Mob lynching in Jharkhand again: Beaten up for ‘selling beef’, tribal man dead, 2 critical

MP2011

Senior T20I Player
Joined
Aug 22, 2018
Runs
17,926
Post of the Week
1
https://theprint.in/india/mob-lynch...lling-beef-tribal-man-dead-2-critical/295283/

Ranchi: In yet another incident of mob lynching in Jharkhand, a tribal man died hours after he was beaten up for allegedly selling beef. The mob also attacked two other men and their condition is stated to be critical, a senior police officer told ThePrint.

The incident took place in Khunti district, around 50 km from state capital Ranchi.

According to the police, a group of 12 to 15 men caught hold of the three men at Jaltanda Suari village early Sunday morning for allegedly selling beef at a riverside market.

The mob came from neighbouring villages after news of alleged cow slaughter spread through text and WhatsApp messages. Seeing the mob approaching, the three tried to run away but were caught, said the officer quoted above.

The police identified the deceased as Kalantus Barla and the injured as Fagu Kachhapand and Phillip Hahoro. All three are tribal Christians.

Five villagers have been arrested so far and raids are on to nab others, said DIG V. Homkar.

The police said they received calls from some villagers, following which they rushed to the spot and rescued the trio. All three were then taken to a local hospital from where two, including Barla, were referred to Ranchi Medical College. Barla succumbed to his injuries in the evening.


“Senior officers are camping at the spot. The district’s SP and deputy commissioner are personally supervising the case. Different teams were formed to nab the culprits. We assure that strict action will be taken against all of them,” Homkar said after visiting the spot.

Barla’s death is the second allegedly due to lynching in Jharkhand in the last three months, with the first victim being Tabrez Ansari who died in June. The incident also comes a month before Jharkhand goes to polls.

Ansari was beaten by a violent mob as he was suspected of theft. He was rescued by the local police after almost eight hours and produced before a court as a thief. He was soon remanded in judicial custody, where he died after four days.

His 19-year-old wife is still fighting for justice, after the police initially dropped the murder charge from the chargesheet, only to add it later after a public outcry.
 
Still nothing to worry about. Sanghi snakes are too shameless to admit that India under Feku has become hotbed of violence where our own people aren't safe.
 
We've these shameful incidents happening at home, and Feku is very happy in the company of some sellout NRIs in an event which won't impact the common Indian populace in any manner.
 
So no presence of paid stooges on this thread.

For them standing ovations and point scoring in a foreign country are more important than lives of innocents...
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr"><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/WATCH?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#WATCH</a> Prime Minister Narendra Modi says,'everything is fine,' in different Indian languages. <a href="https://t.co/IpSKbGpTjg">pic.twitter.com/IpSKbGpTjg</a></p>— ANI (@ANI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1175834744271114242?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 22, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

'All is well in India'-PM Modi
No comments.
 
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-lang="en"><p lang="en" dir="ltr"><a href="https://twitter.com/hashtag/WATCH?src=hash&ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">#WATCH</a> Prime Minister Narendra Modi says,'everything is fine,' in different Indian languages. <a href="https://t.co/IpSKbGpTjg">pic.twitter.com/IpSKbGpTjg</a></p>— ANI (@ANI) <a href="https://twitter.com/ANI/status/1175834744271114242?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">September 22, 2019</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>

'All is well in India'-PM Modi
No comments.

Tamil crowd was least I guess - got the lowest cheers.

Didn't speak in Malayalam among the South. Looks like he's given up rabada2
 
Tamil crowd was least I guess - got the lowest cheers.

Didn't speak in Malayalam among the South. Looks like he's given up rabada2

Yeah, his party will never win in those 2 states. Never have, never will. Still we are doing fine, much better than BJP ruled states north of the Vindhyas.

Good to see a like-minded poster here, are you Malayali bro?
 
Yeah, his party will never win in those 2 states. Never have, never will. Still we are doing fine, much better than BJP ruled states north of the Vindhyas.

