What's new

South Africa v India | Final ODI | Centurion | 23/01/2011

Status
Not open for further replies.
People really need to stop comparing cricketers with each other then their knocks to each others as it'll not always be of the same magnitude or situation in the game and plus both have their strengths and weaknesses.
 
People really need to stop comparing cricketers with each other then their knocks to each others as it'll not always be the same magnitude or situation in the game and plus both have their strengths and weaknesses.

Yes but...........but............
dazzlers innings was a lot better than fake pathans

bang bang
 
Razzaq's innings was great but Pathan's pips it as he played on a bowler friendly wicket..
 
Yes but...........but............
dazzlers innings was a lot better than fake pathans

bang bang

Why compare in the first place? Like I said it was different conditions i.e. pitch, over head conditions etc; and secondly whats with this naqli Pathan business?
 
I would rate them both on par with each other! :D

They were both great if the wickets were same then Razzaq's was better. However due to this being played on a hard bouncy wicket with overcast conditions I give a tiny edge to Pathan....
 
They were both great however if the wickets were same then Razzaq's was better. However due to this being played on a hard bouncy wicket with overcast conditions I give a tiny edge to Pathan....

Ok I'll actually give in on this! Your right both being great knocks but in terms of the conditions as Pathan's was at more of a bowlers track with some pace and bounce where as Razzaq's was on more of a pancake!
 
They were both great if the wickets were same then Razzaq's was better. However due to this being played on a hard bouncy wicket with overcast conditions I give a tiny edge to Pathan....

No offense, and I'm not downplaying Pathans innings but Razzlers actually won us the game, you know? Just saying.

Anyhow SA win. Grats to them :D
 
Well done yousuf & Zak.....well played both SAD & India through out the tour ...:14:14:

Test draw
T20 India
ODI SAF

very good series....:14:
 
No offense, and I'm not downplaying Pathans innings but Razzlers actually won us the game, you know? Just saying.

Anyhow SA win. Grats to them :D

Yeah thats true however I am not talking about a match winning knock here, I am comparing the difficulty level of both innings..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top