What's new

[VIDEOS] Why anti Muslim bias is so profound among Hindutva supporters?

Hindus don't like muslims because?

Can anybody tell me the main reasons ???
1 main reason i can think of is cows.
2nd main reason is they still blame today's muslims for the things that happened 200 years ago in Mughal dynasty.
3rd reason is bjp brainwashing them that muslim will rule india if they are not controlled and they will kills Hindus.
 
The Bald Eagle said:
Lol...do you think people all around the world slaughter or kill cow for fun or eating? It's just a no brainer
Click to expand...

Don't talk about around the world.

In India killing cows is illegal. Throwing its head near a temple is inviting a riot.

Why Muslims do it and why are you defending it?
 
Stewie said:
Why do you and your kind have problem with Muslims expressing their faith then? You asking for evidence but when someone brings up cows the inner navy comes out screaming and whining.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ohh the double standards here!
Click to expand...

Killing cows is Muslim expression of faith?
 
BouncerGuy said:
Hindus don't like muslims because?

Can anybody tell me the main reasons ???
1 main reason i can think of is cows.
2nd main reason is they still blame today's muslims for the things that happened 200 years ago in Mughal dynasty.
3rd reason is bjp brainwashing them that muslim will rule india if they are not controlled and they will kills Hindus.
Click to expand...

There is no BJP brainwashing. We can see the condition of Hindus in BD and Pakistan.
 
Stewie said:
Pork is not “banned” in Pakistan. People just don’t eat it. If it’s a Christian establishment catering to Christian’s, they are free to serve it nobody is going to punish them for it.

But more importantly, Pakistan is not even a secular state which you guys claim to be. So why this ban? Not only a ban but hindutva guys are conducting extra judicial killings of Muslims who they claim killed cows.

What justification can be provided for such heinous Hindus policies and actions?
Click to expand...

Secular states cannot have protected animals?

Cow is a protected animal in India.

If Muslims defy law and think they can do what they please and insult another religion then the other side will retaliate. That's human behaviour.

One must not light matches sitting on a barrel of gunpowder.

We don't need to provide any justification for our laws to anyone, just like you don't need for your laws.
 
Stewie said:
Why do you and your kind have problem with Muslims expressing their faith then? You asking for evidence but when someone brings up cows the inner navy comes out screaming and whining.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ohh the double standards here!
Click to expand...

Finally the truth is out.

Killing cows and insulting another religion is expression of faith for Muslims.
 
BouncerGuy said:
Hindus don't like muslims because?

Can anybody tell me the main reasons ???
1 main reason i can think of is cows.
2nd main reason is they still blame today's muslims for the things that happened 200 years ago in Mughal dynasty.
3rd reason is bjp brainwashing them that muslim will rule india if they are not controlled and they will kills Hindus.
Click to expand...
I had answered this in post #23 in the first page of the thread, and neither cow or mughals were the reasons. Posting it again to refresh your memory:

Let us forget the past and focus only on present.

1. Muslims refuse to hand over temple which was converted to a mosque, despite it clearly showing parts of the temple. And it is not about many temples, just 2-3 which hold very high sanctity for hindus.

2. Many indian muslims protested giving citizenship to minority refugees who were already living in india. It was not an open offer for population exchange, nor was it about taking away citizenship, but to give citizenship to those refugees who were already living in India. Yet many indian muslims took to streets to protest against that.

3. And the common supremacist belief that we ruled you guys. It may suit Pakistanis, but Indian muslims can't cling to this supremacist thought if they want to live like equals.

4. Refusal to accept secular laws. Want to have their own parallel system where indian laws do not apply. Like opposing giving maintenance to wives after divorce. You can't have a parallel justice system and being exclusionary, and then complain of being othered.

5. Many muslims will not see anything wrong in the above points, and I understand that it is the way their brain is wired. So it is not for convincing anyone, but some points which show how there will be resentment even if you forget the history.
 
Stewie said:
Why do you and your kind have problem with Muslims expressing their faith then? You asking for evidence but when someone brings up cows the inner navy comes out screaming and whining.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ohh the double standards here!
Click to expand...
Show me any verse from Quraan which says that cow slaughter is a religious requirement of the muslims.
Or even a Hadith, or even a WEAK hadith.