Good to see a like-minded poster here, are you Malayali bro?

No. From Bengaluru, Karnataka. But know a little of it. Friends, sister-in-law also is Tamilian from a border region of Kerala.

My state is gone, but it's mostly because of the Lingayat vote. Ironically a community created as a separate religion to get rid of casteism.
 
I would not write off BJP in Kerala and TN. Remember how West Bengal was considered an impregnable fortress for Communists and later TMC.

In Kerala BJP has already found some purchase. TN looks quite unlikely but if Rajnikanth joins hands with BJP....

I hope a United third front gains traction to counter the BJP juggernaut.
 
Tamil crowd was least I guess - got the lowest cheers.

Didn't speak in Malayalam among the South. Looks like he's given up rabada2

BJP has no more leeway in the South I think. It was a surprise they won a few seats in the Telugu states. Tamils have been playing musical chairs with two parties that are crooked and corrupt for decades Kerala is a communist hotbed. They will be happy if they hold on to K'taka and a few seats here and there in other states
 
Still nothing to worry about. Sanghi snakes are too shameless to admit that India under Feku has become hotbed of violence where our own people aren't safe.

Who according to you is the alternate for Modi in India? Sonia Gandhi?
 
Who according to you is the alternate for Modi in India? Sonia Gandhi?
Who told you that event manager is an alternative? Oh, those 41% stooges for whom he is God?

And I see no comment from you on those hapless guys who got in cross hairs of these barbarians.
 
Missing [MENTION=142162]Napa[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] and some other prizes members
 
Missing [MENTION=142162]Napa[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] and some other prizes members
It’s sad when the one Hindutva that did post in this thread did not mention the incident at all instead focusing on BJP strategies in the south.
 
that is the beauty of democracy.

two choices and both are wrong.

That's a vacuum in leadership. A national party keeps propping up the descendants of the first PM and they've turned out to be duds. BJP seems to be the only party with meritocracy.
 
Who told you that event manager is an alternative? Oh, those 41% stooges for whom he is God?

And I see no comment from you on those hapless guys who got in cross hairs of these barbarians.

Absolutely disgusting that people are being killed for beef. What's there to comment on it. My question is, which by the way is a genuine one, who is the alternative to Modi in India?
 
Missing [MENTION=142162]Napa[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] and some other prizes members

Out of everyone, i expect [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] to easily defend this without much effort.

India is shining, wee have so much money, we will give it to victims and they will live much better life than they would have when their loved one was alive.
 
Missing [MENTION=142162]Napa[/MENTION] [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] and some other prizes members

Here is my prize opinion for you "every crime should be prosecuted, especially extreme crimes such as murders". The rule of law is important for the country. Hence, I hope that this crime is also prosecuted and the guilty punished.

Anything else?
 
BJP seems to be the only party with meritocracy.
Lol, are you for real? BJP and meritocracy?

Only merit which matters in BJP is who can divide the electorate more on communal lines! Who can utter/do most **** about religion/caste different from yours!

I'm surprised at myself that I'm even engaging you....
 
Absolutely disgusting that people are being killed for beef. What's there to comment on it. My question is, which by the way is a genuine one, who is the alternative to Modi in India?
If you think event manager is the default choice to govern India, I have nothing to say to you.
 
Out of everyone, i expect [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] to easily defend this without much effort.

India is shining, wee have so much money, we will give it to victims and they will live much better life than they would have when their loved one was alive.
Hypocrisy comes naturally to such people. They've become so blind in defending the indefensible that they forget this path is only leading us to complete destruction.
 
Lol, are you for real? BJP and meritocracy?

Only merit which matters in BJP is who can divide the electorate more on communal lines! Who can utter/do most **** about religion/caste different from yours!

I'm surprised at myself that I'm even engaging you....

