in-australia-5537821.html
 
Mustaq Ali is a domestic T20 tournament and not first class/list A. IPL is 100 times better in quality than Mustaq Ali trophy. Hence he couldnt replicate his good Mustaq Ali form in IPL where he went for plenty.

Last time I checked his stats he had only played 1 IPL match. So on what basis he became the product of IPL? :inti
 
He keeps cribbing but it doesn't change the fact that IPL revolutionized Indian LOI teams

Really? Aren't you the same guy who was blaming CSK and Mumbai Mafia for the current selection blunders in Indian LOI teams? Why is it so hard for some of you to remain consistent with your views? :inti
 
Really? Aren't you the same guy who was blaming CSK and Mumbai Mafia for the current selection blunders in Indian LOI teams? Why is it so hard for some of you to remain consistent with your views? :inti

Calling what it is is not changing views. IPL has changed the face of Indian cricket and I have always maintained that. The side affects are the cliques and gangs but it doesn't change the fact that Indian cricket went to the next level because of IPL.
 
Calling what it is is not changing views. IPL has changed the face of Indian cricket and I have always maintained that. The side affects are the cliques and gangs but it doesn't change the fact that Indian cricket went to the next level because of IPL.

Read your post again and tell me where are you making any sense. The side effects you have mentioned are actually affecting the team balance and can cost India the world cup. It seems you are feeling like a rabbit caught in the headlights. On one hand you want to criticise mafia gangs that came into existence because of IPL on the other hand you also want to defend your beloved IPL.

So when you criticise IPL gangs you are calling what it is but when others do it you have problems with it. Lol. Make up your mind. :inti
 
Read your post again and tell me where are you making any sense. The side effects you have mentioned are actually affecting the team balance and can cost India the world cup. It seems you are feeling like a rabbit caught in the headlights. On one hand you want to criticise mafia gangs that came into existence because of IPL on the other hand you also want to defend your beloved IPL.

So when you criticise IPL gangs you are calling what it is but when others do it you have problems with it. Lol. Make up your mind. :inti

It's similar to this. We all love your countries but we criticize the things that aren't good in your country. I don't know how many posts I've written about the way IPL changed Indian teams. I had a few debates with you too about how players like Bumrah, Pandya were picked out of IPL without many domestic performances. And I remember one debate especially where I argued how IPL is the ultimate step for anyone trying to get into India LOI teams. We can criticize how the way it functions but we cannot deny the impact it had on LOI teams. You have always maintained that it's a pyjama league with no real benefits. I don't agree with that view.
 
Last time I checked his stats he had only played 1 IPL match. So on what basis he became the product of IPL? :inti

Technically you are right. Khaleel has only played 1 IPL game so he shouldn't be considered an IPL product. But he also had not played enough domestic cricket in any format to be called up to the national side either.

But the fact is also that Khaleel would never have been fast-tracked in the India A side if the DD scouts and (by extension) Zaheer Khan had not spotted him. So one can say that Khaleel wouldn't be in the Indian team today if it wasn't for the IPL. He might have gotten there 2-3 years later. But not this quickly.

So there is some truth to what [MENTION=147347]Canford Cliffs[/MENTION] is saying but I am of the opinion that the truth lies somewhere between.

I believe what we are seeing today is a new process of talent management and succession where players with little FC experience are being fast-tracked to the national side but under the "A Team banner".

So players like the Pandya bothers, Bumrah, Khaleel, Siraj are the first generation of "India A products".
 
Last edited:
Khaleel is pretty average to be honest. No pace no exceptional height. The only reason he is getting the hype is because he is a left arm seamer and india did not had a left arm seamer for a long time.
When you see Afridi bowling . You can see he has got the skills. He has pace , swing, height , yorker , slow ball and more importantly he is a very smart bowler
 
KA showing SA as to how it's done.

17.6
6
Ahmed to McDermott, SIX runs, shot! High and long over deep midwicket. McDermott swung hard at a length ball and made great contact, there's a fielder on the boundary but the ball clears him easily
17.5
1b
Ahmed to Tye, 1 bye, whoops! Pant lets it go through his legs to concede a bye, Bumrah mops up behind him. Tye had swung hard at a full ball and missed
17.4
2
Ahmed to Tye, 2 runs, full and straight from Khaleel, Tye lines it up and lofts back over the bowler's head, the fielder on the straight boundary runs across to cut it off
17.3
4
Ahmed to Tye, FOUR runs, edged and the ball beats the fielder at short third man for another boundary! Tye stayed back in his crease and drove at a full ball, Kohli watches with hands on hips
17.2
4
Ahmed to Tye, FOUR runs, width outside off, on a short length, and Tye has room to free his arms and slap the ball off the back foot to the extra cover boundary
17.2
1w
Ahmed to Tye, 1 wide, a bouncer that flies high above Tye's attempted hook, that's a wide for height because it's over the batsman's head
17.1
1
Ahmed to McDermott, 1 run, a slower ball, forced through the leg side for a single
 
Khaleel looks really average. Shaheen himself needs to work on a few aspects of his bowling, but right now he looks far ahead of this Khaleel.
 
Khaleel was bowling with decent pace in Asia cup. Now posters are saying that his pace has gone down. Happens with too many Indian bowlers.
 
Khaleel was bowling with decent pace in Asia cup. Now posters are saying that his pace has gone down. Happens with too many Indian bowlers.

We heard he was 145+. In Asia cup he was 135. In this series he is at 130. That's quite a steep fall.
 
17.6
6
Ahmed to McDermott, SIX runs, shot! High and long over deep midwicket. McDermott swung hard at a length ball and made great contact, there's a fielder on the boundary but the ball clears him easily
17.5
1b
Ahmed to Tye, 1 bye, whoops! Pant lets it go through his legs to concede a bye, Bumrah mops up behind him. Tye had swung hard at a full ball and missed
17.4
2
Ahmed to Tye, 2 runs, full and straight from Khaleel, Tye lines it up and lofts back over the bowler's head, the fielder on the straight boundary runs across to cut it off
17.3
4
Ahmed to Tye, FOUR runs, edged and the ball beats the fielder at short third man for another boundary! Tye stayed back in his crease and drove at a full ball, Kohli watches with hands on hips
17.2
4
Ahmed to Tye, FOUR runs, width outside off, on a short length, and Tye has room to free his arms and slap the ball off the back foot to the extra cover boundary
17.2
1w
Ahmed to Tye, 1 wide, a bouncer that flies high above Tye's attempted hook, that's a wide for height because it's over the batsman's head
17.1
1
Ahmed to McDermott, 1 run, a slower ball, forced through the leg side for a single

That over was bowled with a wet ball when it was pouring at MCG.
 
Khaleed Ahmad has to learn a lot, and learn that fast, otherwise his international career will be over soon.
 
This thread needs to be removed and thrown in the bad comparisons bin. :yk :vk2 :rabada2 :shezzy :bhajji :sarf2
 
:))) I think you are being too harsh.

Genuinely when he bowled the other day there wasn't pace, there wasn't the height factor there was no threat from him. Kind of like Amir, except Amir actually makes things happen sometimes.
 
Shaheen is too good a bowler and a well preserved fluke talent to have come from Pakistan in international cricket.
 
Close this thread.

Khaleel is not ready for international cricket. His bowling is mediocre. His batting is deplorable and fielding is even worse. I would rather have Siraj. He can at least smack a few big shots if needed and he can bowl in excess of 135k's.

Khaleel is not good enough to be compared to Shaheen in any angle. Back to domestics.

Avesh Khan is much better than Khaleel. Even Shivam Mavi is better than him.
 
Back
Top