The first thing we need to do is conduct IQ test on the potential candidates because babar turned out be a low IQ total dumb captain
Don’t think it’ll work - because I can tell you right now the top two scorers in IQ Test …. Shan Masood & Imam Ul Haq.
Conventional IQ test is based on memory (historical facts), linguistics (language skills), numerical aptitude & logical rationality- people with better academic background will always do better in such IQ tests …. In fact, I have taken many such IQ tests - my scores there and in GMAT is quite good, actually among top percentile - and, I’ll do dodo as cricket captain, not only as for my playing skills but also for my man management deficiency, ill temperament & individualistic nature…
In fact the most potential guy among next incumbents was dumb enough to post personal “pleasure moment” in social media.
The most cunning & street smart player in all sports combined that I have seen, probably was Diego Maradona - someone genius with ball at feet and equally sharp in his mind …. Not sure how much he could have scored in IQ test, but guy would need calculator to count how many players are on the field!!!!
Cricket Captain should be -
1. An automatic choice in playing XI on cricket merit
2. A strong character to lead from the front and stand strong under pressure (his individual performance won’t suffer for captaincy pressure - the best ones actually perform better as captain)
3. A great communicator, who can get the message to his team - English, Bangla, Urdu, Hindi or sign/body language doesn’t matter, doesn’t matter if he is talkative or very aloof … what it matters is getting the message to his team - Ian Chappel did that with his tongue & vocal cord; Imran did that with his eyes.
4. A fair guy, who would be honest, transparent & just to his players on playing merit, can put merit & team requirements above personal preferences
5. A quick decision maker, who is decisive with his decisions (not necessarily always correct), and bold enough to back it, not afraid of making mistakes
6. A great listener- an approachable guy, open to opinions/suggestions and ready to accept it, if it makes sense; not necessarily he’ll hug everyone, but will listen if anyone is asked for opinion - final call is his
7. A hunger for learning/collecting information- he learns from every mistake and remembers it for next time
8. A bold guy who live by the sword, ready to die by it as well - isn’t afraid to loose his job as captain, therefore doesn’t look for protections from his trusted ones
Unfortunately, apart from first one Babar doesn’t tick any other box - so he failed.