Support for Pakistan in India during ICC World Cup 2023

Have you not seen some of the posts ?

There are an ugly minority of fans literally waiting on Babar to fail so that they can jump and say i told you so.

There is always pressure when you are representing Pakistan.

We have one of the most toxic and least intelligent fan bases in the world.
I don't consider such people as Pak fans. They are more of lobbyists. Criticizing players is one thing but hating and wanting the team to fail is pathetic.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Among our big cities, Hyderabad has highest Muslim population at almost 50%, a lot of Islamic religious/cultural influence and in the older parts of the city the people support Pakistan against India as well. Hyderabad nizam wanted to merge with Pakistan in 1947. Expect lots of support there. Politicians there will be welcoming to Pakistan as well.

Kolkata and Chennai too have lot of support for Pakistan, but Chennai doesn't have a big Muslim population, just for some weird reason the crowds here like Pakistan. Politicians in these places are also pro-Pakistan, remember the Bengal CM felicitating Imran, Waqar, Wasim before the 2016 WT20 clash? It was surprising to see Kolkata supporting Pakistan over Bangladesh despite Bengal and Bangladesh having common language and culture.

Bengaluru will be strictly ok, not much support but neither hostility. Pakistan plays Australia and New Zealand in Bengaluru and Indian crowds tend to like players from those countries, maybe because of IPL or some other reason, tik tok, social media interactions, don't know. But certainly among visiting teams I see more support for Aus, NZ as opposed to England or Sri Lanka. Government there is Congress so don't expect any scene.

In fact in 4 of the 5 venues Pakistan will be playing, opposition parties are in power, not BJP. And these are not ordinary opposition parties but fiercely anti-BJP/RSS/Modi, and pro-Muslim. So you can expect some photo ops and felicitations thrown by the politicians to win over Muslim votes, like how Mamata Banerjee did in 2016.

Ahmedabad will be hostile, Gujarat is the bastion of BJP and of Narendra Modi, Amit Shah. Fiercely nationalistic crowd, and no love for Pakistan.

I have been as honest as possible here.

Back in 2010s, how were the vibes toward Pakistanis (actors, cricketers) in Gujarat and Ahmedabad?

What is the reason for the hate towards Pakistan in Ahmedabad? Is it because Sultan Ahmed Shah, a Muslim ruler of India, founded the city?
 
Have you not seen some of the posts on this forum?

There are an ugly minority of fans literally waiting on Babar to fail so that they can jump and say i told you so.

There is always pressure when you are representing Pakistan.

We have one of the most toxic and least intelligent fan bases in the world.

No Pak poster wants Babar or Pak to fail, there’s a small minority which I’m a part of that knows we are going to fail, it’s inevitable based on what we’ve seen from this team.

The majority were doing bhangra when we went to Number 1 in ODI’s as if it was true reflection on our team. The Asia cup brought the majority back down to earth.

We’ll still support the team, but we don’t expect this team to finish top 4.

Babar was the captain in 2019(?), he had 4 years to build a squad for this years World Cup and I know PCB is at fault for not scheduling enough ODI’s but we’re going into this World Cup with half of the players in the squad who haven’t proven themselves at the international level, and yet we’re taking them to the World Cup.

Australia played Cummins, Hazelwood and Starc in the same xi for the first time after 3 years(?), we play our best xi until we lose which isn’t going to happen too often when you’re playing B teams.
 
People who want Pakistan to fail are very few.

I dont think barring a few right wing Indian extremists (they know who they are) on this forum anyone hates Pakistani players.

However, I sometimes feel Pakistani fans hate Indian posters and Indian players more than vice versa.

This is what I have noticed over the last 14 years of my stay and I could be wrong.

I think safety of players is guaranteed inshAllah.

The BJP is not stupid.
 
No Pak poster wants Babar or Pak to fail, there’s a small minority which I’m a part of that knows we are going to fail, it’s inevitable based on what we’ve seen from this team.

The majority were doing bhangra when we went to Number 1 in ODI’s as if it was true reflection on our team. The Asia cup brought the majority back down to earth.

We’ll still support the team, but we don’t expect this team to finish top 4.

Babar was the captain in 2019(?), he had 4 years to build a squad for this years World Cup and I know PCB is at fault for not scheduling enough ODI’s but we’re going into this World Cup with half of the players in the squad who haven’t proven themselves at the international level, and yet we’re taking them to the World Cup.

Australia played Cummins, Hazelwood and Starc in the same xi for the first time after 3 years(?), we play our best xi until we lose which isn’t going to happen too often when you’re playing B teams.
But then again, you can only play what's put in front of you right? given that we don't play as much as the other teams, we can't fully blame us always playing our best xi. India can afford to rest the likes of Rohit and Kohli because they play so much more than us.
 
Man I've not been active on PP for a few months (maybe more than a year or so?), but seems like we have so many left field opinions.


I just saw a video from an India news channel on YouTube with the Pakistani team arriving in India. It seemed quite wholesome with the crowd cheering and folks shouting "Babar bhai" "Shaheen bhai" to get their attention for a photo. Then I made the mistake of scrolling down in the comments and they were so hateful. My God.
 
Me and a couple of friends have bought tickets for 25k each to watch pak-aus match in Bangalore and will be supporting Pakistan. Being an Indian, I dislike Indian team and don't want to win the cup. I feel that Pakistan public with all its been through, deserves the cup and happiness. Not everyone is polarized like you, many are happy to see Pakistan doing well. Don't spend too much time on twitter, it's polarized because that's how it is built and controlled.

Don't believe whats posted online. Thats a very good advise.
 
