What's new

The Wrestling Discussion Thread

So they put the belt back on Gunther just to have that stupid German v Yahud backdrop for a past it Goldberg 😂 🤡 what an idiot h is

Should’ve instead bought Muhammad Hasan out of retirement, far more fitting with his classic theme of the Arabian chant in the background 😂 @shaz619 @RedwoodOriginal @BunnyRabbit

But then everyone would be rooting against Berg given current situation.

About 70% of the roster is probably Yahud’s, I re-visited that interview Berg did and I think his words were twisted a bit, I don’t think he meant it in the way people thought he did and I’ve not seen enough evidence to see him as a die hard Yahud unlike some of my favourite podcasters (Brian Last).

Man, it’s mad to to think that in every decade since Hassan’s departure; he would still be the biggest heel in wrestling, such is the climate in our world today and peak Islamaphobia in the good ol US! Only Vince would have the balls to bring him back, we all know that Stephanie got bigger cahonas then H ever did.
 
If I am Gunther I’m like hell no I’m not putting you over, go back home before you get hurt.

My take is this and most of you wont agree with it.

H has booked the World Heavyweight title so badly that the championship needs Goldberg; since he is available that is. Whether he wins it or not is something to debate, but the fact that a big name is competing for it, elevates the prestige.

And besides Orton, and we can both agree that feud should have been handled differently, Gunther has not really fought a big name or beat one when it truly meant something.

This match will bring a sh!t ton of eye balls and everybody hates how Berg is an unsafe worker, but other then Lesnar, the only guy left in wrestling who can make fans suspend their disbelief and people are secretly marks for that; it made H feel very insecure when Berg came over and he jobbed him into next week compared to how he should have been booked when he made his 2nd comeback. So I can see Gunther benefiting from all the extra attention, he needs this match more then people would like to think.

If Berg somehow has a couple of matches in him, I think that it would be a good piece of business, if done right, that he goes over to set up a huge rematch against Gunther at SS. It’s a high risk strategy and I am 99% sure H wont go that way and it’s fine, as long as Gunther looks extremely dominant against Berg, if it’s a one and done, then it’s essential that Gunther beats up Berg, similar to how Lesnar destroyed Cena all those years ago.

If Orton or Punk got decent runs with the WHC, then Gunther probably didn’t need this match with Berg, but we all know how H treats wrestlers with greater legacies than his own.
 
Woman: My son has cancer.

Tony Khan: I'm really sorry to hear that, but I really hope you tune-in on Wednesday night to watch AEW Grand Slam Mexico. It'll be a great show with some great wrestling, great stars, great matches, a great crowd. Did I mention that it'll be great?

TNA would have been fortunate to have him hyping their PPV’s back in the day lol I just found some work for Tony in the wrestling business 🤡
 
Goldberg got a massive reception from the fans. Trips might see it as an opportunity to push Rollins. What if Goldberg beats Gunther followed by an MITB cash in from Seth. That sort of booking will bury everything other than Seth something synonymous with Triple H.
 
The only two guys I can think of who got over due to their matches are Rey and Benoit. It would be an extremely different task for Ilja to reach that. As casual fans care about the feud than the matches.
There are plenty of other examples too of guys who got over because of their wrestling.

Even if someone isn't aware of their rivalry they will get sucked in because whenever Gunther and Ilja get into the ring it's pure magic. It's wrestling how wrestling should be. A battle of attrition between a dominant heel and a babyface who refuses to give up.
 
There are plenty of other examples too of guys who got over because of their wrestling.

Even if someone isn't aware of their rivalry they will get sucked in because whenever Gunther and Ilja get into the ring it's pure magic. It's wrestling how wrestling should be. A battle of attrition between a dominant heel and a babyface who refuses to give up.
Yes it's been magic. but the thing is they've only wrestled in NXT in my understanding. Getting the far bigger audience to get invested in the matches is something a lot of wrestlers who were so over in NXT have failed to achieve. Dont get me wrong, I loved their both matches and I like both of their work considering how highly I rate black and gold NXT.
 
They tried too hard to make Solo an enforcer that it didn’t fit earlier on. Then Jacob came and outclassed him in that role and that forced Solo to add a different dimension to his character of being more manipulative and have that evil charm / charisma. Some of his antics at MITB were p funny lol.

Been gradually become a fan of Solo. His character work has improved and his character work is far better than the other two Uso bros.
I enjoy him actually but this is not a main-event gimmick. Which is fine. Not everyone is cut out to be a John Cena or Stone Cold. But they need to stop acting like he's a main-event heel because neither him nor the booking supports that idea.
 
Yes it's been magic. but the thing is they've only wrestled in NXT in my understanding. Getting the far bigger audience to get invested in the matches is something a lot of wrestlers who were so over in NXT have failed to achieve. Dont get me wrong, I loved their both matches and I like both of their work considering how highly I rate black and gold NXT.
What does them having only worked in NXT have to do with anything? We are talking about the quality of the wrestling. If anything, matches like those would draw even reactions on bigger shows, and bring even more notoriety to these guys, especially Ilja. You are completely ignoring the fact that wrestling fans like wrestling. And in WWE, where most matches on RAW and SD are not exactly 20 minute mat classics, the fans appreciate great wrestling even more when they see it on a big show.

These two in a match at a future WrestleMania would blow the roof off the arena.
 
TNA would have been fortunate to have him hyping their PPV’s back in the day lol I just found some work for Tony in the wrestling business 🤡
Who needs coked out nepobaby when you have the talented Don West selling TNA merchandise on public-access?

RIP, he was really underrated. It's still absolutely hilarious to me though that they had him doing that. Just because he used to be a salesman, I'm guessing?
 
Goldberg got a massive reception from the fans. Trips might see it as an opportunity to push Rollins. What if Goldberg beats Gunther followed by an MITB cash in from Seth. That sort of booking will bury everything other than Seth something synonymous with Triple H.
Lol did you see Oldberg? He had a stroke just climbing up the ropes.

I don't think even H is dumb enough to do that. That would just put negative heat on the company. Gunther may as well retire and leave wrestling after that, because he won't be worth a $hit as a wrestler.
 
