What's new

South Africa (138 & 285/5) defeat Australia (212 & 207) by 5 wickets in the final to clinch the World Test Championship 2023/25 title

So you think Sidhu was a Joginder Sharma level player?

This is not a Rizwan bashing thread, please use your brain here.
Practice what you bloody preach

Do you honestly think Sidhu was a Head level player? What a clownish statement to begin with!
 
In the 1996 tour to WI, Sidhu averaged 46 against the trio of Ambrose, Walsh and Bishop and we have @Rana here comparing Sidhu with Joginder Sharma.
 
In the 1996 tour to WI, Sidhu averaged 46 against the trio of Ambrose, Walsh and Bishop and we have @Rana here comparing Sidhu with Joginder Sharma.
Even a joker like Rizwan averaged something like that against Cummins, Starc and Hazlewood in Australia

Don’t give me random one offs to prove a ridiculous point!
 
Practice what you bloody preach

Do you honestly think Sidhu was a Head level player? What a clownish statement to begin with!
In tests, yes.

Instead of running your mouth go watch some actual cricket from the past.

Shastri used to unleash hell on spinners of the calibre of Warne and Murali.
 
From These peoples hitting few boundary means he is better players :kp
In tests, yes.

Instead of running your mouth go watch some actual cricket from the past.

Shastri used to unleash hell on spinners of the calibre of Warne and Murali.
 
beta stick to Rizwan bashing, this is something way above your calibre.
Don't take these guys view serious because for them Asif Ali is best captain in Pakistan , Usman Khan is best limited over players and fixer Sharjeel is best Opener in Pakistan cricket 😂😂😂😂

:kp
 
Yeah, its a known thing. I am not shocked though, you hardly have any knowledge of cricket pre 2020.

Even his cricinfo profile says the same.
Ravi shahstri faced Warne when warne was a debutant on the flattest wicket possible 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭.

Only an indian can hype a 35 avg test batter and act like he'd be relevant to warne and murli in prime.

Keep your 2020 covid knowledge to yourself please.
 
When did i say that.

I am comparing a 42 averaging test opener from the 90s to a middle order batsman averaging the same?

Is this getting too difficult to grasp?

mominsaigol is not the sharpest tool in the shed. Please forgive him.
 
And Muralitharan has a higher str rate then Head in test cricket :yk
Strike rates increase if you have scores of 5 of 3 or 10 of 4 lol.

A high score is a high score though. Not easy to achieve even especially for a bowling allrounder.

Anyway I like sachin and won't say anything negative about him. I will however laugh at the notion of someone believing ravi shastri is in bootlicker distance of Warne and murli as a cricketer 🤣
 
Ravi shahstri faced Warne when warne was a debutant on the flattest wicket possible 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭.

Only an indian can hype a 35 avg test batter and act like he'd be relevant to warne and murli in prime.

Keep your 2020 covid knowledge to yourself please.
Warne debuted in 1997-1998?

Again, watch some cricket before mouthing off
 
Not sure why Australia are hellbent on shoehorning their middle order batters as openers.

They tried Steve Smith as opener for a while too.
No options. Konstas is too young and Campbell Kellaway needs at least one more season of Shield , but looks the most promising imo.
 
Pathetic umpiring. As I said all the close call will go in australia favour. :kp
 
Travis Head is the 5th greatest all format batsmen of all time after kohli, KP, Gayle and Warner.

Siddu wasnt even relevant in his own era.
 
Should have 6 down till now. Robbed by umpires. once a cheater always a cheater . Give them trophy. :kp
 
Travis Head is the 5th greatest all format batsmen of all time after kohli, KP, Gayle and Warner.

Siddu wasnt even relevant in his own era.
IMO its Kohli, KP and ABDV who would get into the great teams in all formats. They have solid records no matter the format.

Players like Head, Gayle and Warner are tier below. Not bad players across formats by any means but they have some weaknesses in test particularly.
 
IMO its Kohli, KP and ABDV who would get into the great teams in all formats. They have solid records no matter the format.

Players like Head, Gayle and Warner are tier below. Not bad players across formats by any means but they have some weaknesses in test particularly.
By all formats, I mean players that are good in all formats. AB is an odi and test legend but he underachieved in international t20
 
Travis Head is the 5th greatest all format batsmen of all time after kohli, KP, Gayle and Warner.

Siddu wasnt even relevant in his own era.