Cow slaughter IS NOT a religious need of muslims. Preventing cow slaughter is not religious oppression of muslims.
 
The Prophet (s.a.w) used to eat meat in moderation.
Tirmidhi: The worst vessel a man can fill is his stomach.

Abu Hurayrah reports: “Meat was brought to the Prophet. The shoulder was handed over to him, as he liked it. He had a bite of it.” (Related by Ahmad, Al-Bukhari and Muslim).

Even if it is not a religious requirement, and you only want to follow the Sunnah of Prophet (s.a.w) then he preferred the shoulder of the lamb, and even that in moderation.

So since when cow meat became a religious need of muslims? After muslims become gluttons and decided to ignore the Sunnah of the Holy Prophet?
 
The Bald Eagle said:
Lol...do you think people all around the world slaughter or kill cow for fun or eating? It's just a no brainer
Click to expand...

Cows are extremely sacred to most Hindus.

Do you understand and recognize that ? A simple YES/NO answer please without resorting to rhetorical questions.
 
BouncerGuy said:
Hindus don't like muslims because?

Can anybody tell me the main reasons ???
1 main reason i can think of is cows.
2nd main reason is they still blame today's muslims for the things that happened 200 years ago in Mughal dynasty.
3rd reason is bjp brainwashing them that muslim will rule india if they are not controlled and they will kills Hindus.
Click to expand...

The main reason is the mindset which is displayed in this very thread by certain posters is extrapolated 10 times and by real life Muslims.

But like I said before, no Muslim will introspect about the main reason.

They have victim mentality imbibed in their minds and will continue to blame Mughals, cow, RSS etc just like you are doing.
 
CricketCartoons said:
Show me any verse from Quraan which says that cow slaughter is a religious requirement of the muslims.
Or even a Hadith, or even a WEAK hadith.

Cow slaughter IS NOT a religious need of muslims. Preventing cow slaughter is not religious oppression of muslims.
Click to expand...
There is no such verse.

Indian Muslims clergy has voluntarily advocated that Muslims should refrain from eating beef or slaughtering since before partition.

It's your community who dithers and finds loopholes to allow it to happen.
 
Stewie said:
So I pray Fajr prayer out in the open, does that mean I have to prove to you or whoever witnessed me doing so that there is an Allah and Muhammed PBUH is His True Last Prophet?

How much sense does that make?

If a Hindu is raining bell at a Mandir, does he or she have to prove that the Bhagwan sitting inside actually heard the bell ring?


You are making no sense.
Click to expand...

Except the conflict is never about the very simplistic scenario that you are describing. As it stands, despite literally centuries of bloody conflict EVEN the most well educated Muslims do not budge on how sacred cows are to Hindus, which explains all there is to know about why Muslims have very little tolerance for non-muslims especially the idolators. And then the same people will go on and paint the Hindus as intolerant !!! Madness galore!.

This thread is a LIVE example!
 
DeadlyVenom said:
There is no such verse.

Indian Muslims clergy has voluntarily advocated that Muslims should refrain from eating beef or slaughtering since before partition.

It's your community who dithers and finds loopholes to allow it to happen.
Click to expand...
My community is full of munafiqs. In an ideal world, I would create an Al Qaeda just to deal with munafiqs who call themselves hindu.
 
CricketCartoons said:
My community is full of munafiqs. In an ideal world, I would create an Al Qaeda just to deal with munafiqs who call themselves hindu.
Click to expand...

Please try beef: it's delicious. Believe me, you'll start liking beef more than Modi more than India a few munches in.
 
BouncerGuy said:
Hindus don't like muslims because?

Can anybody tell me the main reasons ???
1 main reason i can think of is cows.
2nd main reason is they still blame today's muslims for the things that happened 200 years ago in Mughal dynasty.
3rd reason is bjp brainwashing them that muslim will rule india if they are not controlled and they will kills Hindus.
Click to expand...

Cows, Mughals and BJP. Are these really your three takeaways from the thread
 
CricketCartoons said:
The next time I come to Bombay, I will knock to be your guest. Deal?
Click to expand...

Nope. In the likes of Bombay and Bangalore, they will pass on buffalo meet under the guise of beef. Fancy restaurants also have it listed as "BeeF" to lure unsuspecting individuals.