Don't be a numbnut when I'm asking a straight question. Who is the alternative to Modi? There is meritocracy in BJP. Remember the 2G scam idiot Raja in Congress rule. A nincompoop that doesn't know how to read has gobbled up millions. Stop your rants on communal crap. It is precisely because of people like you why Modi was reelected. You sit tight and swallow your pride while billions were looted. However an odd lynching and suddenly India has gone to dogs. For people like you, billions lost and thereby generations lost are little compared to some body killed for some innocuous reason. People get killed for 5 dollars in developed countries. There are depraved minds everywhere. Now I will be surprised if you name one alternative to Narendra Modi as the PM of India right now.
 
If you think event manager is the default choice to govern India, I have nothing to say to you.

And yet again, you fail to provide an alternative name. Precisely why I think Modi should be the PM. If his critics can't even name a candidate that's eligible to stand against him then their empty rhetoric is hollow with no meaning
 
Don't be a numbnut when I'm asking a straight question. Who is the alternative to Modi? There is meritocracy in BJP. Remember the 2G scam idiot Raja in Congress rule. A nincompoop that doesn't know how to read has gobbled up millions. Stop your rants on communal crap. It is precisely because of people like you why Modi was reelected. You sit tight and swallow your pride while billions were looted. However an odd lynching and suddenly India has gone to dogs. For people like you, billions lost and thereby generations lost are little compared to some body killed for some innocuous reason. People get killed for 5 dollars in developed countries. There are depraved minds everywhere. Now I will be surprised if you name one alternative to Narendra Modi as the PM of India right now.
So another stooge spotted. Will make it a point not to engage with unpaid stooges like you.
 
And yet again, you fail to provide an alternative name. Precisely why I think Modi should be the PM. If his critics can't even name a candidate that's eligible to stand against him then their empty rhetoric is hollow with no meaning

Usual excuse who are afraid to openly admit their support for RSS.
 
So another stooge spotted. Will make it a point not to engage with unpaid stooges like you.

Another Sonia supporter or communist spotted. Your days of eating public money is gone. Decades of rule and you can't produce a single leader that you can proudly say can stand against Modi. Nuff said!!
 
Usual excuse who are afraid to openly admit their support for RSS.
These stooges are so funny. For them event manager is the only one who can rule India and yet ask for alternatives..If you in your devious mind have already thought of him as the only one, who are we to suggest any alternative?

In any case, these creatures aren't good for any positive debate especially when they start hurling abuses at you.
 
I still lol at reading this,

"There is meritocracy in Bharat Jalao Party....
 
These stooges are so funny. For them event manager is the only one who can rule India and yet ask for alternatives..If you in your devious mind have already thought of him as the only one, who are we to suggest any alternative?

In any case, these creatures aren't good for any positive debate especially when they start hurling abuses at you.

Let.me.ask in simple.words so you can understand and probably come up with a name. Which political.leader in India has the credibility to stand against Modi? Now is that too hard to answer? You twist, you turn, you call people stooges but you can't answer the question. If you cant, well, then we know you are just a Modi hater with a propaganda in mind. If that's the case, there is no debating with you.
 
Besides, I being an Indian, having lived all my life in India, don't need lessons in patriotism from a fake wannabe Indian who doesn't even live here. Who doesn't even know what we've to go through due to these goons.
 
These stooges are so funny. For them event manager is the only one who can rule India and yet ask for alternatives..If you in your devious mind have already thought of him as the only one, who are we to suggest any alternative?

In any case, these creatures aren't good for any positive debate especially when they start hurling abuses at you.

Abuse?

Been calling out your “sugar coating” of abuse committed by RSS.

It’s not funny to millions of Kashmiri who are still under curfew.

It isn’t funny to those Indian Muslims who are afraid to speak against RSS goons.

But it’s okay and fun for you to sugar coat their abuse?

You have never debated you just spin the news by “sugar coating” with an excuse if not Modi then who else.
 
lol, more drivel from the stooge..

