What's new

Overrated and Underrated Players

malakian said:
Anderson is just tearing leather off the ball in the first video, nothing to see there. cba watching the other one because it's likely to be equally as ridiculous.

We all know English players wouldn't cheat anyway, we lead the world when it comes to fair play.
Click to expand...

fairplay lol:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AizLOspJ--Y

the CMJ commentary is clearly biased but reflects the imperial mindset of the day! lol
 
malakian said:
Anderson is just tearing leather off the ball in the first video, nothing to see there. cba watching the other one because it's likely to be equally as ridiculous.

We all know English players wouldn't cheat anyway, we lead the world when it comes to fair play.
Click to expand...

Here's Prior claiming the batsman is BOWLED after he dislodges the bails himself.

Fairplay :))). Now don't watch this one too.

[UTUBE]nqwEwS8cwzQ[/UTUBE]
 
I reckon Herath and Danish are criminally under-rated on PP.
 
WebGuru said:
You might have noticed i added Trescothick, Collingwood etc in the list too actually we are talking about any cricketer in the history not only the currently playing cricketers.
Click to expand...

He didn't last that long for people to rate him.
 
vicky_iisc said:
Nah... how can he be underrated ? He was a walking wicket. Can't suddenly put him higher coz of his 170 y'day.
Click to expand...

I am not putting him higher because of this 170 but he is really underrated...When he came to intentional scene he had 6 centuries in less thn 35 ODI's he played...I know he lost the rhythm later and performed in patches...He scored 5 centuries in 2006..And 4 centuries in 2011...They guy deserve a bit more respect...
 
Suresh Raina is really overrated player the guy played 167 ODI's scoring 3 centuries and those 3 came against Hong Kong, Bangladesh & Lanka...
 
Ashraful_Rox said:
Out of form, but not overrated. Sachin is overrated
Click to expand...

Are you even sure what you are saying ? Sachin is overrated ? ha ha ha.. someone who has scored more centuries than the matches the so called "underrated players" have played.. is overrated?

While I respect one's entitled to an opinion, but not whim.. saying anything which you like..

Can you point one area of performance where Sachin is rated more than he deserves ? Would like to know that.
 
Last edited:
WebGuru said:
Suresh Raina is really overrated player the guy played 167 ODI's scoring 3 centuries and those 3 came against Hong Kong, Bangladesh & Lanka...
Click to expand...

I think we need to define what the term overrated means ? He is not called best in India or anything like that.. he is a useful lower order batsman (centuries for 6-7th position are rare).. In WC 2011, he was the primary reason of our QF and SF victories (well one of the primary reasons).. certainly can't call him overrated..
 
vicky_iisc said:
Are you even sure what you are saying ? Sachin is overrated ? ha ha ha.. someone who has scored more centuries than the matches the so called "underrated players" have played.. is overrated?

While I respect one's entitled to an opinion, but not whim.. saying anything which you like..

Can you point one area of performance where Sachin is rated more than he deserves ? Would like to know that.
Click to expand...

The England series both home and away he was quite poor and also he didn't do wonders lately, averaging quite low this year. He needs to be dropped as India has better replacements, if Gambhir and Sewag can be kicked out why isn't the same medicine being applied for God. He is a quality batsman no doubt, but don't like his fans, giving him god status and Sachin worshiping is just beyond pathetic.
 
Ashraful_Rox said:
The England series both home and away he was quite poor and also he didn't do wonders lately, averaging quite low this year. He needs to be dropped as India has better replacements, if Gambhir and Sewag can be kicked out why isn't the same medicine being applied for God. He is a quality batsman no doubt, but don't like his fans, giving him god status and Sachin worshiping is just beyond pathetic.
Click to expand...

Yes, he was rubbish after WC2011.. well not rubbish but by his own standards, not performed well.. he scored a 94 in oval and 80-odd in Sydney.. that ridiculous 100th 100 was going on in his mind..

Anyway, are you calling him overrated on recent performance ? Nobody is appreciating his recent performance .. so not sure what you mean. If you are calling him overrated based on his overall performance in career, then i would like to know where is he overrated.

No one should be called God, but if some fans call someone that, does it mean he is overrated ?
 
vicky_iisc said:
I think we need to define what the term overrated means ? He is not called best in India or anything like that.. he is a useful lower order batsman (centuries for 6-7th position are rare).. In WC 2011, he was the primary reason of our QF and SF victories (well one of the primary reasons).. certainly can't call him overrated..
Click to expand...