Please visit Kerala - that's where the action is at.
 
Varun said:
Please try beef: it's delicious. Believe me, you'll start liking beef more than Modi more than India a few munches in.
Click to expand...

I can vouch for this ..

I have a jar of pickled beef next to me right now, every time I take a bite it makes me wanna be a better man.

Hope you'll take the plunge, I don't know a hindu personally that doesn't like beef. It's their guilty pleasure.
 
RexRex said:
I can vouch for this ..

I have a jar of pickled beef next to me right now, every time I take a bite it makes me wanna be a better man.

Hope you'll take the plunge, I don't know a hindu personally that doesn't like beef. It's their guilty pleasure.
Click to expand...
I have King James Bible, which I still keep on the highest shelf on my book shelf, along with Quraan, and make sure that I don't let dust settle on it. Because I will feel guilty that I am not respecting someones Holy book, despite using it only for academic reasons.
 
Posters here openly mocking Hindus and offering them beef.

Will allow the same if Muslims are offered pork here?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
cricketjoshila said:
Posters here openly mocking Hindus and offering them beef.

Will allow the same if Muslims are offered pork here?
Click to expand...
There is no comparison.

Pork doesn't evoke the same feeling to Muslims which beef does to Hindus.

One evokes disgust, the other evokes deep pain.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
cricketjoshila said:
Posters here openly mocking Hindus and offering them beef.

Will allow the same if Muslims are offered pork here?
Click to expand...

Beef is openly consumed and legal in plenty of areas of the country, sweetheart. Kerala as mentioned above is one such place.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
CricketCartoons said:
Ask the mods to create an interview thread for me, so that I can take such questions. Not in this thread.
Click to expand...

We'll do the questions later. Please make sure your next post is from a shack at a beach in Kerala.
 
CricketCartoons said:
I have King James Bible, which I still keep on the highest shelf on my book shelf, along with Quraan, and make sure that I don't let dust settle on it. Because I will feel guilty that I am not respecting someones Holy book, despite using it only for academic reasons.
Click to expand...

That's a lovely thing to do.

But it seems you are clearly unaware of the millions of hindus in India who adore beef and consume it daily. They reply that they do not see this as a religious requirement. Perhaps you move around in social circles that are extremely orthodox and conservative.

There's a 2009 book by D.N Jha about cow and it's historical place in India. You should take a look.
 
RexRex said:
That's a lovely thing to do.

But it seems you are clearly unaware of the millions of hindus in India who adore beef and consume it daily. They reply that they do not see this as a religious requirement. Perhaps you move around in social circles that are extremely orthodox and conservative.

There's a 2009 book by D.N Jha about cow and it's historical place in India. You should take a look.
Click to expand...
I read DN Jha in 2009 itself. Want to have a debate on his book? I can rip it apart.

When you ask me to read a book, hope you are willing to have a debate on it.
 
CricketCartoons said:
I read DN Jha in 2009 itself. Want to have a debate on his book? I can rip it apart.

When you ask me to read a book, hope you are willing to have a debate on it.
Click to expand...

No thanks .. I asked you serveral months ago to discuss this very thing (holiness of cow) when I had the time and you ran away. Not interested anymore.
 
CricketCartoons said:
And when you see those who engage in [offensive] discourse concerning Our verses, then turn away from them until they enter into another conversation. - Al Quraan.
Click to expand...

You know - from a college canteen to an airplane, the "veg" vs "non veg" choice in India is an illusion. Non-veg mainly refers to chicken. I understand that beef or pork cannot be served easily, but why not mutton? Fish? Look at the length of our coastline, so many people have seafood - you included.

We would have greatly evolved as a nation if we are flying together in an airplane row ABC (A- @CricketCartoons B - @Varun C - @uppercut ) and the friendly hostess offers veg, chicken, beef as a choice and we have what we have without throwing a tanty like @uppercut who is happy with his veg meal.
 
RexRex said:
No thanks .. I asked you serveral months ago to discuss this very thing (holiness of cow) when I had the time and you ran away. Not interested anymore.
Click to expand...
Several months ago? Have I been active since several months after I resumed after. a long break?

Although I quit my job in the end of last year, I was still not free as being a director, the whole process takes a long time.
 