Just in the last few posts I figured you out. A person with no view and no confidence in himself with no ideals. Basically, you don't know what you want but you just want to erase something that already happened. What happens after you erase it? You don't have an answer as expected. Thats 10 min of time I'm never gonna get back
 
Besides, I being an Indian, having lived all my life in India, don't need lessons in patriotism from a fake wannabe Indian who doesn't even live here. Who doesn't even know what we've to go through due to these goons.

Don't tell people you live in India when you can't name a single leader that can stand against Modi LOL. When you bash some one you are expected to provide an alternative. You have none. I'm surprised you still don't considering you lived all your life in India. As they say, a frog in a well knows just about the well. You probably have been living in a bucket in that well
 
Abuse?

Been calling out your “sugar coating” of abuse committed by RSS.

It’s not funny to millions of Kashmiri who are still under curfew.

It isn’t funny to those Indian Muslims who are afraid to speak against RSS goons.

But it’s okay and fun for you to sugar coat their abuse?

You have never debated you just spin the news by “sugar coating” with an excuse if not Modi then who else.
You've sussed him absolutely the correct way. He just pretends to be a neutral. In reality, he is as dangerous as your average sanghi snake.
 
You've sussed him absolutely the correct way. He just pretends to be a neutral. In reality, he is as dangerous as your average sanghi snake.

A bunch of rants but can't get those fingers to type a single name huh. Heck that must be embarrassing. You are probably one of those defeatists that has already given up.
 
Abuse?

Been calling out your “sugar coating” of abuse committed by RSS.

It’s not funny to millions of Kashmiri who are still under curfew.

It isn’t funny to those Indian Muslims who are afraid to speak against RSS goons.

But it’s okay and fun for you to sugar coat their abuse?

You have never debated you just spin the news by “sugar coating” with an excuse if not Modi then who else.
Its not just sugar coating the abuse he even justifies that abuse by saying that event manager is the only who can rule India. So there you go...You get to know his true colors...
 
Don't tell people you live in India when you can't name a single leader that can stand against Modi LOL. When you bash some one you are expected to provide an alternative. You have none. I'm surprised you still don't considering you lived all your life in India. As they say, a frog in a well knows just about the well. You probably have been living in a bucket in that well

Not following your back and forth but Why are you so rattled and flustered lol..
 
One poster is so frustrated that he seems to have given up on democracy.

You read his posts and you realise what a hopeless case the opposition is if they have supporters like these.

One of the reasons the opposition isnt doing well is because their supporters abuse others for voting for the bjp and dont try to correct their mistakes.

This is electoral politics, you win elections and you lose elections. When you lose, try to rectify your problems rather than abusing voters for not voting for you.
 
As per PM Modi, everything is fine in India.

I can't say for sure what's the current situation regarding availability in restaurants here in Bengaluru cuz I haven't eaten beef in a while. But one thing I know is - a day after the BJP took over in Karnataka, a number of BJP workers patrolled some Muslim areas warning beef shops against selling beef. We haven't got to the point of beating people up, but you never know. The one thing going against them is that many of these Muslim-dominated areas have Hindu Tamilians living side by side. A lot of them eat beef and have more guts than the BJP boys. So if they try to push their weight around too much, the Muslims will have an ally in these areas.
 
Out of everyone, i expect [MENTION=76058]cricketjoshila[/MENTION] to easily defend this without much effort.

India is shining, wee have so much money, we will give it to victims and they will live much better life than they would have when their loved one was alive.

Why are you so flustered by the economic might of India?

This is a murder and murderers will be dealt with.

Atleast my PM didnot cry that this was a consipracy to sabotage his Howdy Modi event.
 
I can't say for sure what's the current situation regarding availability in restaurants here in Bengaluru cuz I haven't eaten beef in a while. But one thing I know is - a day after the BJP took over in Karnataka, a number of BJP workers patrolled some Muslim areas warning beef shops against selling beef. We haven't got to the point of beating people up, but you never know. The one thing going against them is that many of these Muslim-dominated areas have Hindu Tamilians living side by side. A lot of them eat beef and have more guts than the BJP boys. So if they try to push their weight around too much, the Muslims will have an ally in these areas.

