Why Indian Hindutva supporters back Israel on Gaza bombing

Good point ... notice the complete lack of outrage when the Saudis were indulging in similar atrocities. The worst ofcourse was the Iran Iraq war in the 80s that went on for years and ofcourse the BD Genocide in 71. No tears shed for those victims.

How do you know that. Now stop derailing the thread, it's obvious, the RSS hindutwa brigade have been exposed as sympathizers to Genocide.
 
But surely you do realise that doing nothing and commiting mass murder is like comparing chalk and cheese

Note how the pro-israeli hindutvas have jumped onto the lifeline his posts have provided them. 😉
 
Last edited by a moderator:
How do you know that.

Here is one way how we can do that... how many protests were done in the universities here in the USA in support of the Yemeni victims?


Now stop derailing the thread, it's obvious, the RSS hindutwa brigade have been exposed as sympathizers to Genocide.

We will find out soon ... that is if you can respond to my post# 389 on this very thread... instead of running away.
 
Israel seems happy with India's stance. Netanyahu even called Modi to update him.

Why should India bother if pakistanis have a problem with the wordings.



India's stance have been consistent over every war in last two decades.

You guys seem to be bothered about our opinions

I suggest you lobby Modi to condemn Hamas and bring your imaginary law to light so he can call them terrorists.

Until then your words are not compatible with your regimes stance.
[/QUOTE]

No we are not. Its amusing though. How pakistanis have opinion on everything Indian but no one seems to care about it. Pakistani PM had to finally rant on twitter.

I am perfectly happy with how Modi is dealing with terrorists. Israel doesn't seem to have any issues either.
 
Hindutva bigots will never condemn genocide again Muslims but instead condone it.

Stop wasting your time, Hindutva bigots have shown their ugly bigoted behinds many times.

Their bigotry is firmly established.

The rest of the global south is on the right side of the history except Hindutva bigots.

Do you need a napkin?
 
Iam talking about all countries OUTSIDE of CURRENT day Israel and Palestine in the entire Middle east. Don't try to play the dead beat card.

You need to defrenciate between zionests and orthodox Jews. However, the remaining orthodox that are left are happily living there with all religions . It's the zionists who drove the orthodox Jews out because of their extreme views and actions .
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you need a napkin?
I don't understand what do they want from us? Do they expect us to swarm social media shedding crocodile tears, and abusing Israel? Or do they want us to start boycotting any product or service that directly or indirectly benefits Israel? Or do they want us to stop all types of business/trade and diplomatic ties with Israel?

Those are the things that Muslims do because of their Ummah brotherhood. Why would anyone expect non Muslims in India to do the same?​
 
Note how the pro-israeli hindutvas have jumped onto the lifeline his posts have provided them. 😉

Lol. The level of hypocrisy amongst the hindutwa brigade is bewildering. This has shown they can stoop to any levels to support their deluded narrative
 
I don't understand what do they want from us? Do they expect us to swarm social media shedding crocodile tears, and abusing Israel? Or do they want us to start boycotting any product or service that directly or indirectly benefits Israel? Or do they want us to stop all types of business/trade and diplomatic ties with Israel?

Those are the things that Muslims do because of their Ummah brotherhood. Why would anyone expect non Muslims in India to do the same?​

Don't paint everyone with the same brush. Hindutwa extremists and orthodox Hindu indians is like comparing chalk and cheese. You obviously know your level.
 
I don't understand what do they want from us? Do they expect us to swarm social media shedding crocodile tears, and abusing Israel? Or do they want us to start boycotting any product or service that directly or indirectly benefits Israel? Or do they want us to stop all types of business/trade and diplomatic ties with Israel?

Those are the things that Muslims do because of their Ummah brotherhood. Why would anyone expect non Muslims in India to do the same?​

They hate Hindus. They hate Jews.

They think India and Indians are doing something wrong and wants to shame us. Well, doesn't work. Hardly anyone in the world is going to take the pakistani opinion on India.
 
Don't paint everyone with the same brush. Hindutwa extremists and orthodox Hindu indians is like comparing chalk and cheese. You obviously know your level.

Don't presume to tell us about our religion.