It is interesting to see the other perspective from some Hindus on a sensitive topic such as beef.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
It is interesting to see the other perspective from some Hindus on a sensitive topic such as beef.
Click to expand...

It wasn't as sensitive up to a decade ago. Since then several major states (Karnataka, Maharashtra included) have banned it.
 
I request all of you to post about the topic. COW and BEEF stuff is irrelevant. Read the title of this thread and then post next. THANKS
 
Last edited:
CricketCartoons said:
As much hindu as Salman Rushdie is a muslim.
Click to expand...
Islam has clear doctrines on apostasy.

In contrast you Hindus have been happy cultivating a loosely goosey anything goes image for a long time and lecturing is on open mindedness and not forcing religion on others.

So I don't think we can make a comparison with Hindu beef eaters and apostates in Islam.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
Islam has clear doctrines on apostasy.

In contrast you Hindus have been happy cultivating a loosely goosey anything goes image for a long time and lecturing is on open mindedness and not forcing religion on others.

So I don't think we can make a comparison with Hindu beef eaters and apostates in Islam.
Click to expand...
The munafiq among hindus are the result of the secularism project after independence. It is the post independence which created an army of hinduism hating hindus, who are not even culturally hindus. During mughals and british, hindus still owned their own education. After independence, education was controlled by marxists. Our grandfather generation knew Sanskrit and Urdu (read/write), our generation only knew engineering and medicine. I was quite anti hindu myself. Like putting my feet near an idol which people worshipped, to tie my shoes. I was brought up on marxist literature, because I was hungry for books, and the marxist books were distributed for free.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
Islam has clear doctrines on apostasy.

In contrast you Hindus have been happy cultivating a loosely goosey anything goes image for a long time and lecturing is on open mindedness and not forcing religion on others.

So I don't think we can make a comparison with Hindu beef eaters and apostates in Islam.
Click to expand...

Who cultivated this image? Which Dharma Guru?
 
big_gamer007 said:
there are 1.5 bl Indians, I am not here to defend actions/words of anyone else other than my own.

Do you see me bringing in terrorists in arguments with you just because you might have a common religion? Or grooming Gangs from Britain just because you might have a common country of origin?

Is that the kind of debates that you want to resort to?

Let’s discuss the topic in hand without bringing random quotes from random people who have 0 connection to this topic.
Click to expand...
If you are not here to defend someone else then why do you jump in the debate to rescue others or comment at their behalf.

Coming back on thread topic you yourself are a epitome of anti Muslim bias as you criticize them for being rigid and unwilling for introspection without any proof while you beg other to amend their posts even when they are stating facts backed by stats.

Also you consider Hinduism to be flexible but at the same time don't condemn those guys who equate eating of cow meat to some cardinal crime. Also before lecturing others to read different books read Quran first because if you would have ever, you wouldn't have come with such misleading, ignorant posts about Muslims and Islam
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
What would be the incentive? Hindus are ranked according to their caste or dharma, where would a Muslim convert rank on that hierarchy?
Click to expand...
For the nth time. You have asked the same question many time before. You do not have to accept caste system to become a Hindu.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
Islam has clear doctrines on apostasy.

In contrast you Hindus have been happy cultivating a loosely goosey anything goes image for a long time and lecturing is on open mindedness and not forcing religion on others.

So I don't think we can make a comparison with Hindu beef eaters and apostates in Islam.
Click to expand...
What will happen to apostates? Just wanted to hear it from a Muslim.
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
What would be the incentive? Hindus are ranked according to their caste or dharma, where would a Muslim convert rank on that hierarchy?
Click to expand...
Will increase your spiritual portfolio. More colors, more festivals, less judgement, more deities to choose from. Islam is bit bland because it was born in the desert. You can have the best of both worlds. The discipline of Islam and the freedom of Hinduism.
 
Because they are probably at loggerheads with Muslims as Muslim League proceeded Hindu Mahasabha.

Credit to Hindutva supporters though, unlike Muslim League that easily got Pakistan and wins in Kerala thanks to British and Congress, Hindutva went from being banned to actually moving up at grass root levels, it’s not surprising that so many of the Hindutva leaders are doctors and professors remember what makes them strong and are patient enough to bring about change and power.