I just saw a video from an India news channel on YouTube with the Pakistani team arriving in India. It seemed quite wholesome with the crowd cheering and folks shouting "Babar bhai" "Shaheen bhai" to get their attention for a photo. Then I made the mistake of scrolling down in the comments and they were so hateful. My God.
Pakistanis and Indians are always friendly face to face. Especially when abroad the two get along like brethren when they see each other, to most casual outsiders they look like they're from the same country, share a similar language etc.. Plenty of Pakistanis and Indians live and work alongside each other as economic migrants all over the world with absolutely no issues. I've seen plenty of Ind-Pak games in uni on the big screen seated alongside and the atmosphere was brilliant.

The hate gets spewed online!
 
I don't buy the fact that there will be hostility towards Pakistani players even in Ahmedabad or north India.
A few miscrents might shout Zimbabar at Babar but that is not hostility, just a bit of banter. Seen that happening in Pakistan too.
99.99% of people come to watch good cricket, cheer for their team, mind their business and leave.
 
Good to see Muslims backing other Muslims regardless of man-made borders
You are amazing to say the least! No wonder, even in sports you guys won't ever be able to keep religion away. You keep on reminding Shoaib Malik's apology to 'Muslim brethren after the T20 final 2007, and quite fittingly Irfan Pathan was the MoM. Don't go by social media, it would only further the rift created by the politicians. Our cricket team is comprised of Md Siraj, Md Shami, I hope you don't insinuate they would support Pakistan. Same way many of us (non-muslims) idolized Wasim and Waqar, and copied their bowling action. Even after that Waqar made such a crass comment after their only WC win over India. So, even though it's a pak forum be a bit circumspect.
 
I don't buy the fact that there will be hostility towards Pakistani players even in Ahmedabad or north India.
A few miscrents might shout Zimbabar at Babar but that is not hostility, just a bit of banter. Seen that happening in Pakistan too.
99.99% of people come to watch good cricket, cheer for their team, mind their business and leave.
Exactly, even in a place like Mumbai (not sure if Pak is playing there) where people have every reason to be angry, will Pakistani cricketers face issues. Most people will enjoy the rivalry and move on.
 

We are looking foward to the next 1.5 months as well
Good to know they were welcomed with open hearts. That's what we Indians have been and should be known for. And some people on Twitter were driving the propaganda that they were given a cold welcome as evident by the fact that there were no flowers and bouquets for them at arrival.
 
Among our big cities, Hyderabad has highest Muslim population at almost 50%, a lot of Islamic religious/cultural influence and in the older parts of the city the people support Pakistan against India as well. Hyderabad nizam wanted to merge with Pakistan in 1947. Expect lots of support there. Politicians there will be welcoming to Pakistan as well.

Kolkata and Chennai too have lot of support for Pakistan, but Chennai doesn't have a big Muslim population, just for some weird reason the crowds here like Pakistan. Politicians in these places are also pro-Pakistan, remember the Bengal CM felicitating Imran, Waqar, Wasim before the 2016 WT20 clash? It was surprising to see Kolkata supporting Pakistan over Bangladesh despite Bengal and Bangladesh having common language and culture.

Bengaluru will be strictly ok, not much support but neither hostility. Pakistan plays Australia and New Zealand in Bengaluru and Indian crowds tend to like players from those countries, maybe because of IPL or some other reason, tik tok, social media interactions, don't know. But certainly among visiting teams I see more support for Aus, NZ as opposed to England or Sri Lanka. Government there is Congress so don't expect any scene.

In fact in 4 of the 5 venues Pakistan will be playing, opposition parties are in power, not BJP. And these are not ordinary opposition parties but fiercely anti-BJP/RSS/Modi, and pro-Muslim. So you can expect some photo ops and felicitations thrown by the politicians to win over Muslim votes, like how Mamata Banerjee did in 2016.

Ahmedabad will be hostile, Gujarat is the bastion of BJP and of Narendra Modi, Amit Shah. Fiercely nationalistic crowd, and no love for Pakistan.

I have been as honest as possible here.
Good post, you have said more or less what I have in my minds. Despite all the crazy propaganda & huge shift in mentality for a huge portion of population in last one decade I am pretty confident Pak team will be received warmly in general as long as they are playing in south & east parts of India(Where they will play most of their matches anyway). Obviously things are extreme & completely opposite in the north /west zone but since they will have to play maximum two games there they shouldn't be worried. Chennai, Kalkata & Hyderabad have always appreciated Pak even when they were playing against Ind. So I think that won't change too much this time around. They have always admired aggressive passionate cricket from Pak which historically all the visiting sides from 80's to 2000's were known for.
Who do you think Indians will support the most other than Pak? Specially considering WI isn't here this time who have always enjoyed massive support in Ind. Sri used to have a lot of fans but that was during their glory years with dozens of mega stars. Don't think the current mediocre side will move the Indians much. I don't expect much for Aus & Eng, they may secretly admire the way these two play modern cricket but I don't think that secret adulation will come open. So who do you think Indians will support the most? As local & educated fan you should have acute idea.
 
Babar looking good with orange :D

NWAqPm6.png
 
IA. Have met some Hyderabadi people and they are extremely nice and courteous. Their Urdu accent is indistinguishable from Pakistan's. Pak might get a fairly neutral environment in South as well I think (if any game is scheduled there)
Yup! One thing Pakistani players will find familiar in Hyderabad is that they will see a lot of things written in Urdu as well!
 
