What's new

India [234/3] beat Australia [230] by 7 wickets in the third ODI to win the ODI series 2-1

BreadPakoda said:
You will not understand as you support a team with no cricketing legacy - no world cups to show, no big moments. Fans of elite teams want the absolute best. Nothing less. And Dhoni isn't the absolute best "for us" at this point.
Click to expand...
If we had half the resources you had, I can assure you we wouldn't just have the 2 WCs. You've underperformed with all the advantages you have over every other country - you have the money and talent pool but are behind Aus and WI in terms of success.
 
WengerOut said:
This is the reason. It is too less frequent to remember. That was 2 years ago
Click to expand...
Dhoni bats down the order and has a batting line up of Rohit, Dhawan and Kohli, it's difficult for him to be the stand out performer often.

It's not his job to be the stand out performer either, he's a support player. As long as he's scoring 50s and finishing games, he's doing his job.
 
Last edited:
Aman said:
Dhoni bats down the order and has a batting line up of Rohit, Dhawan and Kohli, it's difficult for him to be the stand out performer often.

It's not his job to be the stand out performer either, he's a support player.
Click to expand...

No need to be stand out. Performance that has positive effect
 
WengerOut said:
No need to be stand out. Performance that has positive effect
Click to expand...
As long as he's scoring runs and winning matches, is it not positive? Last match he saw India home and is keeping India in the game today.
 
Aman said:
If we had half the resources you had, I can assure you we wouldn't just have the 2 WCs. You've underperformed with all the advantages you have over every other country - you have the money and talent pool but are behind Aus and WI in terms of success.
Click to expand...

Could've, would've, should've, once again. Sadly, that's all you've got.

Any way, that's not even my point. All I am saying is that it seems like its difficult for you to comprehend our plight at seeing Dhoni in the team. It stems from the fact that there are high expectations from India. For NZ, getting into a semi final is their biggest achievement in the game, something elite teams can any way do without breaking a sweat. Hence expectations are low from their players. Don't take it to heart.
 
Aman said:
As long as he's scoring runs and winning matches, is it not positive? Last match he saw India home and is keeping India in the game today.
Click to expand...

He is not having a say in winning matches. He need somebody to accelerate at the other end. It is not the norm nowadays just to occupy the crease and score. I believe you advocate against Kane exactly for that. So why this hypocrisy?
 
BreadPakoda said:
Could've, would've, should've, once again. Sadly, that's all you've got.

Any way, that's not even my point. All I am saying is that it seems like its difficult for you to comprehend our plight at seeing Dhoni in the team. It stems from the fact that there are high expectations from India. For NZ, getting into a semi final is their biggest achievement in the game, something elite teams can any way do without breaking a sweat. Hence expectations are low from their players. Don't take it to heart.
Click to expand...
Well either way, making a SF would be an accomplishment for India - with or without Dhoni.

You've gone life and death with a Aus team missing their two best batsmen and a lot of their first string bowlers.
 
WengerOut said:
He is not having a say in winning matches. He need somebody to accelerate at the other end. It is not the norm nowadays just to occupy the crease and score. I believe you advocate against Kane exactly for that. So why this hypocrisy?
Click to expand...
That's for T20s.

ODI's I'm fine with him and Taylor providing a platform and allowing the others the freedom to hit/play their natural game.
 
Aman said:
Can't remember against who think it may have been SL/Aus when India had a comically low score and Dhoni got them to some respectability. I remember commenting in the match thread for it. Think India still lost but he was great in that match.
Click to expand...

I got it but as said, in the context of the game, that inning had no mean and it was perfectly suited for him, no run-scoring pressure, bowlers not trying any hard as they know damage has been done and pitch eases out as well.

Today is arguably the best he is playing in perhaps last two-three years(that again because he doesn't have to deal with quick scoring pressure)and his first standout performance with bat in last few years but you should understand that India have decent enough batting resources benched who can definitely chase 230 on a flat wicket but can also hit some quick-fire runs when the need of hour is to maximize on the platform laid by top order.

I mean, Pant, is one guy the way he played in that final test in Australia, you think he doesn't deserves to be in LO squad? He is perfectly suited to 5 or 6.
 
Aman said:
Well either way, making a SF would be an accomplishment for India - with or without Dhoni.