There is a reason Muslim League’s countries (BD and Pak) are bankrupt, and Hindutva leaders like N Rao, Vajpayee, Modi have stabilised the ship because patience helped.

@big_gamer007 Am i completely right wing now :viru justifying their anti-abrahamic stance.
 
Champ_Pal said:
For the nth time. You have asked the same question many time before. You do not have to accept caste system to become a Hindu.
Click to expand...

You don't even believe in the scriptures of legendary Hindu scholars like Manusmirti, why would any self respecting hindu convert take advice from you?
 
I would like to also point out core RSS are more anti- Christian missionaries than anti-Muslims, at least thats what I have seen from their schools where Muslims can study but i doubt christian will get admission into but they don’t advertise that anti-bias as much due to backlash.
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
You don't even believe in the scriptures of legendary Hindu scholars like Manusmirti, why would any self respecting hindu convert take advice from you?
Click to expand...
Come back to your roots. You don't have to be a practicing Hindu. Be a casual hindu. Heck, be a anti hindu hindu like some others here and taunt hindus with beef, but just convert.

Your roots are in Jalandhar, which was named after a demon king. Be a demon asura (they are also respected) but become a hindu, please.
 
JaDed said:
I would like to also point out core RSS are more anti- Christian missionaries than anti-Muslims, at least thats what I have seen from their schools where Muslims can study but i doubt christian will get admission into but they don’t advertise that anti-bias as much due to backlash.
Click to expand...
RSS at the fundamental level are against anyone who is affecting the demography. Demography is destiny, a proven but forgotten truth. Many people have not learnt it from history. Even those anti hindu hindus who can mock other hindus with beef, can only do it because of this demography. The moment it is about to change, it will not make any difference whether you are a kattar hindu or an anti hindu hindu.
 
JaDed said:
I would like to also point out core RSS are more anti- Christian missionaries than anti-Muslims, at least thats what I have seen from their schools where Muslims can study but i doubt christian will get admission into but they don’t advertise that anti-bias as much due to backlash.
Click to expand...

which RSS run schools are you talking about ?
 
Champ_Pal said:
What will happen to apostates? Just wanted to hear it from a Muslim.
Click to expand...
They are excommunicated.

There is no concept of giving legitimacy to blasphemous beliefs to coexist alongside Orthodox beliefs.

In contrast you guys have lectured us on PP about Hinduism lack of rules, flexibility, open mindedness etc etc.

Yet when Hindu fellows say they enjoy eating beef mods are called and there is talk of train tickets being purchased to beat the person up.

Hardly inclusive.
 
DeadlyVenom said:
They are excommunicated.

There is no concept of giving legitimacy to blasphemous beliefs to coexist alongside Orthodox beliefs.

In contrast you guys have lectured us on PP about Hinduism lack of rules, flexibility, open mindedness etc etc.

Yet when Hindu fellows say they enjoy eating beef mods are called and there is talk of train tickets being purchased to beat the person up.

Hardly inclusive.
Click to expand...
Come on, you are being disingenuous on purpose. The poster was inviting me to have beef. You also know what he was trying to do. I did not bother, but other posters saw that he was trying to attack my faith.
 
CricketCartoons said:
Will increase your spiritual portfolio. More colors, more festivals, less judgement, more deities to choose from. Islam is bit bland because it was born in the desert. You can have the best of both worlds. The discipline of Islam and the freedom of Hinduism.
Click to expand...

This is more intriguing, I can see genuine hindu depth to this calling. But consider my British disposition where the garish colours and noise of Bollywood trash has me running for cover. Could I really stomach a hundred festivals and dance parties a year? :unsure:

Same goes for the advice from @Varun with regard to alcohol. Where is the pleasure in something that is on tap all day every day in front and behind? There is a reason we crave the forbidden fruit remember? :genius
 
cricketjoshila said:
Finally the truth is out.

Killing cows and insulting another religion is expression of faith for Muslims.
Click to expand...
Oh the hypocrite at his best.

If a Muslim expressed his religion, they want proof and evidence because you are supposedly making a claim that affect them.

But when Hindu makes a claim about protecting cows, they are saying it does not affect Muslims? If a Muslim kills a cow, they kill their Muslims and claim “it does not affect a Muslim?”