Good post, you have said more or less what I have in my minds. Despite all the crazy propaganda & huge shift in mentality for a huge portion of population in last one decade I am pretty confident Pak team will be received warmly in general as long as they are playing in south & east parts of India(Where they will play most of their matches anyway). Obviously things are extreme & completely opposite in the north /west zone but since they will have to play maximum two games there they shouldn't be worried. Chennai, Kalkata & Hyderabad have always appreciated Pak even when they were playing against Ind. So I think that won't change too much this time around. They have always admired aggressive passionate cricket from Pak which historically all the visiting sides from 80's to 2000's were known for.
Who do you think Indians will support the most other than Pak? Specially considering WI isn't here this time who have always enjoyed massive support in Ind. Sri used to have a lot of fans but that was during their glory years with dozens of mega stars. Don't think the current mediocre side will move the Indians much. I don't expect much for Aus & Eng, they may secretly admire the way these two play modern cricket but I don't think that secret adulation will come open. So who do you think Indians will support the most? As local & educated fan you should have acute idea.
Support for NZ is ever present, irrespective of the pastings we've received from them during Ko's because of the dignity/honour with which they conduct themselves. SA may also get good support. Pak will get good support from the crowds (in South and east) than the pitches as the specific opponents they play against are dangerous for those particular type of pitches. For all the tensions, BJP has played safely by scheduling most pak matches in states which don't hold animosity towards Pak.
 
Got my tickets for Pakistan - Sri Lanka game folks, God willing I'll be there to watch along with my cousins!!! Fingers crossed not to get any critical work at office and I get my leave approved!!!
Hopefully your presence will prove a lucky charm for Pak that day. :)
 
Depends on what you make out of that word welcome.

Most teams will be greeted by fans outside the airport. Its a part of sporting culture of India.
But you know very well that Pakistan and India in eyes og eachother are not like most other teams. There is a speciall history there.

Anyways don’t want to derail the thread, as mentioned before it was a very good and heartning welcome, those people turning up must be praised.
 
Support for NZ is ever present, irrespective of the pastings we've received from them during Ko's because of the dignity/honour with which they conduct themselves. SA may also get good support. Pak will get good support from the crowds (in South and east) than the pitches as the specific opponents they play against are dangerous for those particular type of pitches. For all the tensions, BJP has played safely by scheduling most pak matches in states which don't hold animosity towards Pak.
I think there was a lot of love for SA players in India during the time of ABD, Faf, Steyn etc. Australia as well due to their IPL presence.
 
Got my tickets for Pakistan - Sri Lanka game folks, God willing I'll be there to watch along with my cousins!!! Fingers crossed not to get any critical work at office and I get my leave approved!!!
I am trying hard to get Pak Vs Nz, extend your support if u can 😀
 
But you know very well that Pakistan and India in eyes og eachother are not like most other teams. There is a speciall history there.

Anyways don’t want to derail the thread, as mentioned before it was a very good and heartning welcome, those people turning up must be praised.

People turned up in much larger numbers when Imran's team or Wasim Akram's team came here. These people actually had huge fan following in India.

In 80s and 90s it was common to see posters of some pakistani cricketers in sports clubs or magazines.

That has not been the case for last 2 decades or so.

What you are seeing here are people inside airport who are excited at seeing cricket stars up close and a small crowd outside.

20 years back the reception would have been 10 times bigger.
 
Back in 2010s, how were the vibes toward Pakistanis (actors, cricketers) in Gujarat and Ahmedabad?

What is the reason for the hate towards Pakistan in Ahmedabad? Is it because Sultan Ahmed Shah, a Muslim ruler of India, founded the city?
Gujarat has been anti-Pakistan for the last 20-25 years, BJP captured the state at the turn of the millennium and have made Gujarat their fortress. A series of events happened which caused all this, was different in 90s and before. But I don't want to derail this thread by talking about politics.
 
People who want Pakistan to fail are very few.

I dont think barring a few right wing Indian extremists (they know who they are) on this forum anyone hates Pakistani players.

However, I sometimes feel Pakistani fans hate Indian posters and Indian players more than vice versa.

This is what I have noticed over the last 14 years of my stay and I could be wrong.

I think safety of players is guaranteed inshAllah.

The BJP is not stupid.
People often forget that Wasim Akram was a much-liked cricketer in India for his ability and charisma and it didn't matter to Indians that he was a Pakistani even when we were fighting over Kargil, lol. Whatever his personal failings, he was clearly the only Pakistani player in the late 90's who had the EQ and the social skills to be genuinely friendly with even players of a "hostile" nation while being careful enough not to bring religion/politics when the situation was quite "delicate" .

There's that story of the 2003 World Cup encounter when we hadn't played each other in 3 years and Akram was the only Pakistani player who came over to chat with the Indian team. These things are not lost on Indian fans.

There were far too many incidents though of other Pakistani cricketers making foolish/provocative statements and actions which soured things a lot.

Akhtar and Afridi claiming Sachin was scared of the ball

Akhtar patting Sachin on the head in an extremely condescending manner

Afridi claiming Indians have small hearts and then going on to specifically thank Kashmiris while he was captain in a thoughtless, provocative manner while he was in India :)))

Sohail Tanvir talking smack about Hindus/Indians

Imran Nazir calling us "buzdil"

Waqar praising Rizwan for doing namaz in front of Hindus - like its some sort of achievement

And many Pakistanis/foreign-based Pakistanis not only supported this stuff but mocked us for being docile, soft and often drew allegories of medieval Muslim conquerors who conquered the Hindus :facepalm


PCB did not even bother to reign in active cricketers who indulged in this stuff.

Whereas our cricketers from the 90's were absolute gentlemen and were professional who rarely commented on anything regarding Pakistan.

Imagine if Sourav Ganguly as captain decided to do an Afridi in a presser 2 days before Multan Test in 2004 and said he was celebrating Bangladesh Liberation Day?