The Karnataka Prevention of Cow Slaughter and Cattle Preservation Act, 1964 governs the slaughter of cattle in the state. Slaughter of cow, calf of a cow (male or female) or calf of a she-buffalo totally prohibited. Slaughter of bulls, bullocks and adult buffaloes is permitted on obtaining a "fit-for-slaughter" certificate provided cattle is over 12 years of age or is permanently incapacitated for breeding, draught or milk due to injury, deformity or any other cause. Transport for slaughter to a place outside the State not permitted. Sale, purchase or disposal of a cow or a calf, for slaughter, is not permitted.

Anyone violating the law can be punished with imprisonment up to maximum of 6 months or fine of up to ₹1,000 or both. The crime is treated as a cognizable offence


Thats the law. Hindu,Muslim,Tamilian,Kannada,Bjp,Congress, lingayat,vokkaliga, all have to obey it.
 
Unlike the event manager, to me India is not all about winning elections only and forming the govt, by hook or crook which event manager is so keen on. Its not the electoral politics which is be all and end all of everything related to India. The idea of India is much bigger than winning these elections.

I didn't have many objections from AB's govt despite the presence of nutcases like Bharti, Advani etc.

But this govt has finished the very essence of India and looking at the way things are going, looks like it is not going to stop just at that.
 
The Karnataka Prevention of Cow Slaughter and Cattle Preservation Act, 1964 governs the slaughter of cattle in the state. Slaughter of cow, calf of a cow (male or female) or calf of a she-buffalo totally prohibited. Slaughter of bulls, bullocks and adult buffaloes is permitted on obtaining a "fit-for-slaughter" certificate provided cattle is over 12 years of age or is permanently incapacitated for breeding, draught or milk due to injury, deformity or any other cause. Transport for slaughter to a place outside the State not permitted. Sale, purchase or disposal of a cow or a calf, for slaughter, is not permitted.

Anyone violating the law can be punished with imprisonment up to maximum of 6 months or fine of up to ₹1,000 or both. The crime is treated as a cognizable offence


Thats the law. Hindu,Muslim,Tamilian,Kannada,Bjp,Congress, lingayat,vokkaliga, all have to obey it.

Thank you but not sure what's the relevance. I wasn't planning on consuming a cow live and whole. Neither were the Tamilians, I hope.

There is no restriction on the sale or consumption of beef in Karnataka.

BTW, Kannada is the language. Kannadigas, the people.
 
Thank you but not sure what's the relevance. I wasn't planning on consuming a cow live and whole. Neither were the Tamilians, I hope.

There is no restriction on the sale or consumption of beef in Karnataka.

BTW, Kannada is the language. Kannadigas, the people.

Unless all beef is imported or is cara beef, it cannot be sold or consumed in karnataka.

Ofcourse congress govt turns a blind eye to the violators of this law.
 
The idea of India is what most people of the country want it to be. If it dorsnot suit you, well you got to live with it.
 
For starters, idea of people being lynched on the basis of what they eat doesn't suit my conscience and that after me not sharing their religion. It does suit a lot of people, I accept that which is my biggest fear.

Hell, even a HC CJ is not spared from religious bigotry from the ruling dispensation. If he isn't, then what hope does a common man have.
 
I wonder why was I not asked to move to Pakistan?
 
So I'm being declared a Pakistani...Easiest resort for stooges....

Mods - Pls prove my nationality as my plea will fall on deaf ears...
 
So I'm being declared a Pakistani...Easiest resort for stooges....

Mods - Pls prove my nationality as my plea will fall on deaf ears...

Unlike Ram Shekar who is a Pakistani, I believe you are Indian.


So

Mr Indian,

Which political party in your opinion would be better for India currently ?
 