But again while batting between number 3-5 he played 83 matches and doesn't look better.

http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/en...orderby=default;template=results;type=batting
 
WebGuru said:
But again while batting between number 3-5 he played 83 matches and doesn't look better.

http://stats.espncricinfo.com/ci/en...orderby=default;template=results;type=batting
Click to expand...

I think his current role in ODIs is to come at 6-7 and score quickly.. which more or less he is able to do.. he is no Bevan though.. so yes, you can call him not-great.. but then he is rated with not-so-high praise also..

His WC QF/SF innings were the reason why India could sail through.. that talks about character and that is more imp than average.
 
vicky_iisc said:
Yes, he was rubbish after WC2011.. well not rubbish but by his own standards, not performed well.. he scored a 94 in oval and 80-odd in Sydney.. that ridiculous 100th 100 was going on in his mind..

Anyway, are you calling him overrated on recent performance ? Nobody is appreciating his recent performance .. so not sure what you mean. If you are calling him overrated based on his overall performance in career, then i would like to know where is he overrated.

No one should be called God, but if some fans call someone that, does it mean he is overrated ?
Click to expand...

Yes :sachin

Why isn't he dropped like Gambhir and Sehwag?
 
vicky_iisc said:
I think his current role in ODIs is to come at 6-7 and score quickly.. which more or less he is able to do.. he is no Bevan though.. so yes, you can call him not-great.. but then he is rated with not-so-high praise also..

His WC QF/SF innings were the reason why India could sail through.. that talks about character and that is more imp than average.
Click to expand...

Yea i agree with your point i am not talking about here at PP but i have seen the hype about raina on internet and in media...I personally rate Rohit higher thn Raina...
 
Ashraful_Rox said:
Yes :sachin

Why isn't he dropped like Gambhir and Sehwag?
Click to expand...

what is your "yes" for.. people/fans calling him God means he is overrated ? Or he is overrated anyway ?

He should have been dropped. He went to selectors saying he was not getting runs and it's their call now.. they gave him another chance... may be because of his overall reputation.

The point is not about his current performance.. I am asking is he overrated as an overall career ? Even Viv performed poorly in his twilight.. but do we call Viv overrated ?

Let us answer the right question.. do you feel he is overrated in terms of his place in the history is more than what he has done ? Let us not talk about his current performance which is anyway droppable.
 
WebGuru said:
Yea i agree with your point i am not talking about here at PP but i have seen the hype about raina on internet and in media...I personally rate Rohit higher thn Raina...
Click to expand...

Rohit is more "talented".. but is given so many chances.. he is so casual .. I feel Raina loses his wicket because of his inability to play certain deliveries.. Rohit does that coz may be he doesn't feel like playing.

Just look at Rohit's dismissals, in CT SF/final..
 
vicky_iisc said:
Rohit is more "talented".. but is given so many chances.. he is so casual .. I feel Raina loses his wicket because of his inability to play certain deliveries.. Rohit does that coz may be he doesn't feel like playing.

Just look at Rohit's dismissals, in CT SF/final..
Click to expand...

Rohit situation is similar to U Akmal they both do stupid things to get out while already going good with the bat and the silly stuff starts from their bat after they score 30-40 runs...
 
WebGuru said:
Rohit situation is similar to U Akmal they both do stupid things to get out while already going good with the bat and the silly stuff starts from their bat after they score 30-40 runs...
Click to expand...

Umar doesn't waste too many deliveries though. Talunted guy eats up way too many deliveries even after conditions have eased out.
 
WebGuru said:
Rohit situation is similar to U Akmal they both do stupid things to get out while already going good with the bat and the silly stuff starts from their bat after they score 30-40 runs...
Click to expand...

I think Akmal was a promising Test player. Rohit hasn't shown any Test match ability yet, so can;t compare.. let Rohit play a few Tests overseas.
 
leatherface58 said:
Umar doesn't waste too many deliveries though. Talunted guy eats up way too many deliveries even after conditions have eased out.
Click to expand...

vicky_iisc said:
I think Akmal was a promising Test player. Rohit hasn't shown any Test match ability yet, so can;t compare.. let Rohit play a few Tests overseas.
Click to expand...

I am not comparing them i am just saying that they are similar in one way which is getting out stupid way...
 