With Kohli though I was just thinking that out of the so called greats, there has never been a player who has flopped in so many high profile ICC tournament KO games when it actually mattered. And lets be real, even that knock in the ICC T20 final recently was terrible, he can count his lucky stars that SA saved their usual botchmania for the end. You talk about Viv Richards, Travis Head & even KP all these guys played crucial impactful knocks to deliver trophies for their country. Kohli was amazing in bilaterals however, he just didn’t have the marbles when it mattered, it’s a genetic issue and not his fault. I wish him well and hope he can take care of Anushka’s kids in the UK very well.
 
Smith is on 45*. He needs to score a big hundred.

Opportunity for rookie Webster to make a name for himself.
 
By all formats, I mean players that are good in all formats. AB is an odi and test legend but he underachieved in international t20
You are right, he underachieved compared to his IPL exploits, yeah, but he was still a very, very good player in T20i.
 
Who can forget Amir bent Kohli in a KO game against Pakistan to; such a legendary player, I wouldn’t pick him for the Warwickshire Bears second XI in a knockout game. Coward chickened out from this England tour to.
 
You are right, he underachieved compared to his IPL exploits, yeah, but he was still a very, very good player in T20i.
I disagree.

AB avg 26 with a 135 sr in t20. Despite being one of the most explosive league batters, he was beyond awful in international t20.

He is obviously >>>>>>>>>>> Head in odi and test and head won't ever reach him, but head is consistently good in all formats.

HTB in tests with 9 centuries + 1 wtc final, 40+ avg and 100+ sr in modern odi with impact knocks and a solid sr in t20 is good enough to be considered all format.

De villers basically falls in the realm of root and smith, aka solid odi and test players but average t20 players.

Although de villers is leagues and leagues > Smith and root in odi
 
Webster is so underrated. A hidden gem. People forgot that he turned the tidies for AU in BGT. His knocks were small but crucial. And marsh was history.
 
Webster lucky to survive till now but Smith has batted beautifully and with alot of patience and concentration.
 
Kevin Pietersen's whole thing while commentating is saying the same thing multiple times.

"South Africa need Smith. They need Smith. They need Smith. They want him."

We understood you the first time bro.

He is one of the worst commentators around.
 
50 for the Test GOAT.

A real privilege to watch him bat.
And this is why I rate smith > Sachin. Sachin never throughout 24 years of test cricket got his team out of a collapse or a tricky jam.

He scored big but only due to dravid + Sehwag + Ganguly performing prior.

Sachin has a few solid knocks in odi such as desert storm but in test he has zero match saves.

This isnt the first time smith has rescued either. He once reduced Aus against England won them the game single handidely.

Easily the greatest technician and impact player in test history.
 
And this is why I rate smith > Sachin. Sachin never throughout 24 years of test cricket got his team out of a collapse or a tricky jam.

He scored big but only due to dravid + Sehwag + Ganguly performing prior.

Sachin has a few solid knocks in odi such as desert storm but in test he has zero match saves.

This isnt the first time smith has rescued either. He once reduced Aus against England won them the game single handidely.

Easily the greatest technician and impact player in test history.
I agree 100%
 
With Kohli though I was just thinking that out of the so called greats, there has never been a player who has flopped in so many high profile ICC tournament KO games when it actually mattered. And lets be real, even that knock in the ICC T20 final recently was terrible, he can count his lucky stars that SA saved their usual botchmania for the end. You talk about Viv Richards, Travis Head & even KP all these guys played crucial impactful knocks to deliver trophies for their country. Kohli was amazing in bilaterals however, he just didn’t have the marbles when it mattered, it’s a genetic issue and not his fault. I wish him well and hope he can take care of Anushka’s kids in the UK very well.
Kohli is a known choker.

Bumrah your favourite bowler won it for India.

And head averages under 25 when Rohit isn’t captain. He only does well vs rohit the captain.

Another overrated fraud Rohit. He is just good at putting on more fat.
 
And this is why I rate smith > Sachin. Sachin never throughout 24 years of test cricket got his team out of a collapse or a tricky jam.

He scored big but only due to dravid + Sehwag + Ganguly performing prior.

Sachin has a few solid knocks in odi such as desert storm but in test he has zero match saves.

This isnt the first time smith has rescued either. He once reduced Aus against England won them the game single handidely.

Easily the greatest technician and impact player in test history.
Yeppp 100%
 
Head is an impact player.

Even if he is not very consistent, a team needs someone like him.

Nailed it.

It's not his problem that most of the batsmen up the order are hacks atm, so, he should continue to play his natural game as that's what has made him successful thus far.
 
Australia are getting into a good position now.

Vintage Australia.

AUS - 107/4 (33.4 overs).
 
Back
Top