You've gone life and death with a Aus team missing their two best batsmen and a lot of their first string bowlers.
Click to expand...

India were closely tied with England with a W% around 70% in 2018, and won 5-1 in SA. India and England are guaranteed to qualify for the semis, regardless of what you think based on this series.
 
Aman said:
That's for T20s.

ODI's I'm fine with him and Taylor providing a platform and allowing the others the freedom to hit/play their natural game.
Click to expand...

Todays matches are like extended T20s. Teams like Eng, NZ play like that. So Dhoni won't be suitable for that unless for specific situations like this low scoring. Nobody is denying his strength of mind, but his runs are having less impact these days. You won't see any Indian bashing Dhoni of 3 years ago. Then why troll here about WC 2011 win??
 
Aman said:
Well either way, making a SF would be an accomplishment for India - with or without Dhoni.

You've gone life and death with a Aus team missing their two best batsmen and a lot of their first string bowlers.
Click to expand...

We are ranked 2 ODI side and been a top 2 side for years now, so no, getting into the SF won't be an achievement.
 
It's truly sad when sanju manju is the only guy talking some sense, shoni is a hack who has gotten too old, he isn't taking the game deep and he definitely isn't playing to get more match practice.
 
Run rate almost reaching 9, and Dhoni plays out 5 dots and a single to farm the strike.
 
Dhoni embarrassing himself again, putting pressure on the non striker. He would have lost the last game if it weren't for Dinesh.
 
Aman said:
Well either way, making a SF would be an accomplishment for India - with or without Dhoni.

You've gone life and death with a Aus team missing their two best batsmen and a lot of their first string bowlers.
Click to expand...
Anything less than a final would be a disappointment, we aren't NZ SF especially with this team would be a disappointment.
 
Aman said:
Well either way, making a SF would be an accomplishment for India - with or without Dhoni.

You've gone life and death with a Aus team missing their two best batsmen and a lot of their first string bowlers.
Click to expand...
lol, so no letting on your whinges, carry on....
 
Even if we somehow win this series, it'd do us more harm than good.
 
To his credit, Kedar played ok today. I have been critical of him, but he played ok in the first outing. India cannot lose from here.
 
Grandpa always takes the (easy)match to the wire to make it interesting.
 
jagatk said:
Anything less than a final would be a disappointment, we aren't NZ SF especially with this team would be a disappointment.
Click to expand...
Prepare yourself for disappointment then.

Your middle order is weak and doesn't have the gears to score quick, that's not all on Dhoni either. Too late to change it now.

Only way you make it is if your top 3 do all the scoring or if you face England and they choke.
 
Last edited:
Make a "Dhoni is the best cricketer ever" thread and watch the trolls swarming that with a 180° U turn.
 
If India wins this, it'll be due to Jadhav. But like everytime, Dhoni will be hailed as messiah.
 
Aman said:
Prepare yourself for disappointment then.

Your middle order is weak and one dimensional, that's not all on Dhoni either. Too late to change it now.
Click to expand...
It won't matter who 4 and 5 are, the top 3 will win most games on their own given we will get batting pitches and in pandya and jadhav we have decent finishers, 2 leggies and bumrah means we have better bowlers than most teams, we will make semis without breaking sweat.
 
Last edited:
Aman said:
Prepare yourself for disappointment then.

Your middle order is weak and doesn't have the gears to score quick, that's not all on Dhoni either. Too late to change it now.

Only way you make it is if your top 3 do all the scoring or if you face England and they choke.
Click to expand...

Dhoni is not a problem.

Middle order including Dhoni is weak and is a problem.

The above 2 are your opinions.
Quite contradicting when you oppose people advocating changing the part of a problem, that is Dhoni
 
Siddlol. Bowling full tosses down leg side when there's a field set for short balls. OTOH why won't the comms get their head out of dhonis ***. We should be winning this comfortably but thanks to him this will.go down to the wire.
 
WengerOut said:
90% of commenentory is about Dhoni now. Poor Jadhav
Click to expand...