So they put the belt back on Gunther just to have that stupid German v Yahud backdrop for a past it Goldberg 😂 🤡 what an idiot h is

Should’ve instead bought Muhammad Hasan out of retirement, far more fitting with his classic theme of the Arabian chant in the background 😂 @shaz619 @RedwoodOriginal @BunnyRabbit

But then everyone would be rooting against Berg given current situation.
Bruh I'm just having a ball seeing all these Bret Hart memes on Twitter.
 
What does them having only worked in NXT have to do with anything? We are talking about the quality of the wrestling. If anything, matches like those would draw even reactions on bigger shows, and bring even more notoriety to these guys, especially Ilja. You are completely ignoring the fact that wrestling fans like wrestling. And in WWE, where most matches on RAW and SD are not exactly 20 minute mat classics, the fans appreciate great wrestling even more when they see it on a big show.

These two in a match at a future WrestleMania would blow the roof off the arena.
I disagree. If that was the case, the likes of Ricochet, Malenko, Regal, Shelton, Morrison, Cedric would have been top carders.
Majority of WWE fans are just casual fans and kids who don't really like the wrestling part all the time. It's the same thing with Seth, despite being a good worker and talker, the guy just isn't able to draw crowds on his like someone like Roman can. The house show sales in 2019 during his championship run were quite low. Even Roman as the big dog was drawing more.
NXT was only seen by hardcore wrestling fans. They have smaller crowds. It's easier for guys to get over there through their matches. There's a reason Gargano hasn't clicked with the main roster despite him doing fairly well from in ring point of view.
If you put on a 40 minute match on Mania when the audience doesn't care about either guy, they will start booing.
That's why only main events or guys like Taker, HBK, Randy would get to breech that 30 min mark in their matches on arena shows. The notable exception being Triple H who would get the most time for his boring matches due to his politics.
Gunther has won over the crowd and kudos to him. He has massively improved his mic work as well. As far as Ilja is concerned, he first has to get over with the crowd. You or I can't decide who gets over at the end of the day. It's about the reaction they get from fans.
 
Lol did you see Oldberg? He had a stroke just climbing up the ropes.

I don't think even H is dumb enough to do that. That would just put negative heat on the company. Gunther may as well retire and leave wrestling after that, because he won't be worth a $hit as a wrestler.
lol anything is possible in wwe. Goldberg might beat Gunther, Gunther raises his hand and proceeds to beat the **** out of him followed by Seth cashing in. That's only due to the weird love Trips has for Seth.
 
Trips vs Batista (WM 21)
Trips vs Kurt RR 2001?
Trips vs Jericho (where Jericho won and then lost back in 2000)

Can't think of any other.
For what it's worth, I think Trips vs Maven on Heat was a fairly decent match considering the two guys involved. :ssa2
I don't remember any of these matches besides the first one
 
I disagree. If that was the case, the likes of Ricochet, Malenko, Regal, Shelton, Morrison, Cedric would have been top carders.
Majority of WWE fans are just casual fans and kids who don't really like the wrestling part all the time. It's the same thing with Seth, despite being a good worker and talker, the guy just isn't able to draw crowds on his like someone like Roman can. The house show sales in 2019 during his championship run were quite low. Even Roman as the big dog was drawing more.
NXT was only seen by hardcore wrestling fans. They have smaller crowds. It's easier for guys to get over there through their matches. There's a reason Gargano hasn't clicked with the main roster despite him doing fairly well from in ring point of view.
If you put on a 40 minute match on Mania when the audience doesn't care about either guy, they will start booing.
That's why only main events or guys like Taker, HBK, Randy would get to breech that 30 min mark in their matches on arena shows. The notable exception being Triple H who would get the most time for his boring matches due to his politics.
Gunther has won over the crowd and kudos to him. He has massively improved his mic work as well. As far as Ilja is concerned, he first has to get over with the crowd. You or I can't decide who gets over at the end of the day. It's about the reaction they get from fans.
Each case and each wrestler is different so I don't see how you can just lump them all together in the same sentence. I also don't understand how you can compare a charisma vacuum like Gargano to Ilja or Gunther. Yes, some people can only get over in NXT but neither Ilja nor Gunther fall under that category.

That's where you're wrong though. Fans love great wrestling when you give it to them. And matches like Punk v Drew, Cody v Seth, Gunther v Sheamus v Drew, Charlotte v Rhea, Gunther v Sheamus are just some examples of people going absolutely nuts for great wrestling on a big show.

The reason I say Ilja needs to wrestle to get over is because the guy is an unreal babyface. He is so good at playing that babyface fighting from underneath, his selling is incredible and like Gunther, he wrestles a very physical style that can suck in even the casual fan. But he needs to be beaten within an inch of his life. And nobody does that better than Gunther.

Mark my words. This match will blow the roof off WrestleMania, SummerSlam or whichever big show it happens at. I don't care if it happens tomorrow or a year from now.
 
TBH I was thinking about this and all my favorite Triple H matches are gimmick matches lmao.

H v Batista (HIAC) - Vengeance 2005
H v Cactus Jack (Street Fight) - Royal Rumble 2001
H v Shawn (Unsanctioned) - SummerSlam 2002
H v Shawn v Benoit (Triple Threat) - WrestleMania 20
H v Austin (3 Stages of Hell) - No Way Out 2001

Without the bells and whistles or suitable dance partner he is more like a 2/10, Bret was too kind calling him a 4/10.

When has he ever had a great singles match with a low profile opponent or someone who needed him to lead; his wrestling IQ is severely low.
 
You can say maybe Batista at WM 21 and that’s it, but Batista was so over that he’d have had to completely sh!t the bed not to have a great match with him. In-fact Taker did more for Batista than H ever did and we saw that his wrestling IQ was superior to H over the years. Given how terrible H has been post that match with Batista in 2005 in similar scenarios, I am not sure I want to give H credit for the match but yes he put him over which was above that piece of crap.
 
I don't wanna blame the aggreived party because I don't know the extent of the injury. But looking at the footage on Twitter it didn't seem serious at all. And apparently this happened 2 years ago.

It doesn’t look it I agree but if it was unplanned then it’s pretty reckless, similar to how they had been using the guard rails. Does Mox think everyone working there is a hipster mark in on his grand schemes? It’s like everyone is expected to have a premonition of his memo for what he wants to do or that they can all read him like his wife, he don’t know how to express himself professionally, but that’s why you need a manager, what a dork man, however, his worst instincts have been encouraged by coke cogan.
 