Overated:

Dilshan
Mathews
Duminy
Hafeez
Afridi
Pollard
Swann

Underated:

Darren Sammy
Yasir Hameed
Guptill
Jonathon Trott
Kulasekera
Sangakkara
Raza Hassan
 
leatherface58 said:
Underrated - Junaid especially by Amir maniacs who wish for him to fail so they can champion their cheat.
Overrated - Amir. He was good but one series does not make him Wasim. Not even close.
Click to expand...

This is blasphemy. For any avid lover of fast bowling, Amir was a breathe of fresh air. He was filled with natural talent and he had the skills to back them. It was an absolute joy to watch him run in and bowl swiniging deliveries at 145+K plus. For as long as I have been watching cricket Amir was the most naturally talented bowler to have come out in international cricket. Not only was he talented he was developing very quickly. Within a year of his debut, he developed the inswing amongst other variations and gained over 15ks in pace. He may be a cheater but you cannot deny the talent he possessed. That in itself would be an injustice.
 
Over-rated--Angelo Mathews,Dwayne Bravo
Under rated--Chanderpaul,irfan pathan in odis
 
RickyG said:
This is blasphemy. For any avid lover of fast bowling, Amir was a breathe of fresh air. He was filled with natural talent and he had the skills to back them. It was an absolute joy to watch him run in and bowl swiniging deliveries at 145+K plus. For as long as I have been watching cricket Amir was the most naturally talented bowler to have come out in international cricket. Not only was he talented he was developing very quickly. Within a year of his debut, he developed the inswing amongst other variations and gained over 15ks in pace. He may be a cheater but you cannot deny the talent he possessed. That in itself would be an injustice.
Click to expand...

Yes, let us keep morality out of on-field performance. Ricky Ponting may be one of the most arrogant/disliked players, but his greatness or rating as a player don't get lower because of that.

Amir was young and cheated, but was looking promising. Would have been nice to see if he performed consistently or not, had he been playing.
 
Lahiru Thirimanne another very underrated player the guy don't score so often average 30 with the bat but...Except one all his 50+ scores are in overseas conditions against top sides including his century against australia in australia...
 
Agree that Mathews is overrated. So is Chandimal
 
Saqs said:
Agree that Mathews is overrated.
Click to expand...

He maybe under whelming compared to other all rounders of the past but name one better all rounder going today.

And I'm not talking about spin bowling all rounders who are dime a dozen.
 
Overrated - Sir Jadeja, Pak overall bowling lineup, Fatshed, U Chand, Yadav, Broad, current Eng-Test Team

Underrated - Raina, Shafiq, NZ-overall bowling lineup, Misbah as captain & batsman,
 
All rounders better than Matthews.

Kallis. The grandfather of all rounders. Still the best in the business.
Watson is in another league.
Sammy is more destructive with the bat.
Razzaq would still outperform him in this age even.
Even Mitchell Johnson is a better all rounder option.

Mathews isn't even the best all rounder in the team. That's Kulasekara.
 
Saqs said:
All rounders better than Matthews.

Kallis. The grandfather of all rounders. Still the best in the business.
Watson is in another league.
Sammy is more destructive with the bat.
Razzaq would still outperform him in this age even.
Even Mitchell Johnson is a better all rounder option.

Mathews isn't even the best all rounder in the team. That's Kulasekara.
Click to expand...


It will be a pleasant surprise if Kallis plays another LOI for South Africa.

He is too old now and we all know where South Africa's priorities lie. They are going to preserve him for tests and he is hardly going to bowl. That is how they are going to squeeze a couple of years of test cricket out of him.

Watson is number one clearly. Funnily completely forgot about him :gul

Sammy isn't even close to Mathews. Not a competition.

Mathews can slot into most teams in the world purely as a batsman. Sammy is a completely bits n pieces cricketer.

No Razzaq cannot outperform him any more. He can match him in bowling but not in batting.

I seriously doubt that Razzaq can average 40 in test cricket today and 35 in ODIs. He's more likely to come up with more destructive knocks once in a while but in terms of reliability, no.

He is pretty much going to average less than 30 for the rest of his career.


Johnson?

The guy who averages 21 in tests and 16 in ODIs is a better option than Mathews?

Kulasakera is showing good promise with the bat but Mathews is still much more reliable.

