Players and commentators alike were left baffled by a DRS judgement which saw the Black Caps not given a wicket against Pakistan on Tuesday.
New Zealand appealed for a catch down the legside by wicketkeeper Devon Conway off the bowling of Ish Sodhi, with Haider Ali the Pakistan batter in the Twenty20 international at Hagley Oval in Christchurch.
The delivery was called a wide by umpire Wayne Knights but Conway was convinced Haider had edged the ball as he swung at it.
New Zealand captain Kane Williamson opted to use the Decision Review System and slow-motions replays were analysed by TV umpire Shaun Haig.
The ‘ultra-edge’ technology showed a spike indicating a noise suggesting there was an edge, but with the side-on vision it was a frame after what appeared to be contact between the underside of the bat and the ball.
“I can see a clear gap between bat and ball there,” Haig said.
“There is a murmuring on ultra-edge, but there is a clear gap between bat and ball ... satisfied there is no bat involved.”
Haig then told Knights he could stay with his original decision of not out – and a wide – to the vast surprise and dismay of the Black Caps, who had watched the decision-making on a big screen at the ground, while Haider appeared to be walking off in the belief he would be given out.
“Oh no – I’m confused by that decision. That is not right,” said TV commentator and former Black Cap Craig McMillan.
“There’s a noise, there’s a spike – I’m dumbfounded by that to be honest.”
Haider only added seven runs to his tally after the incident before being dismissed, as Pakistan struggled to 130-7 off their 20 overs batting first.
https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/crick...s-in-twenty20-versus-pakistan-in-christchurch