It s either singing paens about dhoni or kohli depending on who is batting. Clarke quite rightly said that kohli won't be happy we need 44 from 30 balls considering only 3 wickets are down but apparently coz dhoni is batting he will be calm and know that we will get home.:vk2
 
rollingstoned said:
It s either singing paens about dhoni or kohli depending on who is batting. Clarke quite rightly said that kohli won't be happy we need 44 from 30 balls considering only 3 wickets are down but apparently coz dhoni is batting he will be calm and know that we will get home.:vk2
Click to expand...

They don't want to be direct but they are bringing up the topic again and again. Can't do more than this.
 
If Aussies had taken the caught behind review, we won't be talking about this nonsense now
 
Dhoni dropped. Now see the trolls coming back to thread to say India has been so lucky today.
 
Probably the worst Aussie fielding side ive seen. Far cry from the days of ponting, Symonds, Clarke etc.
 
India will win this


Medium pacer and siddle. Don't expect much
 
MP2011 said:
Even Tendulkar didn't have that kinda influence. At least he remained largely good for India, unlike Dhoni.
Click to expand...
Are you surprised, this guy kept his captaincy on back of politicking gets selectors sacked before himself and then ran away tail between his legs mid tour once he saw the writing on the wall and no srini to save him this time.
 
Last edited:
Jadhav has been sensational today. Despite not playing any int'l cricket for months now, he has batted with great purpose.
 
jagatk said:
Are you surprised this guy kept his captaincy on back of politicking gets selectors sacked before himself and then ran away tail between his legs mis tour once he saw the writing on the wall and no srini to save him this time.
Click to expand...
Yeah.

Dhoni has all the makings of a politician. Should be good career choice for him.
 
I know Stonnis is mentally strong and wants to bowl in the death over. The guy is limited as hell. He should be used in the middle overs
 
I know Dhoni will get all the credit, but its Jadhav who has got us here, 14 off last 2 overs.
 
India cant even chase 231 easily against Aus D side.
 
If not for rain gods - series score lines would have been

2-1(T20I’s)
3-1(Tests)
2-1(ODI’s) for India.
 
Brilliant chase by India. Gave opposition a whiff of false hope and then cruelly pummeling them down
 
Siddle has to be one of the most brainless odi bowlers I have watched.

They need Starc, Hazzlwood and Cummins to be back in the team. Zampa deserves to be ahead of lyon
 
Jadhav has won me over. If only he could improve his fitness.
 
shah_1 said:
Siddle has to be one of the most brainless odi bowlers I have watched.

They need Starc, Hazzlwood and Cummins to be back in the team. Zampa deserves to be ahead of lyon
Click to expand...

No idea why he and Lyon were selected in the first place. Both are far away from being white ball cricketers.
 
Now that it is more or less sealed, see Dhoni coming into his own.
 
shah_1 said:
Siddle has to be one of the most brainless odi bowlers I have watched.

They need Starc, Hazzlwood and Cummins to be back in the team. Zampa deserves to be ahead of lyon
Click to expand...

That bowling attack will not do better than what their current attack is doing, people really overrate the Aussie quicks and Smith in LoI's they are average cricketers in odi.
 
jagatk said:
That bowling attack will not do better than what their current attack is doing, people really overrate the Aussie quicks and Smith in LoI's they are average cricketers in odi.
Click to expand...
That exact team was thrashed badly by Eng team last year. However, whatever is not available to you, suddenly looks good.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

C
1st ODI of the three-match series between India (230) and Sri Lanka (230/8) end in a tie
2 3 4
Replies
260
Views
3K
jnaveen1980
J
C
Sri Lanka (248/7) overwhelm India (138) by 110 runs to clinch the 3 match ODI series by a 2-0 margin
2
Replies
130
Views
2K
Mesozoic
Mesozoic
BouncerGuy
India (137/9 & 4/0) win a super over against Sri Lanka (137/8 & 2/2) by 2 wickets to clean sweep the series 3-0
3 4 5
Replies
363
Views
5K
jnaveen1980
J
BouncerGuy
Abhishek Sharma's 47-ball ton helps India (234/2) rout Zimbabwe (134) by 100 runs, Level Series
2
Replies
153
Views
3K
Mp812
Mp812
FearlessRoar
England (376 & 87/0) comfortably defeat West Indies (282 & 175) in the 3rd Test by 10 wickets to clinch the series 3-0
2 3
Replies
188
Views
2K
James
James
Back
Top