Its laughable how a Pakistani wants to talk about a Hindu in India.
 
They hate Hindus. They hate Jews.

They think India and Indians are doing something wrong and wants to shame us. Well, doesn't work. Hardly anyone in the world is going to take the pakistani opinion on India.
They can and should do everything in their capability to help Palestine. No one would say a word. It's shameful that so far they have done zilch despite being the only Islamic country with nukes.
 
You need to defrenciate between zionests and orthodox Jews. However, the remaining orthodox that are left are happily living there with all religions . It's the zionists who drove the orthodox Jews out because of their extreme views and actions .

You are saying that the reason why the entire middle east ( you can add north Africa too ) has now virtually negligible Jewish population is because of the Zionists who live in Israel?

Again to prevent another round of mindless deadbeat responses... when I say middle east I mean outside of Israel and Palestine because thats the CURRENT conflict zone. Let me know if you want a big list of Muslim countries from where they have been evicted. Clear ?
 
They hate Hindus. They hate Jews.

They think India and Indians are doing something wrong and wants to shame us. Well, doesn't work. Hardly anyone in the world is going to take the pakistani opinion on India.
Typing this as i’m travelling to Lake Placif with my Hindu friend and to meet up a Jewish friend to go on a 8 hours hike.

Clearly not friends with Hindutva and Zionist.
 
You are saying that the reason why the entire middle east ( you can add north Africa too ) has now virtually negligible Jewish population is because of the Zionists who live in Israel?

Again to prevent another round of mindless deadbeat responses... when I say middle east I mean outside of Israel and Palestine because thats the CURRENT conflict zone. Let me know if you want a big list of Muslim countries from where they have been evicted. Clear ?

You see, your ilk can't comprehend pro israeli movement as as a oppressive regime which has neglected all religions. They have killed Christians, muslims, orthodox Jews, because of their extremism. Their plan on GREATER ISRAEL is all planned up decades ago in which they plan to extend their illegal occupation in to other territories. The reason you can't fathom this is because of guilty conscience of what you believe in
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't understand what do they want from us? Do they expect us to swarm social media shedding crocodile tears, and abusing Israel? Or do they want us to start boycotting any product or service that directly or indirectly benefits Israel? Or do they want us to stop all types of business/trade and diplomatic ties with Israel?

Those are the things that Muslims do because of their Ummah brotherhood. Why would anyone expect non Muslims in India to do the same?​
Nothing, you are free to do as you wish.
The criticism is for the support of genocide and defense for those who are criticised for committing genocide. - self explanatory.
 
Here is one way how we can do that... how many protests were done in the universities here in the USA in support of the Yemeni victims?




We will find out soon ... that is if you can respond to my post# 389 on this very thread... instead of running away.
The protests in the west are funded by everyone who wants to bringdown west. Palestinian cause is just an excuse. Half of those protesters are professional anarchists. Globalists, Communists, LGBT+, Socialists have all joined hands to cause civil unrest. These are all clearly organized and the Democratic party is playing both sides of the match. On one hand, they support Israel and on the other hand they also support these protests.

Until the US elections are over, we will not see a concrete stance of US on the Israel-Palestine war.
 
Typing this as i’m travelling to Lake Placif with my Hindu friend and to meet up a Jewish friend to go on a 8 hours hike.

Clearly not friends with Hindutva and Zionist.
Don't forget to pickup your black rainbow friend too on your way.
 
I don't understand what do they want from us? Do they expect us to swarm social media shedding crocodile tears, and abusing Israel? Or do they want us to start boycotting any product or service that directly or indirectly benefits Israel? Or do they want us to stop all types of business/trade and diplomatic ties with Israel?

Those are the things that Muslims do because of their Ummah brotherhood. Why would anyone expect non Muslims in India to do the same?​

How about just stop justifying israeli genocide of the Palestinians?
 
How about just stop justifying israeli genocide of the Palestinians?
You guys won't even say a word against Hamas for slaughtering 1200 innocent civilians in Israel, but want the rest of the world to condemn Israel? One of the posters was even justifying what Hamas did. Who started the whole mess, Hamas or Israel? Would Israel have reacted the way they did if Hamas had not butchered 1200 Israelis?