Corrected

If most of the people of India support bjp then thats it. You cannot complain because people are not supporting you. Because you didnot had any problems when people supported your ideology.
 
Deaths of innocents is useless for you, got it....
 
Being from the south, I was immune to these kind of religious fanaticism. When people have nothing they cling on to their religion or race or caste to make themselves feel relevant in the society. If people in India spend half the energy on developing themselves than worrying about what others are doing, we would be a far developed society.
 
Being from the south, I was immune to these kind of religious fanaticism. When people have nothing they cling on to their religion or race or caste to make themselves feel relevant in the society. If people in India spend half the energy on developing themselves than worrying about what others are doing, we would be a far developed society.

trust me the sooner India gets rid of these guys the better. I lived in Karachi during some of the troubles there and the fear and hate that is generated literally overnight is horrible. It destroys lives and society. Pakistan is still trying to recover. Why would India want to go down this dark path? Just when we finally have a PM in Pakistan who is finally ready to step forward and draw a line on the past?

I mean surely we all have to move forward at some point but this is just not happening..
 
trust me the sooner India gets rid of these guys the better. I lived in Karachi during some of the troubles there and the fear and hate that is generated literally overnight is horrible. It destroys lives and society. Pakistan is still trying to recover. Why would India want to go down this dark path? Just when we finally have a PM in Pakistan who is finally ready to step forward and draw a line on the past?

I mean surely we all have to move forward at some point but this is just not happening..

How can we get rid of these guys? These habits are deep rooted in our society and it may take couple hundred years to change.These guys are who take the law (I believe this is an asinine law, government has no business telling people what to eat), are looking for relevance in their lives. They just want to run with the mob. Sad thing is there was no one to stand up and say what these morons were doing is wrong.
 
https://theprint.in/india/mob-lynch...lling-beef-tribal-man-dead-2-critical/295283/

Ranchi: In yet another incident of mob lynching in Jharkhand, a tribal man died hours after he was beaten up for allegedly selling beef. The mob also attacked two other men and their condition is stated to be critical, a senior police officer told ThePrint.

The incident took place in Khunti district, around 50 km from state capital Ranchi.

According to the police, a group of 12 to 15 men caught hold of the three men at Jaltanda Suari village early Sunday morning for allegedly selling beef at a riverside market.

The mob came from neighbouring villages after news of alleged cow slaughter spread through text and WhatsApp messages. Seeing the mob approaching, the three tried to run away but were caught, said the officer quoted above.

The police identified the deceased as Kalantus Barla and the injured as Fagu Kachhapand and Phillip Hahoro. All three are tribal Christians.

Five villagers have been arrested so far and raids are on to nab others, said DIG V. Homkar.

The police said they received calls from some villagers, following which they rushed to the spot and rescued the trio. All three were then taken to a local hospital from where two, including Barla, were referred to Ranchi Medical College. Barla succumbed to his injuries in the evening.


“Senior officers are camping at the spot. The district’s SP and deputy commissioner are personally supervising the case. Different teams were formed to nab the culprits. We assure that strict action will be taken against all of them,” Homkar said after visiting the spot.

Barla’s death is the second allegedly due to lynching in Jharkhand in the last three months, with the first victim being Tabrez Ansari who died in June. The incident also comes a month before Jharkhand goes to polls.

Ansari was beaten by a violent mob as he was suspected of theft. He was rescued by the local police after almost eight hours and produced before a court as a thief. He was soon remanded in judicial custody, where he died after four days.

His 19-year-old wife is still fighting for justice, after the police initially dropped the murder charge from the chargesheet, only to add it later after a public outcry.

This is absolutely pathetic!! Like someone so eloquently put in another thread ... I like my beef as much as my bacon. These morons are successfully regressing their country back by decades when it comes to social progress. Someone needs to tell the saffron crew (as much as the conservative bastion here stateside), no matter how much you grow the economy, if there is no social progress then everything is a moot point. In an alternate universe, even if a Taliban regime manages to show the best economic growth, nobody wants to live there because ... it is the Taliban regime!