Each case and each wrestler is different so I don't see how you can just lump them all together in the same sentence. I also don't understand how you can compare a charisma vacuum like Gargano to Ilja or Gunther. Yes, some people can only get over in NXT but neither Ilja nor Gunther fall under that category.

That's where you're wrong though. Fans love great wrestling when you give it to them. And matches like Punk v Drew, Cody v Seth, Gunther v Sheamus v Drew, Charlotte v Rhea, Gunther v Sheamus are just some examples of people going absolutely nuts for great wrestling on a big show.

The reason I say Ilja needs to wrestle to get over is because the guy is an unreal babyface. He is so good at playing that babyface fighting from underneath, his selling is incredible and like Gunther, he wrestles a very physical style that can suck in even the casual fan. But he needs to be beaten within an inch of his life. And nobody does that better than Gunther.

Mark my words. This match will blow the roof off WrestleMania, SummerSlam or whichever big show it happens at. I don't care if it happens tomorrow or a year from now.
Let's wait and see. I don't think Ilja is charismatic enough or an effective pure face like Sami. He is a very good worker I agree. And the match between the two will be amazing like the two previous ones no doubt. I have doubts if he can get over on the main roster. Although I am only aware of his work on NXT and little bit of main roster. I haven't followed his indie career so I may be wrong.
Punk, Drew, Cody, Gunther, Sheamus, Charlotte, Rhea etc all of them are well rounded individuals with great personalities. Even Seth was okayish with his initial heel turn in 2020 and his matches with Edge were fantastic.
 
Let's wait and see. I don't think Ilja is charismatic enough or an effective pure face like Sami. He is a very good worker I agree. And the match between the two will be amazing like the two previous ones no doubt. I have doubts if he can get over on the main roster. Although I am only aware of his work on NXT and little bit of main roster. I haven't followed his indie career so I may be wrong.
Punk, Drew, Cody, Gunther, Sheamus, Charlotte, Rhea etc all of them are well rounded individuals with great personalities. Even Seth was okayish with his initial heel turn in 2020 and his matches with Edge were fantastic.

In the ring I believe he will get over and be a top star at the top of the card with the right backing, if he can cut authentic promos, that would be a huge bonus and he could break into the world championship league. Nobody expected Gunther to thrive as much as he has, but he worked extremely hard on his character, he’s a natural on TV now and he makes it look so easy, but I recall his run in NXT and he was still within his shell a bit, Vince helped unlock Gunther’s complete potential while H was happy to book him in indie dream matches to get an ego boost from smarks. Unfortunately for Ilja, the odds are not in his favour because H doesn’t know how to create stars and he has a dated view of pro-wrestling in 2025.
 
In the ring I believe he will get over and be a top star at the top of the card with the right backing, if he can cut authentic promos, that would be a huge bonus and he could break into the world championship league. Nobody expected Gunther to thrive as much as he has, but he worked extremely hard on his character, he’s a natural on TV now and he makes it look so easy, but I recall his run in NXT and he was still within his shell a bit, Vince helped unlock Gunther’s complete potential while H was happy to book him in indie dream matches to get an ego boost from smarks. Unfortunately for Ilja, the odds are not in his favour because H doesn’t know how to create stars and he has a dated view of pro-wrestling in 2025.
Gunther is something different I believe. The guy understands pro wrestling and sports entertainment very very well. Gunther proved all of his critics wrong.
How Ilja works with his character and promos will have a lot to decide if he can get over with the head booker definitely not a smart one. You can make a case for Gunther being a generational talent. I don't know if Ilja is as good as him.
 
Trips vs Batista (WM 21)
Trips vs Kurt RR 2001?
Trips vs Jericho (where Jericho won and then lost back in 2000)

Can't think of any other.
For what it's worth, I think Trips vs Maven on Heat was a fairly decent match considering the two guys involved. :ssa2

Triple H vs HBK - SummerSlam 2002.

One of my favorite wrestling matches of all time.

Even Elimination Chamber 2002 was good (HBK pinned HHH to win the world title).
 
Triple H vs HBK - SummerSlam 2002.

One of my favorite wrestling matches of all time.

Even Elimination Chamber 2002 was good (HBK pinned HHH to win the world title).
I think @RedwoodOriginal was asking if there is any good singles match of Triple H's career that didn't feature any stipulation or gimmick like steel cage, No DQ, HIAC, triple threat etc.
 
Gunther is something different I believe. The guy understands pro wrestling and sports entertainment very very well. Gunther proved all of his critics wrong.
How Ilja works with his character and promos will have a lot to decide if he can get over with the head booker definitely not a smart one. You can make a case for Gunther being a generational talent. I don't know if Ilja is as good as him.

Nobody expected Gunther to be one hell of an act on TV for similar reasons that they believe Ilja will struggle, people knew Gunther would be a breath of fresh air in the ring, no one expected him to have improved as much as he did with his character, the expectation was that he’d be in the mould of a Cesaro but a bit better then that. However, Vince saw the upside/vision with him as a menacing ‘German/Hitler’ like villain, when Vince can see how he can fit you at the top of the card, he tends to follow through with those instincts. For those who he is unsure about, he will give you the opportunity but the room for error is very low. The onus is on the booker to have a plan in place but also use their instincts to maximise the main event potential of unique performers. It will be a challenge for Ilja to, because we already have Gunther playing the kind of character he would have fit into seamlessly, however, he can be a believable face to and it’s going to be a lot harder to develop his face persona, but not impossible, the odds are against him due to the current creative regime. To start off with I wouldn’t be against him being a heel on Smackdown while he gains TV experience.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Triple H vs HBK - SummerSlam 2002.

One of my favorite wrestling matches of all time.

Even Elimination Chamber 2002 was good (HBK pinned HHH to win the world title).

Those matches were like a miracle for me because Shawn was returning from his career ending back injury; Shawn well past his prime put on two of the best matches up until those two PPV’s of the year like it was nothing, in the words of Mo. Asif ‘A fish never forgets how to swim’. I will give H some credit for that gimmick match though because Shawn’s mom thought he would get crippled again so it probably wasn’t easy to work with that on your shoulders and he was safe on that night, H never really worked stiff or injured anybody other then his quad and wrestling IQ.
 
