Heartiest congratulations to England on yet another historic and breathtaking Test victory against India. Chasing down two successive 370+ targets is nothing short of extraordinary. Credit where it’s due — this would not have been possible without the Bazball approach. England have built a seasoned, mentally strong core who execute their roles with precision. And while they still have weak links, India simply failed to exploit them.
India, on the other hand, must urgently reassess their entire Test setup — starting from the coaching staff. Gautam Gambhir, with all due respect for winning us two ICC tournaments, seems to have drained the soul and character out of this side. As a coach, he appears overly rigid, confrontational, and frankly uninspiring. Maybe that approach works for him personally, but it doesn’t translate well into team leadership. Indian cricket needs a coach who can foster growth, not just enforce control. It’s time the BCCI considers a change.
Shubman Gill, as a young captain, deserves some patience. We knew the risks when we appointed someone whose place in the XI wasn’t even fully secure. So let’s not act shocked at the early hiccups. That said, he needs to evolve quickly. India needs an assertive, commanding leader — not someone who appears unsure. This is not a team of hungry youngsters; it’s a room full of multi-millionaires. Leadership in Indian cricket demands a firm hand. Virat, Rohit, Dhoni, Kumble, and Ganguly — all were strong-willed leaders who got the best out of their teams. Weak leadership just won’t cut it in this environment.
The bowling, however, was the biggest disappointment. Prasidh Krishna has sadly been exposed — effective in T20s, but simply not cut out for Test cricket. There’s no aggression, no presence. He doesn’t even attempt to challenge batters mentally — and you need that in red-ball cricket. Shardul Thakur performed to expectations. He is what he is — a limited-conditions swing bowler, and those conditions just didn’t turn up.
Mohammed Siraj remains too inconsistent. Fans are left waiting for him to “click,” but international cricket isn’t about occasional brilliance. He needs to be consistently threatening — and he wasn’t. Dropped catches didn’t help, but that’s part of the game.
Ravindra Jadeja, abroad, remains a painful reminder of our lack of match-winning spinners outside Asia since Chandrasekhar in the 1970s.
Karun Nair, after such a long absence, deserves a bit of slack. Here’s hoping for a better show in the next Test.
Yashasvi Jaiswal — your century is overshadowed by your shockingly poor fielding. Dropping 4-5 catches in a single game is unacceptable at any level, let alone international cricket. Regardless of your hundred, your overall impact was negative. Catches win matches — and you cost us dearly. There’s no shortage of batting talent in India. If this level of carelessness continues, you’ll find yourself out of the XI quickly. Talent isn’t a free pass to mediocrity.
And here’s the broader concern — England seems to have changed the blueprint to beat India at home. Earlier, they relied on swinging conditions. Now, they’re willing to play us on flat pitches, confident that our batters won’t pile up 600s and that our bowlers can’t defend even sizable targets. That’s a big psychological shift — and it should worry Indian cricket deeply.
Lastly, a word on Virat Kohli. Whatever your views, be respectful of what he brought to Indian Test cricket. Even if we had lost this Test under him, the fight would have been visible — the energy, the defiance, the belief. Under his leadership, India treated Test cricket as a badge of pride. What we saw in this match was a disinterested unit going through the motions. No fire, no hunger, no intent. And if this continues, Indian fans are in for some long, painful days ahead.