If you don't have the intestinal fortitude to condemn Hamas for what they did, don't expect us to condemn Israel either.​
 
You guys won't even say a word against Hamas for slaughtering 1200 innocent civilians in Israel, but want the rest of the world to condemn Israel? One of the posters was even justifying what Hamas did. Who started the whole mess, Hamas or Israel? Would Israel have reacted the way they did if Hamas had not butchered 1200 Israelis?

If you don't have the intestinal fortitude to condemn Hamas for what they did, don't expect us to condemn Israel either.​

Why should he condemn Hamas?

Why should you condemn Israel?

Freedom of choice is a concept you need to learn.
 
But surely you do realise that doing nothing and commiting mass murder is like comparing chalk and cheese
No I don't! If you don't stop a war then it is as good as supporting it. You do also realize that the Saudi's have deep political interests with the Zionists.
 
Doing nothing isn't great, but at least they aren't committing genocide like the Israelis. That's the difference. If you want to criticise Saudis be my guest but maybe bump a thread about Saudi Arabia.
What are you saying? I am not only attacking the Saudi's but all Muslim countries particularly the Arab ones. I hope that makes you feel better. No Bin Salman is just telling Israel to "kill the Palestinians all you want we won't be doing anything other then turn the other way".
 
No I don't! If you don't stop a war then it is as good as supporting it. You do also realize that the Saudi's have deep political interests with the Zionists.

I've got no affiliation with the Saudi government- regime, but you got to defrenciate from no action to 76 years of brutal occupation
 
You guys won't even say a word against Hamas for slaughtering 1200 innocent civilians in Israel, but want the rest of the world to condemn Israel? One of the posters was even justifying what Hamas did. Who started the whole mess, Hamas or Israel? Would Israel have reacted the way they did if Hamas had not butchered 1200 Israelis?

If you don't have the intestinal fortitude to condemn Hamas for what they did, don't expect us to condemn Israel either.​

Do you condem the 1948 Nakbah massacre?
 
I've got no affiliation with the Saudi government- regime, but you got to defrenciate from no action to 76 years of brutal occupation
To me no action is cowardice.This is what IK did when India revoked article 370.
 
Typing this as i’m travelling to Lake Placif with my Hindu friend and to meet up a Jewish friend to go on a 8 hours hike.

Clearly not friends with Hindutva and Zionist.

Anecdotal vs Empirical evidence. As it stands there is not a single major religion that Muslims can claim to have lived harmoniously with for a substantial amount of time in any corner of the world. They have long standing disputes almost everywhere in the world.

That is a cold hard facts.
 
The state of Palestine did not exist before 1948. There is no such country. It was inhabited by Arabs and Jews.

Israel was established as a Jewish homeland and Arab nations wanted to end it before it even began.

Somebody should start a thread on the creation of Israel vs creation of Pakistan and the similarities between the two, should make for an interesting discussion.
 
As it stands there is not a single major religion that Muslims can claim to have lived harmoniously with for a substantial amount of time in any corner of the world. They have long standing disputes almost everywhere in the world.

Is this true ? Make your case.
 
Is this true ? Make your case.


Sure thing.

1. Jews - Israel now and in the past EVERYWHERE in the middle east. There is hardly any Jew left in Pakistan.
2. Christians - Practically everywhere including Chechnya, Lebanon and as far away as in NZ/AUS.
3. Buddhists - Myanmar, Srilanka
4. Hindus - Practically everywhere in India, Pak, BD
5. Atheist's - China
6. Ultra Liberals - A whole bunch of Scandinavian countries and Canada.

Let me know if you want to go back in time.
 
Sure thing.

1. Jews - Israel now and in the past EVERYWHERE in the middle east. There is hardly any Jew left in Pakistan.
2. Christians - Practically everywhere including Chechnya, Lebanon and as far away as in NZ/AUS.
3. Buddhists - Myanmar, Srilanka
4. Hindus - Practically everywhere in India, Pak, BD
5. Atheist's - China
6. Ultra Liberals - A whole bunch of Scandinavian countries and Canada.