But they didn't do that because they carried themselves like proper cricket diplomats who had enough sense not to provoke in a delicate situation.

Only post Mumbai 26/11, did our cricketers(even then, mostly ex-cricketers) started stooping to that level with the likes of Sehwag making crass comments , Gambhir mocking Afridi, Irfan Pathan trolling and baiting fans etc.

Before that, it was 100 % a one way street. Indian cricket fans and cricketers, with increasing conservatism in the country, became less gracious and absolutely unsympathetic to the plight of Pakistan cricket.

Before, there were wars, alleged ISI sponsored terrorism etc, Kashmir dispute but even then a right wing BJP government under Vajpayee wanted that "Jeet Lo Dil" series to go ahead. Many won't accept it but PCB were near broke and desperately wanted that series because of their broadcast deal with Ten Sports. Nowadays, even a left wing Indian government won't let that happen. But back then, Vajpayee could have been petty about it but he chose not to be.


I think this World Cup match between India and Pakistan is very important and more important than people admit. If it can start people-to-people and cricket-fan-to-cricket fan interactions and exchanges, this can genuinely restart bilateral cricket relations if once again Indians become genuine admirers of Pakistan cricket like they were of a Wasim Akram in the past.

There's a definite change in the air with regards to Pakistani cricket at least and Shaheen's gesture towards Bumrah when he became a father, the mutual respect between Babar, Virat, Rizwan and Rohit etc. has not gone unnoticed and most Indians know that it's not just a PR stunt when PAK cricketers do that nowadays. Intentions are everything.

Bobby, Rizzy, Shaheen are not only damn good cricketers but they are also complete pros and they represent PAK with a lot of dignity and class. Even the most right-wing Indian who can't stand the idea of Pakistan as an ideological construct and a physical reality cannot deny or resist admiring that

This could be the beginning of something very beautiful at least cricket-wise, and, hopefully, something more going forward.
 
Support for NZ is ever present, irrespective of the pastings we've received from them during Ko's because of the dignity/honour with which they conduct themselves. SA may also get good support. Pak will get good support from the crowds (in South and east) than the pitches as the specific opponents they play against are dangerous for those particular type of pitches. For all the tensions, BJP has played safely by scheduling most pak matches in states which don't hold animosity towards Pak.
So basically what you are saying is Nz will be the most supported overseas team after Pak? Well I can see some logic. I don't know about SA honestly, I always thought those crazy fanfare they used to receive were for particular players(AB,Steyn,Amla), before that for guys like Donald & Klusner. Current generation has no such name who will attract many Indians. Miller potentially, but he is no way near as big those past legends were. So maybe you are right, Nz is the one other than Pak who will probably receive some warmth due to their good boy image. What do you about Afg? Based on online Indians seem to have lot more sympathy for them compared to what they have for Pak, Ban or Sri. I see them getting lot support in SENA matches as well as against Pak & Ban.
 
Who do you think Indians will support the most other than Pak? Specially considering WI isn't here this time who have always enjoyed massive support in Ind. Sri used to have a lot of fans but that was during their glory years with dozens of mega stars. Don't think the current mediocre side will move the Indians much. I don't expect much for Aus & Eng, they may secretly admire the way these two play modern cricket but I don't think that secret adulation will come open. So who do you think Indians will support the most? As local & educated fan you should have acute idea.
Among crowds, apart from India and maybe Afghanistan, Pakistan will get maximum support especially in Kolkata, Chennai, Hyderabad. Though Australia and NZ are well liked here, NZ because of their good boys reputation and Australia because of IPL, social media interactions etc. In some venues Aus, NZ will be most liked behind India. South Africa was supported when AB was playing, not the case now since our people aren't familiar with many of their players. West Indies always had a fanbase here, unfortunately they aren't coming this time. England has a fanbase in Jaipur because of IPL but no match scheduled there. Sri Lankan and Bangladeshi players aren't well known, so will be mostly ignored.

Chennai crowd appreciates good cricket, so all teams will get support here if they do well. I have got tickets for 4 games in the city, if my boss is kind I will try to watch the games.

If I were to summarize, had Pakistan fielded more charismatic players they would have definitely been number 2. But I am leaning towards Afghanistan because of Rashid Khan and other T20 league stars, also many Indians have a soft corner for the country, remember India has been the home venue for Afghans for many years now. Pakistan at number 3, but NZ, Aus will be comfortably ahead in venues like Bengaluru, Pak any way is limited to just 5 venues.
 
Not to forget, Pakistan will be at home in Hyderabad because of the use of Urdu in signboards as well as in communication with many locals. People there speak Urdu supposedly in a funny accent but still apart from Lucknow, Bhopal and Delhi, Hyderabad is a centre for the language. And cuisine is also supposedly very similar to Pakistan's, though I presume cricketers will be very careful about their diets, more fitness conscious.
 
Pak will play back to back games in Hyderabad and Chennai, in fact 4 consecutive games in Hyderabad if you count the warm up fixtures. One Bengaluru game between 2 Kolkata ones.

Great chance to get acclimatized to local conditions, and not just in the field.
 
Pak will play back to back games in Hyderabad and Chennai, in fact 4 consecutive games in Hyderabad if you count the warm up fixtures. One Bengaluru game between 2 Kolkata ones.

Great chance to get acclimatized to local conditions, and not just in the field.

To be honest the schedule is very kind to us. Not much travelling and play weaker teams first 2 games to build confidence.
 