Someone needs to educate these saffron clowns accordingly (sadly I doubt that will happen though).
 
This is absolutely pathetic!! Like someone so eloquently put in another thread ... I like my beef as much as my bacon. These morons are successfully regressing their country back by decades when it comes to social progress. Someone needs to tell the saffron crew (as much as the conservative bastion here stateside), no matter how much you grow the economy, if there is no social progress then everything is a moot point. In an alternate universe, even if a Taliban regime manages to show the best economic growth, nobody wants to live there because ... it is the Taliban regime!

Someone needs to educate these saffron clowns accordingly (sadly I doubt that will happen though).

All in the name of Mother Cow. Vigilante justice has increased alarmingly in the past 2 decades. More so under the current Lynching party government.
 
Unless all beef is imported or is cara beef, it cannot be sold or consumed in karnataka.

These riders , addendums and conditions are irrelevant and don't exist.

There is no restriction legally on eating beef in Karnataka or selling it.

The idea of India is what most people of the country want it to be. If it dorsnot suit you, well you got to live with it.

Until this grand idea of India becomes law, I don't care about the feelings of the rest of Indians.

Most people in the world believe in a God. Sure, I live with that and don't go around slapping every believer I meet. But that doesn't mean I should also believe in a God.

Similarly, my meal doesn't care about your feelings as long as I'm eating something legal. When I start eating a Modi fan, you can come back to me :cobra
 
These riders , addendums and conditions are irrelevant and don't exist.

There is no restriction legally on eating beef in Karnataka or selling it.



Until this grand idea of India becomes law, I don't care about the feelings of the rest of Indians.

Most people in the world believe in a God. Sure, I live with that and don't go around slapping every believer I meet. But that doesn't mean I should also believe in a God.

Similarly, my meal doesn't care about your feelings as long as I'm eating something legal. When I start eating a Modi fan, you can come back to me :cobra

If someone is selling or eating cow meat in Karnataka he will be questioned about its origin, because cows cannot be killed.

I can understand you are frustrated because in another thread you took shots at Lingayats for voting Bjp.

It doesnot matter what you believe, you got to obey the law.
 
I can understand you are frustrated because in another thread you took shots at Lingayats for voting Bjp.

Lingayats mostly voted BJP because of Yeddyurappa. He deserves some credit for almost being a one-man army in setting up the BJP and for his guts regarding the Hubli Idgah Maidan issue. But you have no idea about how corrupt this guy is and how he's facilitated it. That would be acceptable if he was competent which he is not on most matters that don't involve temple trusts or religious activity. Also has a very strong dubious aspect to his personal life involving his deceased wife.
 
Lingayats mostly voted BJP because of Yeddyurappa. He deserves some credit for almost being a one-man army in setting up the BJP and for his guts regarding the Hubli Idgah Maidan issue. But you have no idea about how corrupt this guy is and how he's facilitated it. That would be acceptable if he was competent which he is not on most matters that don't involve temple trusts or religious activity. Also has a very strong dubious aspect to his personal life involving his deceased wife.

Is he worse than HDK? DK Shivakumara? Siddharamiah?

Kannadigas voted massively for bjp in the LS. Its wrong to say they won only because of Lingayat votes.
 
Lingayats mostly voted BJP because of Yeddyurappa. He deserves some credit for almost being a one-man army in setting up the BJP and for his guts regarding the Hubli Idgah Maidan issue. But you have no idea about how corrupt this guy is and how he's facilitated it. That would be acceptable if he was competent which he is not on most matters that don't involve temple trusts or religious activity. Also has a very strong dubious aspect to his personal life involving his deceased wife.

Yes yediyurappa is previously caught in corruption charges. But for voters in Karnataka it was choosing between highly corrupt vs less corrupt and can at least be trusted a bit. So they unanimously rejected congress and JDS allies
 
Is he worse than HDK? DK Shivakumara? Siddharamiah?