Let me know if you want to go back in time.

Yet every election. Your leader keeps on making sure, that Pakistan lives rent free in his head.
 
You need to practice what you preach. When we question the Hindutwa extremists, you start throwing a tantrum

Who are you to question anyone about their choice of criticizing or not criticizing anyone?

This isn't pakistan where people have to toe your line or face the music.

This is a free world.
 
Sure thing.

1. Jews - Israel now and in the past EVERYWHERE in the middle east. There is hardly any Jew left in Pakistan.
2. Christians - Practically everywhere including Chechnya, Lebanon and as far away as in NZ/AUS.
3. Buddhists - Myanmar, Srilanka
4. Hindus - Practically everywhere in India, Pak, BD
5. Atheist's - China
6. Ultra Liberals - A whole bunch of Scandinavian countries and Canada.

Let me know if you want to go back in time.

^ Interesting, and you think these are all motivated by their religious doctrine rather than being standard geopolitical territorial disputes ?
 
You guys won't even say a word against Hamas for slaughtering 1200 innocent civilians in Israel, but want the rest of the world to condemn Israel? One of the posters was even justifying what Hamas did. Who started the whole mess, Hamas or Israel? Would Israel have reacted the way they did if Hamas had not butchered 1200 Israelis?

If you don't have the intestinal fortitude to condemn Hamas for what they did, don't expect us to condemn Israel either.​

Israel by turning Gaza into a concentration camp until Hamas turned to desperate measures. But regardless of who started what, even if you have no affiliation with either side, why would an Indian feel it necessary to defend genocide committed by the israelis? Why not just stay neutral even if you don't sympathise with those who have suffered more?
 
^ Interesting, and you think these are all motivated by their religious doctrine rather than being standard geopolitical territorial disputes ?

Without a shadow of doubt. Do this thought experiment... Why do Buddhists who are widely spread across the globe .... dont have any religious conflicts with anyone in the world ?

The litmus test of religious tolerance can be literally ascertained by checking the track record of any religious group in question vs their track record against Buddhist. Actually Jains would be the top pick but they are literally miniscule in numbers outside India.
 
Israel by turning Gaza into a concentration camp until Hamas turned to desperate measures. But regardless of who started what, even if you have no affiliation with either side, why would an Indian feel it necessary to defend genocide committed by the israelis? Why not just stay neutral even if you don't sympathise with those who have suffered more?
You don't get desperate and kill innocent people who have nothing to do with the atrocities you have suffered. It's exactly this mentality of yours shared by some of my countrymen that led to the 1984 Anti Sikh riots and the 2002 Gujarat riots. By the way, being a 'Brit', why exactly do you feel the need to shed tears for Palestine?
 
Without a shadow of doubt. Do this thought experiment... Why do Buddhists who are widely spread across the globe .... dont have any religious conflicts with anyone in the world ?

The litmus test of religious tolerance can be literally ascertained by checking the track record of any religious group in question vs their track record against Buddhist. Actually Jains would be the top pick but they are literally miniscule in numbers outside India.

Hmm .. no pushback from the muslim posters on here. It seems like they agree with you! :unsure:
 
You need to practice what you preach. When we question the Hindutwa extremists, you start throwing a tantrum

Question all you want... but I can assure you upfront that you will quickly and quietly do a tactical retreat or go AWOL sooner or later as history and current affairs are not in your favor

On the other hand I will promise you that I will be here regularly reminding you to respond to pointed questions. Speaking of which .... no response to post #496 ?
 
Hmm .. no pushback from the muslim posters on here. It seems like they agree with you! :unsure:

Just wait and watch.... as sure as the natural phenomena that is sunrise and sunset you will sooner or later find the usual suspects show up here and try to shout me down or deflect from the elephant in the room ... i.e.: Muslim extremism.
 
Someone is giving sermon about Budhist?
You don't get desperate and kill innocent people who have nothing to do with the atrocities you have suffered. It's exactly this mentality of yours shared by some of my countrymen that led to the 1984 Anti Sikh riots and the 2002 Gujarat riots. By the way, being a 'Brit', why exactly do you feel the need to shed tears for Palestine?
neither does every 8 years old and younger before October 7th, 6th, 5th…….
 