To be honest the schedule is very kind to us. Not much travelling and play weaker teams first 2 games to build confidence.
Also if Pak make semis, they know it is Eden Gardens, Kolkata. Other semifinalists will probably be confused till final day, but Pak can make plans much earlier, they anyway will be playing 2 games in Kolkata including against defending world champions. The pitches in Kolkata and Mumbai have polar opposite nature, need entirely different tactics and team selection for those 2 venues. SENA teams will prefer Mumbai, India and Pak will prefer Kolkata. No team would want to take on England in Mumbai.
 
Also if Pak make semis, they know it is Eden Gardens, Kolkata. Other semifinalists will probably be confused till final day, but Pak can make plans much earlier, they anyway will be playing 2 games in Kolkata including against defending world champions. The pitches in Kolkata and Mumbai have polar opposite nature, need entirely different tactics and team selection for those 2 venues. SENA teams will prefer Mumbai, India and Pak will prefer Kolkata. No team would want to take on England in Mumbai.

You love for Pak is very aparent in this thread. Which team you will be supporting this world cup bro?? Especially on 14th Oct in Ahmedabad?

:kp
 
So basically what you are saying is Nz will be the most supported overseas team after Pak? Well I can see some logic. I don't know about SA honestly, I always thought those crazy fanfare they used to receive were for particular players(AB,Steyn,Amla), before that for guys like Donald & Klusner. Current generation has no such name who will attract many Indians. Miller potentially, but he is no way near as big those past legends were. So maybe you are right, Nz is the one other than Pak who will probably receive some warmth due to their good boy image. What do you about Afg? Based on online Indians seem to have lot more sympathy for them compared to what they have for Pak, Ban or Sri. I see them getting lot support in SENA matches as well as against Pak & Ban.
Yeah, current gen SA players are not known to every common man over here unlike AB, Steyn et all. Ah i forgot Afg. They'll receive a lot of support here. Known both for their quick rise, performance and the difficulty they've come up with back home, they have a lot of soft corner here. Afg will absolutely get massive support here - I'll put them above NZ/SA/PAK in that regard. It's a funny thought isn't it, that the neighbour to your neighbour is always liked but neighbours always quarrel among each other. Not just in cricket/politics but it happens in every walk of life.
 
BJP may hate Pakistan but they aren't stupid. I think venues were carefully chosen in such a way that Pak got games in states where opposition is in power, to ensure they are conducted safely, lessens the security headache as well as costs. Had Kerala or Punjab been in contention they too would have got at least one Pak game.

Indo-Pak game was of course meant to be played in the biggest stadium in the world, with the PM in attendance, the stadium too bears his name. Too big an opportunity of self promotion to let go, I can already imagine him walking away with credit if India beats Pak there. Autocratic leaders often use sports for propaganda, self-aggrandizement, like Hitler in 1936 Berlin Olympics or more recently Putin in Sochi winter Olympics and the FIFA World Cup, also Xi Jinping with his winter Olympics. Modi isn't that much of a dictator because of checks and balances, but comes close, like Indira Gandhi hosting the 1982 Asian Games and making it all about herself and for elections. We also have general elections next year, consider this as part of the overall election campaign.

Kolkata, Mumbai, Chennai, Bengaluru, Mohali, Delhi are historically much more important venues for Indian cricket, but the final will be played in Narendra Modi Stadium, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. Tells you a lot, doesn't it?
 
I want Pakistan cricket team to be treated with utmost respect and hospitality. In India, guests are treated as Gods as there is an age old Sanskrit proverb - 'Atithi Devo Bhava'.

However, can I be brutally honest (like always)?

I don't think Pakistan team will be getting support anywhere in India. Back during 2016 T20 WC they got a lot of support in Eden Gardens as Kolkata is a fairly liberal city. Remember how Chief minister Mamta Banerjee felicitated Imran Khan, Wasim and Waqar prior to the Ind-Pak match. But lot has changed in the last 7 years. The atmosphere is very polarized in India now and no one in his/her right mind would support Pakistan (willingly or unwillingly). In fact I won't be surprised if they get verbal abuse as well from fans while walking to airport or going to stadium etc. Lets put it this way, Indians don't want any Pakistani's to be in their soil 1 sec more than what is required for ICC tournament.

Pak players should just focus on cricket, stick to their schedule and only go to places they are allocated to go.

So just for clarification, you don’t want the Pakistani team to be in India for one second more than what is required from the ICC. Please be brutally honest like you ‘normally’ are? I’m not asking about India as a nation, I’m asking about you personally
 
Funny how some Indian posters bragging that southern states of India are better in behaviour than northern states and terming them hostile. The superiority complex is quite visible in people from southern states.

Come out of your wonderland. Be it Pak or any other top team, they'll get equal treatment from fans because people love celebrities all over the world. Not everyday they see international players in their city or country specially Pak players who don't play in IPL.
Not to forget the huge population which has all kinds of people. People who admire players for their skills, who dislikes them because of rivalry and neutral fans who appreciate players irrespective of their country etc.
No matter where they play they'll get similar reception.
People from north are not holding stones in their hands and waiting for players to come.

We'll definitely see news like some fans making below belt comments to players fielding near boundaries but that happens in every part of the world. Asian players face these kinda things in SENA too. What's new?
Even some politically motivated people will protest here and there for playing against Pak but that'll be taken care with proper security and due process. And these protesting people will be no where near any team.
Off course some posters here including few admins waiting for moments like that so they can make a storm in a tea cup.

At the end this will be a good experience for all players to visit and play in India. And they may make it more memorable if perform well.
 