Mathews isn't an all rounder in the league of Imran, Botham and Kapil that is for sure. Maybe as a batsman he is. He isn't destructive but he is a proper middle order batsman and his record reflects that. He is very likely going to end his career with a 40 or close to 40 average in both formats and that is excellent.

As a bowler, he is very mediocre. But he is still classified as an all rounder and is second only to Watson these days.

On top of that he is a proper pressure player.
 
vicky_iisc said:
Is Matthews a fast bowling allrounder ?
Click to expand...

Yes, he isn't express but bowls at the pace of Kallis and Razzaq (later part of his career).

A touch slower than Watson who cranks it up to 90 once in a while.
 
Shivnarine Chanderpaul is really underrated...The guy deserves more respect...
 
underrated - australian batsmen from no.8 - no.11
overrated - australian batsmen from no.1 - no.7

:D
 
Not by everybody but Wahab is really overrated by some here at PP
 
Come to think of it Misbah is very underrated in all forms of the game really. Good player! and may God bless him
 
Over-rated: Nathan Macculum,Dwayne Bravo,Moh.Amir ,Rohit Sharma,Morney Morkel
Under rated: Darren Sammy,R Jadeja (not anymore),Danish Kaneria,Chris Martin,Chanderpaul
 
Last edited:
Overrated - :afridi:wahab ,Darren Bravo, Akmal, Mathews, all other srilankans, JP duminy, Amla. gayle, Biggest is Polard. Tamim iqbal n other bangladeshi's. Dhawan, Zol, Mccullum brothers. Hafeez of course.

Underrated: Bhuvi,Misbah,Younis k, Sammy, Dhoni, Pujara, T Parera and few others
 
Last edited:
TonyStark said:
Overrated - :afridi:wahab ,Darren Bravo, Akmal, Mathews, all other srilankans, JP duminy, Amla. gayle, Biggest is Polard. Tamim iqbal n other bangladeshi's. Dhawan, Zol, Mccullum brothers. Hafeez of course.

Underrated: Bhuvi,Misbah,Younis k, Sammy, Dhoni, Pujara, T Parera and few others
Click to expand...

How is Hashim Aamla overrated?
 
TonyStark said:
Overrated - :afridi:wahab ,Darren Bravo, Akmal, Mathews, all other srilankans, JP duminy, Amla. gayle, Biggest is Polard. Tamim iqbal n other bangladeshi's. Dhawan, Zol, Mccullum brothers. Hafeez of course.

Underrated: Bhuvi,Misbah,Younis k, Sammy, Dhoni, Pujara, T Parera and few others
Click to expand...

How are all Lankans overrated specially Sanga and Jaya? I am surprised you are the first one in this thread who said Amla is overrated...
 
WebGuru said:
How are all Lankans overrated specially Sanga and Jaya? I am surprised you are the first one in this thread who said Amla is overrated...
Click to expand...

U can add new lankans there, Not sanga and mahela:farhat except these two all r garbage. They get spanked by us.

About Amla he is a good player no doubt, But not a match winner. Never saw him finish the matches like kohli and dhoni or even ABD. He chokes. U have a thread for it aswell. :misbah
 
Amla might be great but you cant depend or 100% rely on him. Like u Do on hussey and dhoni. I rate Hussey ahead of him. u can add hussey in underrated list.
 
Yawn.. is'nt a match winner the guy who usually scores more runs than everyone else? maybe i live in Lulu Land then
 
soso_killer said:
Yawn.. is'nt a match winner the guy who usually scores more runs than everyone else? maybe i live in Lulu Land then
Click to expand...

If that is so, why pakistanis question Sachin?:afridi

Dont u guys call him "Not a match winner?":yk

BTW Happy to be in Lulu land:zaka
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Bhaijaan
IPL : Career earnings
Replies
65
Views
2K
Bewal Express
B
FearlessRoar
Which ICC Champions Trophy match has been the most memorable for you?
Replies
37
Views
874
Shehmir
S
Unbiased-Fan
Best XI of each ICC Under19 World Cup
Replies
1
Views
1K
Unbiased-Fan
Unbiased-Fan
OMB
CSK [173/6] defeat DC [172/5] by 4 wickets in IPL 2021
2
Replies
93
Views
5K
globalcitizen
G
OMB
DC [139/7] defeat CSK [136/5] by 3 wickets in IPL 2021
Replies
23
Views
2K
MenInG
MenInG
Back
Top