Anecdotal vs Empirical evidence. As it stands there is not a single major religion that Muslims can claim to have lived harmoniously with for a substantial amount of time in any corner of the world. They have long standing disputes almost everywhere in the world.

That is a cold hard facts.
You got Muslims. Congrats
 
Somebody should start a thread on the creation of Israel vs creation of Pakistan and the similarities between the two, should make for an interesting discussion.
I fully support 2 state solution. This solution is already in place with Gaza and West Bank under Hamas and Palestinian Authority rule. But the extremist elements on both sides need to take a chill break and understand the situation. If not for them, for their future generations, they should give up their violent ways.
 
Somebody should start a thread on the creation of Israel vs creation of Pakistan and the similarities between the two, should make for an interesting discussion.
Yes Pakistani people came from abroad, kicked out the people living there


Ofcourse if the similarities are related to mass murder then your country is guilty of the same during partition. And commited as many brutal crimes.

The only thing similar is Israel being created as a Jewish state and Pakistan as a Muslim

That's it

Pakistani people otherwise were all born in the South Asian subcontinent. And not Europe.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Question all you want... but I can assure you upfront that you will quickly and quietly do a tactical retreat or go AWOL sooner or later as history and current affairs are not in your favor

On the other hand I will promise you that I will be here regularly reminding you to respond to pointed questions. Speaking of which .... no response to post #496 ?

Off course. I've given my points, answers. Problem is , your Narrative as a Hindutwa extremist falls in line with the pro israelis so you only believe what you want to.

I've also replied to 496.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I fully support 2 state solution. This solution is already in place with Gaza and West Bank under Hamas and Palestinian Authority rule. But the extremist elements on both sides need to take a chill break and understand the situation. If not for them, for their future generations, they should give up their violent ways.

But but, Netanyahu has openly admitted, NO to a palastanian state.
 
You see, your ilk can't comprehend pro israeli movement as as a oppressive regime which has neglected all religions. They have killed Christians, muslims, orthodox Jews, because of their extremism. Their plan on GREATER ISRAEL is all planned up decades ago in which they plan to extend their illegal occupation in to other territories. The reason you can't fathom this is because of guilty conscience of what you believe in

Hold your horses ... first answer the very simple question that I have asked multiple times. Its quoted below one more time ...

Off course. I've given my points, answers. Problem is , your Narrative as a Hindutwa extremist falls in line with the pro israelis, so you only believe what you want to.

I've also replied to 496.

No you did not answer my question which I have asked atleast 3 times already ... let me repeat that one more time:

Outside of Israel +Palestine what is the reason for the near complete absence of Jewish population from almost the entire middle eastern Muslim countries plus North Africa ?

I will tell you this upfront .... You will go to the ends of the earth to dance around and NEVER EVER answer that very simple question. Go ahead and prove me wrong.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good. Now feel free to direct your Ire/Outrage towards the root cause of the problem i.e. your co-religionsts across the globe. Cheers! 🍻

Majority of the strong 1.5 billion muslims across the globe live in peace.

It's the same in Hindus who majority are peace loving people, by the minority
Hold your horses ... first answer the very simple question that I have asked multiple times. Its quoted below one more time ...



No you did not answer my question which I have asked atleast 3 times already ... let me repeat that one more time:

Outside of Israel +Palestine what is the reason for the near complete absence of Jewish population from almost the entire middle eastern Muslim countries plus North Africa ?

I will tell you this upfront .... You will go to the ends of the earth to dance around and NEVER EVER answer that very simple question. Go ahead and prove me wrong.

I've given you my answer. And basically IF IT DOESNT SUIT YOUR NARRATIVE, JOG ON.
 
I've given you my answer. And basically IF IT DOESNT SUIT YOUR NARRATIVE, JOG ON.

You absolutely and categorically did not answer the very simple question which was : Why are there hardly the any Jews in almost all Middle east + north African countries except Israel and Palestine?

Need Straight answers.
 
You absolutely and categorically did not answer the very simple question which was : Why are there hardly the any Jews in almost all Middle east + north African countries except Israel and Palestine?