Very well put @Swashbuckler, you have explained in details with logic.As you can see you & I have similar thoughts on this particular topic. I see Afg getting a lot of support in at least 7 matches (SENA,Pak,Ban,Ned). I think they will be treated as almost a home side on those matches. That might trigger one or two upsets as these Afgans always look extra motivated whenever they receive some decent ground support.
You are about Pak lacking that x factor. Despite so much anti Pak agenda running wild all over India I think general people would have still gravitated towards a Pak team who had more charisma, character, star power & aggression. There's a reason why people like Imran,W's, Akhter, Afridi, Saqlain,Anwar even Aamir used to have legions of fans. If the current Pak would play a more exciting risky brand they would have received more support. Having said that I think Babar, Shaheen, Fakhar, Rauf these guys have lot of curiosity & intrigue amongst Indians.
 
BJP may hate Pakistan but they aren't stupid. I think venues were carefully chosen in such a way that Pak got games in states where opposition is in power, to ensure they are conducted safely, lessens the security headache as well as costs. Had Kerala or Punjab been in contention they too would have got at least one Pak game.

Indo-Pak game was of course meant to be played in the biggest stadium in the world, with the PM in attendance, the stadium too bears his name. Too big an opportunity of self promotion to let go, I can already imagine him walking away with credit if India beats Pak there. Autocratic leaders often use sports for propaganda, self-aggrandizement, like Hitler in 1936 Berlin Olympics or more recently Putin in Sochi winter Olympics and the FIFA World Cup, also Xi Jinping with his winter Olympics. Modi isn't that much of a dictator because of checks and balances, but comes close, like Indira Gandhi hosting the 1982 Asian Games and making it all about herself and for elections. We also have general elections next year, consider this as part of the overall election campaign.

Kolkata, Mumbai, Chennai, Bengaluru, Mohali, Delhi are historically much more important venues for Indian cricket, but the final will be played in Narendra Modi Stadium, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. Tells you a lot, doesn't it?
So much nonsense is being spouted here.

1987 WC final in Kolkata. Why? Dalmiya was the most influential man at the BCCI.

2011 WC final in Mumbai. Despite the fact that Wankhede only has a capacity of 32k. Why? Sharad Pawar and Shashank Manohar were ruling the BCCI.

2023 WC final in Ahmedabad, its another thing that its capacity is 134000 and its the biggest stadium in the world, its because Jay Shah is ruling BCCI.

If Dalmiya or Pawar weren't wrong why criticize Jay Shah and drag in Modi.
 
He is right.

Religion trumps nationality, hence majority of Indian Muslims support Pakistan Over India. Ethnicity trumps religion, hence majority of Pakistani-based Pashtuns support Afghanistan over Pakistan.

Indians and Pakistanis can deny above facts all they want but these are the facts.
 
So much nonsense is being spouted here.

1987 WC final in Kolkata. Why? Dalmiya was the most influential man at the BCCI.

2011 WC final in Mumbai. Despite the fact that Wankhede only has a capacity of 32k. Why? Sharad Pawar and Shashank Manohar were ruling the BCCI.

2023 WC final in Ahmedabad, its another thing that its capacity is 134000 and its the biggest stadium in the world, its because Jay Shah is ruling BCCI.

If Dalmiya or Pawar weren't wrong why criticize Jay Shah and drag in Modi.
Are you seriously going to compare Eden Gardens and Wankhede with this new stadium, in terms of legacy and importance to Indian cricket? And appropriately named Narendra Modi stadium lol, that too when he is alive.
 
He is right.

Religion trumps nationality, hence majority of Indian Muslims support Pakistan Over India. Ethnicity trumps religion, hence majority of Pakistani-based Pashtuns support Afghanistan over Pakistan.

Indians and Pakistanis can deny above facts all they want but these are the facts.

Majority of Muslims in India don't support Pakistan. Infact whatever support Pakistan had is diminishing with each generation.
 
Are you seriously going to compare Eden Gardens and Wankhede with this new stadium, in terms of legacy and importance to Indian cricket? And appropriately named Narendra Modi stadium lol, that too when he is alive.
What's the name of the stadium has to do with the fact that it's the best stadium in India as of now?
 
I will say that Pakistan does have support from the Indian crowd always. Never really have to see a point where the Pakistan team is left alone and stranded when they played some good cricket. I really hope that all goes well during this tournament and may the best team wins.
 
You are amazing to say the least! No wonder, even in sports you guys won't ever be able to keep religion away. You keep on reminding Shoaib Malik's apology to 'Muslim brethren after the T20 final 2007, and quite fittingly Irfan Pathan was the MoM. Don't go by social media, it would only further the rift created by the politicians. Our cricket team is comprised of Md Siraj, Md Shami, I hope you don't insinuate they would support Pakistan. Same way many of us (non-muslims) idolized Wasim and Waqar, and copied their bowling action. Even after that Waqar made such a crass comment after their only WC win over India. So, even though it's a pak forum be a bit circumspect.


Go to an Indian forum if you want circumspect or whatever it is that you think is “circumspect”.
 
Are you seriously going to compare Eden Gardens and Wankhede with this new stadium, in terms of legacy and importance to Indian cricket? And appropriately named Narendra Modi stadium lol, that too when he is alive.

What is Wankhede's legacy? The stadium itself was a vanity project of SK Wankhede a politician and secretary of then Bombay cricket association and BCCI.

He had issues with CCI president and former India great Vijay merchant and Wankhede being the politician went on an ego trip. Built a stadium and named it after himself.

All the history and legacy is at the Brabourne stadium except the 2011 WC win.

Btw do you know how and when the stadiums in Chennai and Bangalore named?
 
Majority of Muslims in India don't support Pakistan. Infact whatever support Pakistan had is diminishing with each generation.
This I agree with, atleast in the urban/sub-urban areas there is massive diminish in such blind support, if not for any. Education, rise in societal status and intermingling has played a huge part in it. Also Muslim players are very much part of our national, u19 and A teams. They have fair representation at all levels from all regions without any bias against them. This has contributed too!
 