Those matches were like a miracle for me because Shawn was returning from his career ending back injury; Shawn well past his prime put on two of the best matches up until those two PPV’s of the year like it was nothing, in the words of Mo. Asif ‘A fish never forgets how to swim’. I will give H some credit for that gimmick match though because Shawn’s mom thought he would get crippled again so it probably wasn’t easy to work with that on your shoulders and he was safe on that night, H never really worked stiff or injured anybody other then his quad and wrestling IQ.

Indeed.

At that point, it seemed like HBK's return would be a short-lived one (considering his back injury). But, he ended up having quite a long career.
 
Indeed.

At that point, it seemed like HBK's return would be a short-lived one (considering his back injury). But, he ended up having quite a long career.

When Shawn retired in 1998 he was widely regarded as the best in-ring performer ever, I have some magazines from the early 2000’s praising him in that way and pointing out how it was the expert view. And you’re right, it was just going to be a one and done in 2002, but man, he tore the roof off at SS & at MSG when he won the WHC again, that was one of the greatest fairytale storylines in wrestling, Shawn went from wanting to die after WM 10 to be remembered like Elvis to reaching the pearly white gates in the 2000’s again, to have the run he did after his setbacks was insane to be honest; it comes down to preference but I feel he was even better in his second run.
 
@sweep_shot This was four months ago:


His finisher is so abused now but no one hits the super kick quiet like Shawn.

I wish he wasn’t such a perfectionist because even at his late age I’d have liked to see him in some dream matches but he didn’t want to tarnish the great ending he had to his career at WM 26 against the Undertaker.
 
Rumours that H wants to add more members to Seth’s new group. That’s one way to try and mask what a cluster F this endeavour has been.

Seth just doesn’t have it, he didn’t have it in 2015 and he doesn’t in 2025, you can do what you want, he wont ever be that guy.

Reigns got a strong push repeatedly, but delivered much sooner. Even during the tough times, he had it, maybe you had a problem with the creative but you just knew there was a huge star in him.

The only saving grace will be the eventual Bron betrayal, but that is years away in H’s handbook and he’s doing him a disservice if he is held back for too long.

H’s ego and lack of balls will prevent him from pulling the plug on this, plus Seth is his favourite bender brother.
 
Rumours that H wants to add more members to Seth’s new group. That’s one way to try and mask what a cluster F this endeavour has been.

Seth just doesn’t have it, he didn’t have it in 2015 and he doesn’t in 2025, you can do what you want, he wont ever be that guy.

Reigns got a strong push repeatedly, but delivered much sooner. Even during the tough times, he had it, maybe you had a problem with the creative but you just knew there was a huge star in him.

The only saving grace will be the eventual Bron betrayal, but that is years away in H’s handbook and he’s doing him a disservice if he is held back for too long.

H’s ego and lack of balls will prevent him from pulling the plug on this, plus Seth is his favourite bender brother.
he actually stunted Bron’s progress by putting him in this stupid nameless faction.

He went from having a meteoric singles rise parallel to Jacob Fatu’s but it got halted because Paul wanted to boost his son Seth and needed to force Bron in to give Seth credibility by making him a subordinate to him.

Otherwise Bron after another feud or two would be good to go to challenge for the WHC.
 
he actually stunted Bron’s progress by putting him in this stupid nameless faction.

He went from having a meteoric singles rise parallel to Jacob Fatu’s but it got halted because Paul wanted to boost his son Seth and needed to force Bron in to give Seth credibility by making him a subordinate to him.

Otherwise Bron after another feud or two would be good to go to challenge for the WHC.

Bron should be booked either like how Lesnar was or Sheamus when they came in, some performers you just need to trust your gut and shrewdly build them up big, this moron would have stunted Cody’s growth as well, Vince positioned him as a top guy right away. You’re right, I hadn’t look at it like this before but now that I have, he is doing Bron serious damage.
 
You can say maybe Batista at WM 21 and that’s it, but Batista was so over that he’d have had to completely sh!t the bed not to have a great match with him. In-fact Taker did more for Batista than H ever did and we saw that his wrestling IQ was superior to H over the years. Given how terrible H has been post that match with Batista in 2005 in similar scenarios, I am not sure I want to give H credit for the match but yes he put him over which was above that piece of crap.
Whatever you may think of Triple H I think you have to give him credit for that. Yes Batista was mega over. But none of that happens without him being involved in Evolution with Triple H, and them laying the seeds for that turn. It was a simple story, that we have seen plenty of times, executed to perfection. And it had to be Triple H. It had to be someone the fans hated in kayfabe, real-life, the internet. For me, all three matches they had were perfect for different reasons. First one was main-event worthy match but you felt like the book wasn't closed. Backlash rematch gave H enough of an out to set up the third and final match. And then you had the HIAC which is simply one of the greatest cage matches ever, in my opinion. Yes Batista had all the tools to be a massive star and would have become one eventually. But without Triple H I doubt if any of it would have been as good.
 
Without the bells and whistles or suitable dance partner he is more like a 2/10, Bret was too kind calling him a 4/10.

When has he ever had a great singles match with a low profile opponent or someone who needed him to lead; his wrestling IQ is severely low.
For me he can be 7/10 in gimmick matches. 4/10 otherwise. I stand with Bret's rating.
 
Let's wait and see. I don't think Ilja is charismatic enough or an effective pure face like Sami. He is a very good worker I agree. And the match between the two will be amazing like the two previous ones no doubt. I have doubts if he can get over on the main roster. Although I am only aware of his work on NXT and little bit of main roster. I haven't followed his indie career so I may be wrong.
Punk, Drew, Cody, Gunther, Sheamus, Charlotte, Rhea etc all of them are well rounded individuals with great personalities. Even Seth was okayish with his initial heel turn in 2020 and his matches with Edge were fantastic.
Sami is one of their top babyfaces so that's not exactly a fair comparison he can still be an outstanding babyface, because of the reasons I mentioned above.
 