Need Straight answers.

I've Given you my answer.
 
Absolutely NOT . And Not even remotely close.

All you did was to skirt around the issue hoping that I would just go away ... well sadly for you that is not going to happen.

Well. If it doesn't suit you EXTREME NARRATIVE JOG ON
 
So far it's Comprehensively evident, our Hindutwa friends will defend the pro israeli regime and it's actions at all costs. Maybe guilty conscience kicks in, when turning a blind eye to the evident Genocide.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So far it's Comprehensively evident, our Hindutwa friends will defend the extreme zionest Regime and it's actions at all costs. Maybe guilty conscience kicks in, when turning a blind eye to the evident Genocide.

Come back to this thread when you can answer with facts as to why the Jewish population is almost non existent in the entire middle east and north Africa ( outside of Israel and Palestine)

But Your dogged refusal to answer that very simple question should give you reasons as to u why Israel replies with disproportionate force to deal with militants.
 
Come back to this thread when you can answer with facts as to why the Jewish population is almost non existent in the entire middle east and north Africa ( outside of Israel and Palestine)

But Your dogged refusal to answer that very simple question should give you reasons as to u why Israel replies with disproportionate force to deal with militants.

Bingo. You've answered it. Referring to majority of the 40k murdered women and children as " militants". That Shows the level of hatred and malice you have.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But but, Netanyahu has openly admitted, NO to a palastanian state.
I don't agree with Israel's plan of taking over Gaza and deradicalizing youth by giving them modern education etc.. You cannot take over a country which does not want to be with you unless the people there demand for it. Islam and Judaism can never be at peace. It just needs one spark to become a full scale inferno.
I only support Israel until the part of eliminating Hamas. Once that is achieved, I am hoping Egypt takes over Gaza and Jordan takes over West Bank.

The choice should be for the people of both Gaza and WB to choose what they want to be. They had not had any elections since 2004. Its been 2 decades. No one really knows what Palestinians want.
 
Come back to this thread when you can answer with facts as to why the Jewish population is almost non existent in the entire middle east and north Africa ( outside of Israel and Palestine)

But Your dogged refusal to answer that very simple question should give you reasons as to u why Israel replies with disproportionate force to deal with militants.

There were Jewish tribes living in all over Middle East if you have to go by the Biography of Prophet Muhammad. But they were expelled during his time according to Islamic literature.
 
Bingo. You've answered it. Referring to majority of the 40k murdered women and children as " militants". That Shows the level of hatred and malice you have.

So lets get this straight .... you have ZERO concern about near complete and systematic ethnic cleansing of Jews from numerous Muslim countries to the extent that you don't even bother responding to the question about their ethnic cleansing despite me asking that numerous times.

But yet you expect all the niceties and careful consideration on Israel's part when responding to atrocities initiated against their civilians even when their women and children were attacked.

This widespread bigotry is the reason why Israel acts the way it does in response to attrocities against them. They have suffered enough for many centuries and have learnt that this is the only way to survive.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
There were Jewish tribes living in all over Middle East if you have to go by the Biography of Prophet Muhammad. But they were expelled during his time according to Islamic literature.

Correct. And that precedent was carried forward and acted upon after every single Islamic conquest.

But fat chance anyone will question that here for obvious reasons but instead they will get all hot and heavy when the exact same meds are dished out by others.
 
So lets get this straight .... you have ZERO concern about near complete and systematic ethnic cleansing of Jews from numerous Muslim countries to the extent that you don't even bother responding to the question about their ethnic cleansing despite me asking that numerous times.

But yet you expect all the niceties and careful consideration on Israel's part when responding to atrocities initiated against their civilians even when their women and children were attacked.

This widespread bigotry is the reason why Israel acts the way it does in response to attrocities against them. They have suffered enough for many centuries and have learnt that this is the only way to survive.

Only thing il say, a hindutwa extremist sat in india who has no affiliations with the zionests, yet no surprise your hatred towards muslims, YOU'VE BRANDED INNOCENT PALASTANIAN WOMEN AND CHILDREN MURDERED AS MILITANTS.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Back
Top