Are you seriously going to compare Eden Gardens and Wankhede with this new stadium, in terms of legacy and importance to Indian cricket? And appropriately named Narendra Modi stadium lol, that too when he is alive.
A lot of cricket stadiums in India are named after the local cricket association presidents. Eg: Chinnaswamy in Bangalore, M.A.Chidambaram in Chennai, Arun Jaitley in Delhi etc. Narendra Modi was the president of the Gujarat Cricket Association and so the stadium is named after him. It was much before he became PM.
 
This I agree with, atleast in the urban/sub-urban areas there is massive diminish in such blind support, if not for any. Education, rise in societal status and intermingling has played a huge part in it. Also Muslim players are very much part of our national, u19 and A teams. They have fair representation at all levels from all regions without any bias against them. This has contributed too!
We used to have muslim kids in Hyderabad celebrating Pakistan victories with fireworks in the 1990s, when their own fellow Hyderabadi muslim, M.Azharuddin, was the captain of the Indian team. And muslims have always been represented in the Indian cricket setup.
So I don't think the representation was the issue back then. I don't know what the situation is now, but if there is more support among India's muslims for the Indian team then that is a good thing.
 
I want Pakistan cricket team to be treated with utmost respect and hospitality. In India, guests are treated as Gods as there is an age old Sanskrit proverb - 'Atithi Devo Bhava'.

However, can I be brutally honest (like always)?

I don't think Pakistan team will be getting support anywhere in India. Back during 2016 T20 WC they got a lot of support in Eden Gardens as Kolkata is a fairly liberal city. Remember how Chief minister Mamta Banerjee felicitated Imran Khan, Wasim and Waqar prior to the Ind-Pak match. But lot has changed in the last 7 years. The atmosphere is very polarized in India now and no one in his/her right mind would support Pakistan (willingly or unwillingly). In fact I won't be surprised if they get verbal abuse as well from fans while walking to airport or going to stadium etc. Lets put it this way, Indians don't want any Pakistani's to be in their soil 1 sec more than what is required for ICC tournament.

Pak players should just focus on cricket, stick to their schedule and only go to places they are allocated to go.
Such a great representation of secular India!
 
Many Indians settled in England and Australia support India when we tour those places. They come in Indian attire, bring Indian musical instruments, sing patriotic Indian songs, but locals there don't mind it. But how quick we are to judge our own citizens over something as trivial as a cricket match.
 
Funny how some Indian posters bragging that southern states of India are better in behaviour than northern states and terming them hostile. The superiority complex is quite visible in people from southern states.

Come out of your wonderland. Be it Pak or any other top team, they'll get equal treatment from fans because people love celebrities all over the world. Not everyday they see international players in their city or country specially Pak players who don't play in IPL.
Not to forget the huge population which has all kinds of people. People who admire players for their skills, who dislikes them because of rivalry and neutral fans who appreciate players irrespective of their country etc.
No matter where they play they'll get similar reception.
People from north are not holding stones in their hands and waiting for players to come.

We'll definitely see news like some fans making below belt comments to players fielding near boundaries but that happens in every part of the world. Asian players face these kinda things in SENA too. What's new?
Even some politically motivated people will protest here and there for playing against Pak but that'll be taken care with proper security and due process. And these protesting people will be no where near any team.
Off course some posters here including few admins waiting for moments like that so they can make a storm in a tea cup.

At the end this will be a good experience for all players to visit and play in India. And they may make it more memorable if perform well.
I don't think anybody mentioned anything along those lines. At least that was not the intention. It is true that large parts of Southern India don't have that much of baggage from Partition. It is only natural for people in the North and West to have such intense passions because they probably grew up listening to horror stories of Partition from their parents and grandparents where they lost lives and property etc.

It'll forever be ingrained in their psyche in a way that South Indians can never relate to. It was the greatest refugee crisis before Syria after all.

And similarly, you'll never understand the pain the Tamils feel when they think of the Tamil refugee crisis when their own kith and kin were forced to be refugees.

When Lankan players weren't safe in Chennai and didn't play there at some point, we heard massive criticisms about Tamils being illiberal from those up North who could not understand it at all.

I doubt you have spent two seconds of your life thinking about it. So, obviously, Lankan players will feel no threat when they play in Northern India unlike in Chennai.

This is just the other side of the coin.

Having said that, the threat to Pakistani cricketers in Indian cities is massively overrated on PP. The bigger Indian cities(east,west,north and south) have plenty of working folks who are too busy making ends meet, trying to get their kids through school, negotiating horrible traffic etc. and they just want to see India beat Pakistan, maybe shout a bit, troll a bit on Twitter and then go back to their routines on Monday.

And whether people like it on here or not it's far safer for Pakistanis in India than the other way around because GOI has literally no competition. No rogue ISI/military trying to destabilise the government and the consequences for anything that hurts GOI image when the world is watching will be absolutely brutal. I expect some pre-emptive arrests and detentions before this match to keep all the crooks (even if their own paid agents) in line. Only empty shouting and trolling but that can't be stopped.

Also, I think this fake internet affection for South Indians from a certain section of Pakistanis based on interactions abroad is extremely far from reality

A large number of northern migrants to cities like Bangalore and Chennai absolutely struggle with the cultural shock, the almost absent usage of Hindi and greater usage of regional languages , the cuisine , the movies, the relatively insular nature of the people who can never truly accept a pan-Indian identity and are steeped in their own ethnic identities .

And Southern migrants to the North struggle for the opposite reasons .

What natural affinity can there be with Pashtuns, Baloch, Pakistani Punjabis and Sindhis for us southerners when you are even further apart from the people up North?