It doesn’t look it I agree but if it was unplanned then it’s pretty reckless, similar to how they had been using the guard rails. Does Mox think everyone working there is a hipster mark in on his grand schemes? It’s like everyone is expected to have a premonition of his memo for what he wants to do or that they can all read him like his wife, he don’t know how to express himself professionally, but that’s why you need a manager, what a dork man, however, his worst instincts have been encouraged by coke cogan.
More than reckless, its unprofessional. But then again unprofessionalism is nothing new for Moxley. I guess that's what happens when your boss strokes your ego and makes you think you're the king of the castle. You actually start believing that $hit. Moxley's problem is that while he had the talent and ability to make it as a big star, his brain never left the bingo halls and barns. WWE had a structure that kept him in line, as much as he tried to "rebel" whereas AEW allows him to follow all his worst instincts. So should we really expect anything less?
 
Rumours that H wants to add more members to Seth’s new group. That’s one way to try and mask what a cluster F this endeavour has been.

Seth just doesn’t have it, he didn’t have it in 2015 and he doesn’t in 2025, you can do what you want, he wont ever be that guy.

Reigns got a strong push repeatedly, but delivered much sooner. Even during the tough times, he had it, maybe you had a problem with the creative but you just knew there was a huge star in him.

The only saving grace will be the eventual Bron betrayal, but that is years away in H’s handbook and he’s doing him a disservice if he is held back for too long.

H’s ego and lack of balls will prevent him from pulling the plug on this, plus Seth is his favourite bender brother.
I was thinking about it and even more than being Triple H Jr, Rollins is like the Temu version of Edge. If you follow his career everything has been geared towards making him that type of a character. That really smart heel who is supposedly a master strategist. Thing is, with Edge you really believed it. Him stealing Lita from Matt Hardy is real life also added to his bad guy heel persona. Above all, he had an aura and a presence. You don't believe a damn word coming out of Rollins's mouth, and he has the personality of a mail-box. They literally put him with one of the greatest managers in the history of wrestling, and these two literally have zero chemistry. It's like we are supposed to act like this is the baddest heel group when it just looks like Rollins coming out with two security guards. Bronson Reed is just there to take the pin. Bron Breakker's personality has been completely sidelined in favor of Temu Edge. Add to that the fact that Bron and Bron are basically playing the same role of the enforcer.
 
I was watching Royal Rumble 2005 (whole PPV) and it kinda surprised me how much I enjoyed it. The card literally had two good matches. Shawn Michaels v Edge and the Royal Rumble match, but the PPV moved so briskly. Eventhough Triple H v Randy Orton felt like it went on for about an hour, the whole PPV ran under 3 hours. 5 matches, No ads. Because that's what being on PPV goddamn meant once upon a time. JR wasn't trying to sell me Fireball alcohol MID-MATCH. The commentary was good. The crowd was fully-invested in the show. The Rumble match may have been one of the best ones ever. The PPV theme song was a wonderfully trashy Nu-metal song from Alter Bridge, of all bands! And the ending was pretty much as perfect as it could have been. Brought back some great memories for a Batista stan like me. I guess that's the only way you can enjoy wrestling now. By watching it from back when it actually used to be good!
 
I was thinking about it and even more than being Triple H Jr, Rollins is like the Temu version of Edge. If you follow his career everything has been geared towards making him that type of a character. That really smart heel who is supposedly a master strategist. Thing is, with Edge you really believed it. Him stealing Lita from Matt Hardy is real life also added to his bad guy heel persona. Above all, he had an aura and a presence. You don't believe a damn word coming out of Rollins's mouth, and he has the personality of a mail-box. They literally put him with one of the greatest managers in the history of wrestling, and these two literally have zero chemistry. It's like we are supposed to act like this is the baddest heel group when it just looks like Rollins coming out with two security guards. Bronson Reed is just there to take the pin. Bron Breakker's personality has been completely sidelined in favor of Temu Edge. Add to that the fact that Bron and Bron are basically playing the same role of the enforcer.
In addition to what you said, Edge is one of the most fluent workers of all time something Rollins is never going to reach.
And I think Trips was better than Seth in terms of being a bad guy moving a story along as a wrestler.
 
Rumours that H wants to add more members to Seth’s new group. That’s one way to try and mask what a cluster F this endeavour has been.

Seth just doesn’t have it, he didn’t have it in 2015 and he doesn’t in 2025, you can do what you want, he wont ever be that guy.

Reigns got a strong push repeatedly, but delivered much sooner. Even during the tough times, he had it, maybe you had a problem with the creative but you just knew there was a huge star in him.

The only saving grace will be the eventual Bron betrayal, but that is years away in H’s handbook and he’s doing him a disservice if he is held back for too long.

H’s ego and lack of balls will prevent him from pulling the plug on this, plus Seth is his favourite bender brother.
And Roman was drawing the house shows' sales even as the big dog despite how much he was loathed by older fans, the kids loved him and his matches always had that extra oomph in them.
 
Whatever you may think of Triple H I think you have to give him credit for that. Yes Batista was mega over. But none of that happens without him being involved in Evolution with Triple H, and them laying the seeds for that turn. It was a simple story, that we have seen plenty of times, executed to perfection. And it had to be Triple H. It had to be someone the fans hated in kayfabe, real-life, the internet. For me, all three matches they had were perfect for different reasons. First one was main-event worthy match but you felt like the book wasn't closed. Backlash rematch gave H enough of an out to set up the third and final match. And then you had the HIAC which is simply one of the greatest cage matches ever, in my opinion. Yes Batista had all the tools to be a massive star and would have become one eventually. But without Triple H I doubt if any of it would have been as good.

I will give him credit for putting Batista over and being part of what was arguably the most memorable storyline during the RA era, but he had no choice and Vince was probably dying to strap a rocket to his back. A few things that gets overlooked is that in 2004/2005, there are two critical factors which get overlooked in his rise:

1. H completely botched Orton’s face run.
2. Batista was always grinding, you watch his matches in Q1 of 2004 & compare to Q4 of 2004 and he was a completely different performer.

Starting with the first point, this is very important in Batista getting his push, Batista was looked at in the same vein as LA Knight is today, a guy who looks fantastic, has presence and can work with top guys, but H never saw him in that light and his age went against him. If we’re looking at who they wanted to get over through Evolution, make no mistake, Orton was the first name on the sheet and Batista was not seen as a guy who could break into the main-event; this is supported by how Batista was booked between 2003 to about mid 2004 when they pulled the plug on Orton. If they did not botch Orton, Batista does not touch the main-event even with a barge pole. And a bonus point which supplements 1), is that after H had run riot and his creative ran out of ideas and their original plans failed, they were forced into a corner.