Kannadigas voted massively for bjp in the LS. Its wrong to say they won only because of Lingayat votes.

Yes yediyurappa is previously caught in corruption charges. But for voters in Karnataka it was choosing between highly corrupt vs less corrupt and can at least be trusted a bit. So they unanimously rejected congress and JDS allies

lol at trusting Yeddy.

I'm talking about national elections which was always going to be different to state, though right now if state elections were held, BJP would win more than they did.

For national votes, Yedyurappa also reaped the immediate benefit of the personal ego-based fight between Siddaramiah and the Gowda family. Gowdas didn't help themselves putting up a clown grandson in Mandya. The Vokkaliga (Gowda)and Kuruba (Siddu)votes were split.

Don't get me started on DK and the vendetta going on. All because he poured a bucket of cold water on Amit Shah's bald head, humiliating him a few times :)))
 
^^
Expect Yeddy to try his best to get DK out soon though. They've been friends for a while. DK was part of the RSS during his youth politics days. Also, he has too much info on Yeddy's doings. Some say on Amit and Jay Shah too, which is also a reason for the desperation from the Centre to silence him.

Just lol'd now again remembering Amit Shah's failure to steal MLAs from DK's iron grip :))
 
lol at trusting Yeddy.

I'm talking about national elections which was always going to be different to state, though right now if state elections were held, BJP would win more than they did.

For national votes, Yedyurappa also reaped the immediate benefit of the personal ego-based fight between Siddaramiah and the Gowda family. Gowdas didn't help themselves putting up a clown grandson in Mandya. The Vokkaliga (Gowda)and Kuruba (Siddu)votes were split.

Don't get me started on DK and the vendetta going on. All because he poured a bucket of cold water on Amit Shah's bald head, humiliating him a few times :)))

DK is in jail for corruption. While Shah is the architect of Modi becoming PM twice, BJP and NDA winning in 19 states and the fall of DK's govt in KtK.
 
^^
Expect Yeddy to try his best to get DK out soon though. They've been friends for a while. DK was part of the RSS during his youth politics days. Also, he has too much info on Yeddy's doings. Some say on Amit and Jay Shah too, which is also a reason for the desperation from the Centre to silence him.

Just lol'd now again remembering Amit Shah's failure to steal MLAs from DK's iron grip :))

So how did the karnataka govt fall despite DK?
 
DK is in jail for corruption. While Shah is the architect of Modi becoming PM twice, BJP and NDA winning in 19 states and the fall of DK's govt in KtK.

So how did the karnataka govt fall despite DK?

lol at jailing people on corruption. Like the BJP is clean from top to bottom :)) Modi might not be corrupt in financial matters but corruption is not just about money.

Dude, I'm not blinded enough to dismiss Modi-Shah's political abilities. Have given credit wherever due, purely as politicians. DK hasn't proved himself as big a strategist as Shah as of now. But that doesn't mean Shah is invincible. DK already gave him a scare in Gujarat and humiliated him in Karnataka when everything was in place for a hostile, shameful, morally despicable Operation Kamal. They had their governor, they had the money and they almost had the numbers. Poor Shah's still smarting from the image of DK standing guard on the footboard of the bus as he whisked the MLAs away.

The Karnataka alliance was always on shaky ground due to Siddu's personal hatred for the Gowdas. He thwarted every decent program that HDK tried to implement or propose during his brief tenure to ensure nothing worked in the state. It has been a personal and vindictive campaign by Siddu which is a crying shame for a former CM who did a lot of good for the poor and rural sections of Karnataka in his time.
 
So I'm being declared a Pakistani...Easiest resort for stooges....

Mods - Pls prove my nationality as my plea will fall on deaf ears...

Not sure what happened here.

Don't get emotional about these things. That's what they want you to do. To feel hurt. To feel like you're a traitor for criticizing people worthy of criticism.
 
Back
Top