Visiting South India as a tourist or interacting in professional spaces abroad is completely different.


It's only the people from the Gangetic plains and upwards who can understand your languages, appreciate Punjabi/Sufi poetry, probably watch the same movies and listen to the same songs. Most likely even use similar cuss words. Most South Indians don't know enough about any of that stuff nor do they care about it.

Most Pakistani Pakistanis(Not from UK, Kaneda ) will relate to someone like @Bhaijaan much more and strike a conversation easily.

With traditional South Indians and even with heavily anglicised, convent-educated types like me - not so much.
 
I am trying hard to get Pak Vs Nz, extend your support if u can 😀
You should be able to get it mate! Initially it was a problem, but now the tickets are getting booked easily. Not sure about Bangalore games though. Also keep checking, a few days back they were showing some categories as sold out but now they are available again!
 
Many Indians settled in England and Australia support India when we tour those places. They come in Indian attire, bring Indian musical instruments, sing patriotic Indian songs, but locals there don't mind it. But how quick we are to judge our own citizens over something as trivial as a cricket match.

Maybe bcoz they are Indians?? :vk1

Anyway, no one is judging you brother. As you rightly said its just a game of cricket. I would request you too wear Pakistani attire and sing Dil Dil Pakistan while watching their game somwhere in Chennai. Its time for Indian liberals to shower their love openly for Pakistan and show the world that we are a secular nation.
 
Good to see Muslims backing other Muslims regardless of man-made borders
Its foolish to assume all the fans present in the airport were muslims. If Kohli and Indian team visits Pakistan most of the pakistan fans who will shower their love will be muslims. So you can keep religion aside atleast for once.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Majority of Muslims in India don't support Pakistan. Infact whatever support Pakistan had is diminishing with each generation.
This is actually true at least in Bangalore. Many Muslims here used to be Pakistani supporters (although the majority still supported India) but in recent times that has declined a lot.

Some have simply become secular/less religious/non-practicing, some identify with a more pan-Islamic identity(rarer now but still there) but most simply don't see the Pakistani state as reflective of a South Asian Muslim identity anymore because it's been 2 generations and they are a bit too far removed geographically, chronologically and culturally.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It was just my opinion brother but check the subsequent posts from my fellow Indians and how they are showering full love on Pak cricket team. Probably that represents secular India and not just my idea alone?
There are always different sides. I'm sure many, MANY people in India has cricket fans will love watching Pakistan...and Aus, and Eng etc etc. I hope its a festival of cricket in cricket's largest territories but we also know for a fact there are major security concerns, history of violence at matches and hate fuelled rhetoric that could derail the matches at any point.

Recognising one side does not deny the other.
 
Back in 2010s, how were the vibes toward Pakistanis (actors, cricketers) in Gujarat and Ahmedabad?

What is the reason for the hate towards Pakistan in Ahmedabad? Is it because Sultan Ahmed Shah, a Muslim ruler of India, founded the city?
I think Pakistani team played t20 in Ahmedabad in 2013 series and it passed of witout any events. As for actors, they would usually shoot in Mumbai but if I am right mahira Khan shot for raees in Gujarat and everything wnet about peacefully without and controversies.

The reason people believe Ahmedabad will be hostile is because firstly the government there has been from BJP for past 25 years. Secondly, the Gujarat 2002 riots might be anotehr reason for people to believe that the people there hate muslims and will be hostile. But Pakistan has already played there in 2013 and teh crowd were same as any other crowd in India.
 
There are always different sides. I'm sure many, MANY people in India has cricket fans will love watching Pakistan...and Aus, and Eng etc etc. I hope its a festival of cricket in cricket's largest territories but we also know for a fact there are major security concerns, history of violence at matches and hate fuelled rhetoric that could derail the matches at any point.

Recognising one side does not deny the other.

There are no security concerns at all...else a responsible board like PCB wouldn't have send its team. You saying Pak cricket board send its players deliberately to play in a territory where there are security threats? OMG
 
Star Sports Promo for Pakistan Cricket Team, Specifically Highlighting the Number 1 ODI Batter in the World, King Babar Azam
 
Maybe bcoz they are Indians?? :vk1

Anyway, no one is judging you brother. As you rightly said its just a game of cricket. I would request you too wear Pakistani attire and sing Dil Dil Pakistan while watching their game somwhere in Chennai. Its time for Indian liberals to shower their love openly for Pakistan and show the world that we are a secular nation.
Brother you have a wrong understanding of secularism. Secularism doesn't mean supporting a foriegn team. Secularism means separation of religion and state. A state (government) needs to be secular wherein religion doesn't play a role in policies or governance. But in India secularism meaning has been changed by political parties and media that people need to be secular. How can a common man be secular when he is not in the position to govern? People need to be inclusive and accept diversity which again isn't related to wearing pakistani attire or singing dil dil pakistan.
 
All this will matter when real crowd actually gets to see the event. Such badly is this wc organised that there are limited tickets available for the normal public and are being sold for atrocious prices. The concierge agency I use for all sporting tickets came back today for the semis in wankhade at 2.36 lacs (incl gst) per box ticket. Last year i watched fifa game France vs England at less than half the price.
 
Maybe bcoz they are Indians?? :vk1

Anyway, no one is judging you brother. As you rightly said its just a game of cricket. I would request you too wear Pakistani attire and sing Dil Dil Pakistan while watching their game somwhere in Chennai. Its time for Indian liberals to shower their love openly for Pakistan and show the world that we are a secular nation.
I am sure you also have sung or hummed Dil Dil Pakistan, even unintentionally, the tone is just too catchy.
 
Back
Top