2. Batista kept getting better and better, his improvement so late in his career was pretty unreal when you consider he didn’t come from a wrestling background, it wasn’t until his stint in OVW that he got to train consistently and when they eventually called him up, he was basically learning on the job, it can’t hurt to be able to ride with the greatest pro-wrestler in history either but Batista was such a hard worker man, he is the best example of what a great work ethic can do for you and with a bit of luck, you can really do well. Batista deserves a lot of credit for getting himself ready to the point that when he was pushed to the top, Batista over-delivered and exceeding every expectation on him. There might be some observer reports detailing his rise throughout 2004 which would be good to dig out, weirdly I recall Meltzer being very positive towards Batista, I think he was shocked by the improvement, and the fans recognised this to.

After Batista got over, they shipped him straight to SD because H’s ego got dented and they wouldn’t have been able to prevent the urge of him getting his W’s back from another hot baby face from needlessly being buried. The reign of terror yielded Batista but it was a series of unexpected events which lead them to that, but even after all that, they ship Batista to SD in the number 2 role. I don’t think we should be praising H at all - just putting Batista over was not enough and I don’t give him credit at all now, you’ve taken me back again now and my blood is boiling again, all those buried bacharas, next level unnecessary dominance despite the sh!t TV ratings and politicking for a guy who we would genuinely regard in the 5th spot for heat good heat levels.

Lets not forget how badly they treated Orton as well after the botch-mania with his run, I think you mentioned you watched the 05 RR, and if my memory serves me correctly, H worked with Orton on that PPV? H almost always needed Evolution to help him in his matches but Randy was basically squashed like a bug? It’s like they didn’t even try and sugar coat their failure or try and look after Orton a bit; lets just say we should give H 100% credit for Batista, that was all cancelled out by how Orton was made to look like a sissy after feuding with H; thankfully, there were some guys left who despite being personified greats and genuinely gifted didn’t have so much akar, lucky for Orton, that Taker to him under his wing and helped him recover his mojo and confidence when they feuded I think on the way to WM 21; actually, I will say that is my favourite Orton match ever at WM other then the one against Punk, it took a proper legend to get Orton back on track, or else his career was done.

I need a cup of tea now to calm myself.
 
I was watching Royal Rumble 2005 (whole PPV) and it kinda surprised me how much I enjoyed it. The card literally had two good matches. Shawn Michaels v Edge and the Royal Rumble match, but the PPV moved so briskly. Eventhough Triple H v Randy Orton felt like it went on for about an hour, the whole PPV ran under 3 hours. 5 matches, No ads. Because that's what being on PPV goddamn meant once upon a time. JR wasn't trying to sell me Fireball alcohol MID-MATCH. The commentary was good. The crowd was fully-invested in the show. The Rumble match may have been one of the best ones ever. The PPV theme song was a wonderfully trashy Nu-metal song from Alter Bridge, of all bands! And the ending was pretty much as perfect as it could have been. Brought back some great memories for a Batista stan like me. I guess that's the only way you can enjoy wrestling now. By watching it from back when it actually used to be good!

Outside my issues it was my favourite period in wrestling.

Also, H wasn’t needed between 2003-2005, you take that jibroni out of Evolution and honestly, Chris Jericho would be a much better fit leading the faction.
 
@shaz619 AEW finding new ways to drive off their dwindling audience. This was the opening segment of the show. Entirely in Spanish and without subtitles!


WTH was this on the PPV or Dynamite? lol I think I read Meltzer was defending it religiously or something lmao

I bet this is Hangman being a baby face ? if so, what a dumb phuck 😂🤣

If you’re a student of the game, and I think a heel should be resorting to this anyway, just look at JBL @ Triple Mania.
 
I was thinking about it and even more than being Triple H Jr, Rollins is like the Temu version of Edge. If you follow his career everything has been geared towards making him that type of a character. That really smart heel who is supposedly a master strategist. Thing is, with Edge you really believed it. Him stealing Lita from Matt Hardy is real life also added to his bad guy heel persona. Above all, he had an aura and a presence. You don't believe a damn word coming out of Rollins's mouth, and he has the personality of a mail-box. They literally put him with one of the greatest managers in the history of wrestling, and these two literally have zero chemistry. It's like we are supposed to act like this is the baddest heel group when it just looks like Rollins coming out with two security guards. Bronson Reed is just there to take the pin. Bron Breakker's personality has been completely sidelined in favor of Temu Edge. Add to that the fact that Bron and Bron are basically playing the same role of the enforcer.

Since you told me about Seth’s family background, I can’t get that out of my head either. There’s no ‘Edge’ to the guy, pun-intended ;) And everything about him is so fake, there’s more fake in him the the prime Bella Twins.
 
I will give him credit for putting Batista over and being part of what was arguably the most memorable storyline during the RA era, but he had no choice and Vince was probably dying to strap a rocket to his back. A few things that gets overlooked is that in 2004/2005, there are two critical factors which get overlooked in his rise:

1. H completely botched Orton’s face run.
2. Batista was always grinding, you watch his matches in Q1 of 2004 & compare to Q4 of 2004 and he was a completely different performer.

Starting with the first point, this is very important in Batista getting his push, Batista was looked at in the same vein as LA Knight is today, a guy who looks fantastic, has presence and can work with top guys, but H never saw him in that light and his age went against him. If we’re looking at who they wanted to get over through Evolution, make no mistake, Orton was the first name on the sheet and Batista was not seen as a guy who could break into the main-event; this is supported by how Batista was booked between 2003 to about mid 2004 when they pulled the plug on Orton. If they did not botch Orton, Batista does not touch the main-event even with a barge pole. And a bonus point which supplements 1), is that after H had run riot and his creative ran out of ideas and their original plans failed, they were forced into a corner.

2. Batista kept getting better and better, his improvement so late in his career was pretty unreal when you consider he didn’t come from a wrestling background, it wasn’t until his stint in OVW that he got to train consistently and when they eventually called him up, he was basically learning on the job, it can’t hurt to be able to ride with the greatest pro-wrestler in history either but Batista was such a hard worker man, he is the best example of what a great work ethic can do for you and with a bit of luck, you can really do well. Batista deserves a lot of credit for getting himself ready to the point that when he was pushed to the top, Batista over-delivered and exceeding every expectation on him. There might be some observer reports detailing his rise throughout 2004 which would be good to dig out, weirdly I recall Meltzer being very positive towards Batista, I think he was shocked by the improvement, and the fans recognised this to.

After Batista got over, they shipped him straight to SD because H’s ego got dented and they wouldn’t have been able to prevent the urge of him getting his W’s back from another hot baby face from needlessly being buried. The reign of terror yielded Batista but it was a series of unexpected events which lead them to that, but even after all that, they ship Batista to SD in the number 2 role. I don’t think we should be praising H at all - just putting Batista over was not enough and I don’t give him credit at all now, you’ve taken me back again now and my blood is boiling again, all those buried bacharas, next level unnecessary dominance despite the sh!t TV ratings and politicking for a guy who we would genuinely regard in the 5th spot for heat good heat levels.

Lets not forget how badly they treated Orton as well after the botch-mania with his run, I think you mentioned you watched the 05 RR, and if my memory serves me correctly, H worked with Orton on that PPV? H almost always needed Evolution to help him in his matches but Randy was basically squashed like a bug? It’s like they didn’t even try and sugar coat their failure or try and look after Orton a bit; lets just say we should give H 100% credit for Batista, that was all cancelled out by how Orton was made to look like a sissy after feuding with H; thankfully, there were some guys left who despite being personified greats and genuinely gifted didn’t have so much akar, lucky for Orton, that Taker to him under his wing and helped him recover his mojo and confidence when they feuded I think on the way to WM 21; actually, I will say that is my favourite Orton match ever at WM other then the one against Punk, it took a proper legend to get Orton back on track, or else his career was done.

I need a cup of tea now to calm myself.

That botch of Orton’s face stint also played nicely into Batista’s rise because he always had to be looking over his shoulder (think face Orton always gave Batista a nudge about this) and be the one to stab H before he got stabbed himself.

I actually think we never truly got to see the proper fallout from the cracks in Evolution. If Orton wasn’t rushed, and it was done well, with a view to also make Batista a star (this was never plan A and plan B still involved making him the number 2 guy), he could have worked with Batista at one of the big PPV events, even a WM, there was a lot they could still have done between them all; heck, it all culminating in a Triple Threat for this Undisputed Championship, who will Ric Flair side with etc Could you imagine Batista standing tall with both WHC/WWE titles ? No, because that honour was reserved for 4/10 only, if Jericho retained at WM 18, he could have led Evolution that way and used his superior ring IQ to get the most out of the faction, without compromising the roster at the same time.

The more I think about this and as good as Evolution was, we didn’t get the most out of it. H had only one brain cell and that cell was only good for working out who to bury next, piece of crap.
 
WTH was this on the PPV or Dynamite? lol I think I read Meltzer was defending it religiously or something lmao

I bet this is Hangman being a baby face ? if so, what a dumb phuck 😂🤣

If you’re a student of the game, and I think a heel should be resorting to this anyway, just look at JBL @ Triple Mania.
This Drainmaker alongside Dorby Allen are the biggest AEW shills. I never read their tweets.
 
That botch of Orton’s face stint also played nicely into Batista’s rise because he always had to be looking over his shoulder (think face Orton always gave Batista a nudge about this) and be the one to stab H before he got stabbed himself.

I actually think we never truly got to see the proper fallout from the cracks in Evolution. If Orton wasn’t rushed, and it was done well, with a view to also make Batista a star (this was never plan A and plan B still involved making him the number 2 guy), he could have worked with Batista at one of the big PPV events, even a WM, there was a lot they could still have done between them all; heck, it all culminating in a Triple Threat for this Undisputed Championship, who will Ric Flair side with etc Could you imagine Batista standing tall with both WHC/WWE titles ? No, because that honour was reserved for 4/10 only, if Jericho retained at WM 18, he could have led Evolution that way and used his superior ring IQ to get the most out of the faction, without compromising the roster at the same time.

The more I think about this and as good as Evolution was, we didn’t get the most out of it. H had only one brain cell and that cell was only good for working out who to bury next, piece of crap.
Jericho went on a hiatus after Mania 20 if i am correct. Jericho was the best near top card guy who wasn't pushed enough.
But right now he's everything he wasn't 10 years ago. Alcohol has messed up his brain.
 
Bro you're getting unnecessarily angry towards @RedwoodOriginal
Calm down!!!

I never get angry with @RedwoodOriginal and anybody in this thread really, especially him, we have our own banter so know your role.

I think there is a certain Eugene though who deserves burials every now and then for insinuating such ideas however 🤡
 
Jericho went on a hiatus after Mania 20 if i am correct. Jericho was the best near top card guy who wasn't pushed enough.
But right now he's everything he wasn't 10 years ago. Alcohol has messed up his brain.

Yeah PTSD from all the H burials, Jericho is doing his own reign of terror in AEW. He had to leave then and he came back on top.
 
Yeah PTSD from all the H burials, Jericho is doing his own reign of terror in AEW. He had to leave then and he came back on top.
I'd still love to see Y2J back in WWE. I think he has one last run left in him without the stuff he's been doing in AEW.
 
Bron should be booked either like how Lesnar was or Sheamus when they came in, some performers you just need to trust your gut and shrewdly build them up big, this moron would have stunted Cody’s growth as well, Vince positioned him as a top guy right away. You’re right, I hadn’t look at it like this before but now that I have, he is doing Bron serious damage.
wonder when wwe will be saved from his incredible self sabotage issues. #thegame

Let’s see if Cena will carry smackdown today again..
 
I'd still love to see Y2J back in WWE. I think he has one last run left in him without the stuff he's been doing in AEW.

Agree.

Would love to see Jericho back in WWE for one last run. Perhaps John Cena can have his last feud with Jericho.
 
wonder when wwe will be saved from his incredible self sabotage issues. #thegame

Let’s see if Cena will carry smackdown today again..
I've made peace with the fact that Cena will have terrible matches and do good/entertaining promos. Mostly with people he has crossed paths with in the past. And that's fine. It may not be peak wrestling but it's pretty much the only interesting thing on WWE TV right now. I do think he needs to turn back at some point near the end of his run though. He needs to retire as a babyface.
 
I'd still love to see Y2J back in WWE. I think he has one last run left in him without the stuff he's been doing in AEW.
The state that Jericho is in, honestly I'd be happy to never see him in a wrestling ring again. He needs to retire. He has become an embarrassment at this point. All he is doing is damaging his great legacy.
 
Since you told me about Seth’s family background, I can’t get that out of my head either. There’s no ‘Edge’ to the guy, pun-intended ;) And everything about him is so fake, there’s more fake in him the the prime Bella Twins.
People should just start calling him Ledge. Because after hearing one of his promos you feel like jumping off one
 
I will give him credit for putting Batista over and being part of what was arguably the most memorable storyline during the RA era, but he had no choice and Vince was probably dying to strap a rocket to his back. A few things that gets overlooked is that in 2004/2005, there are two critical factors which get overlooked in his rise:

1. H completely botched Orton’s face run.
2. Batista was always grinding, you watch his matches in Q1 of 2004 & compare to Q4 of 2004 and he was a completely different performer.

Starting with the first point, this is very important in Batista getting his push, Batista was looked at in the same vein as LA Knight is today, a guy who looks fantastic, has presence and can work with top guys, but H never saw him in that light and his age went against him. If we’re looking at who they wanted to get over through Evolution, make no mistake, Orton was the first name on the sheet and Batista was not seen as a guy who could break into the main-event; this is supported by how Batista was booked between 2003 to about mid 2004 when they pulled the plug on Orton. If they did not botch Orton, Batista does not touch the main-event even with a barge pole. And a bonus point which supplements 1), is that after H had run riot and his creative ran out of ideas and their original plans failed, they were forced into a corner.

2. Batista kept getting better and better, his improvement so late in his career was pretty unreal when you consider he didn’t come from a wrestling background, it wasn’t until his stint in OVW that he got to train consistently and when they eventually called him up, he was basically learning on the job, it can’t hurt to be able to ride with the greatest pro-wrestler in history either but Batista was such a hard worker man, he is the best example of what a great work ethic can do for you and with a bit of luck, you can really do well. Batista deserves a lot of credit for getting himself ready to the point that when he was pushed to the top, Batista over-delivered and exceeding every expectation on him. There might be some observer reports detailing his rise throughout 2004 which would be good to dig out, weirdly I recall Meltzer being very positive towards Batista, I think he was shocked by the improvement, and the fans recognised this to.

After Batista got over, they shipped him straight to SD because H’s ego got dented and they wouldn’t have been able to prevent the urge of him getting his W’s back from another hot baby face from needlessly being buried. The reign of terror yielded Batista but it was a series of unexpected events which lead them to that, but even after all that, they ship Batista to SD in the number 2 role. I don’t think we should be praising H at all - just putting Batista over was not enough and I don’t give him credit at all now, you’ve taken me back again now and my blood is boiling again, all those buried bacharas, next level unnecessary dominance despite the sh!t TV ratings and politicking for a guy who we would genuinely regard in the 5th spot for heat good heat levels.

Lets not forget how badly they treated Orton as well after the botch-mania with his run, I think you mentioned you watched the 05 RR, and if my memory serves me correctly, H worked with Orton on that PPV? H almost always needed Evolution to help him in his matches but Randy was basically squashed like a bug? It’s like they didn’t even try and sugar coat their failure or try and look after Orton a bit; lets just say we should give H 100% credit for Batista, that was all cancelled out by how Orton was made to look like a sissy after feuding with H; thankfully, there were some guys left who despite being personified greats and genuinely gifted didn’t have so much akar, lucky for Orton, that Taker to him under his wing and helped him recover his mojo and confidence when they feuded I think on the way to WM 21; actually, I will say that is my favourite Orton match ever at WM other then the one against Punk, it took a proper legend to get Orton back on track, or else his career was done.

I need a cup of tea now to calm myself.
First off, kudos for that passionate post. I may not agree with everything you say, but I respect the absolute hatred you feel for Triple H. The conviction you have in your beliefs is admirable. And tbh you have ended up being right about alot of things about Triple H

With Batista I think H had a big role in Batista's rise. Batista was H's friend/gym buddy and they are about the same age. I'm sure that played some part in him being comparatively unselfish with Batista as he was with others. I'm not saying all of what you're saying isn't true. I think it was probably a perfect storm of all these things falling into place and Vince being willing to pull the trigger on him. With Orton, I thought that whole storyline was poorly executed. Orton was never given the chance to be a babyface But if you ask me, I don't think he was cut out to be a babyface at that point of his career. He was just so much more natural as a heel. One of the matches we sadly missed out on was Batista v Randy Orton at WrestleMania 22. That would have been fantastic. It felt like such a natural end-point of the Evolution storyline.
 
Alot of wrestling fans scoff when they hear the name Mistico, because they associate him with his failed run in WWE as Sin Cara. What they don't know is that he is one of the biggest stars/box-office draws to ever come out of Mexico, a country where drawing money and selling out arenas actually still means something, and fans don't just spend their hard-earned money because the biggest wrestling company is in town.

I recommend everyone to watch this entrance. It's one of the most amazing things I've seen in wrestling in a long time. Also gives you an idea of how massive Mistico is in Mexico.

 
First off, kudos for that passionate post. I may not agree with everything you say, but I respect the absolute hatred you feel for Triple H. The conviction you have in your beliefs is admirable. And tbh you have ended up being right about alot of things about Triple H

With Batista I think H had a big role in Batista's rise. Batista was H's friend/gym buddy and they are about the same age. I'm sure that played some part in him being comparatively unselfish with Batista as he was with others. I'm not saying all of what you're saying isn't true. I think it was probably a perfect storm of all these things falling into place and Vince being willing to pull the trigger on him. With Orton, I thought that whole storyline was poorly executed. Orton was never given the chance to be a babyface But if you ask me, I don't think he was cut out to be a babyface at that point of his career. He was just so much more natural as a heel. One of the matches we sadly missed out on was Batista v Randy Orton at WrestleMania 22. That would have been fantastic. It felt like such a natural end-point of the Evolution storyline.

I forgot about the gym buddies thing 🤣🤣 It probably started with Batista, anyone who wanted a push, spot 4/10 in the gym and compliment his gains because he got a small weenie. You made my day bro 🤣
 
Back
Top