To top it all these religious whackjobs claim India is a secular country and an animal can be protected in a secular country, but conveniently decide to not say the cow is protected due to their perceived religious beliefs which may or may not even have any grounding in religion.

By all accounts cow has been can’t consumed in the past by Hindus.

The Hindutva is a stupid term to even give these peoples. They are not promoting any faith or religion, it’s purely an anti Muslim philosophy based on their policies and actions.

I challenge you to prove me wrong
 
uppercut said:
Cows are extremely sacred to most Hindus.

Do you understand and recognize that ? A simple YES/NO answer please without resorting to rhetorical questions.
Click to expand...
Can you prove it?

Just like you guys ask us to prove everything that supposedly impacts you guys, can you prove without reasonable doubt that cows are not supposed to be slaughtered in Hinduism?
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
This is more intriguing, I can see genuine hindu depth to this calling. But consider my British disposition where the garish colours and noise of Bollywood trash has me running for cover. Could I really stomach a hundred festivals and dance parties a year? :unsure:

Same goes for the advice from @Varun with regard to alcohol. Where is the pleasure in something that is on tap all day every day in front and behind? There is a reason we crave the forbidden fruit remember? :genius
Click to expand...
At least try, no credit card required. Cancel it when you don't want to continue. No punishment for apostasy.

At least be a hindu for a day.
 
Stewie said:
Oh the hypocrite at his best.

If a Muslim expressed his religion, they want proof and evidence because you are supposedly making a claim that affect them.

But when Hindu makes a claim about protecting cows, they are saying it does not affect Muslims? If a Muslim kills a cow, they kill their Muslims and claim “it does not affect a Muslim?”

To top it all these religious whackjobs claim India is a secular country and an animal can be protected in a secular country, but conveniently decide to not say the cow is protected due to their perceived religious beliefs which may or may not even have any grounding in religion.

By all accounts cow has been can’t consumed in the past by Hindus.

The Hindutva is a stupid term to even give these peoples. They are not promoting any faith or religion, it’s purely an anti Muslim philosophy based on their policies and actions.

I challenge you to prove me wrong
Click to expand...
You said that ban on cow slaughter is anti muslim. But it applies to all religions, including hindus. And muslims have no religious requirement for beef. Then how is ban on cow slaughter anti muslim?
 
Cpt. Rishwat said:
Same goes for the advice from @Varun with regard to alcohol. Where is the pleasure in something that is on tap all day every day in front and behind? There is a reason we crave the forbidden fruit remember? :genius
Click to expand...

Have a drink and you'll automatically stop this . Tonight, Friday night is as good a time to start. Cheers!
 
Stewie said:
Can you prove it?

Just like you guys ask us to prove everything that supposedly impacts you guys, can you prove without reasonable doubt that cows are not supposed to be slaughtered in Hinduism?
Click to expand...
Multiple verses in Vedas and Mahabharat.
 
Bumping this again:
Stewie said:
Why do you and your kind have problem with Muslims expressing their faith then? You asking for evidence but when someone brings up cows the inner navy comes out screaming and whining.🤣🤣🤣🤣

Ohh the double standards here!
Click to expand...
Show me any verse from Quraan which says that cow slaughter is a religious requirement of the muslims.
Or even a Hadith, or even a WEAK hadith.

Cow slaughter IS NOT a religious need of muslims. Preventing cow slaughter is not religious oppression of muslims.
 
uppercut said:
Except the conflict is never about the very simplistic scenario that you are describing. As it stands, despite literally centuries of bloody conflict EVEN the most well educated Muslims do not budge on how sacred cows are to Hindus, which explains all there is to know about why Muslims have very little tolerance for non-muslims especially the idolators. And then the same people will go on and paint the Hindus as intolerant !!! Madness galore!.

This thread is a LIVE example!
Click to expand...
Prove it to us that cows are scared to Hindus.

Also how is it a secular state if you impose your beliefs on others? its sacred to you, don't kill it. why should I have to live by your beliefs?
 
CricketCartoons said:
At least try, no credit card required. Cancel it when you don't want to continue. No punishment for apostasy.

At least be a hindu for a day.
Click to expand...

This is another troubling factor. Even the apostates can't stop blathering on about Islam to earn their fortunes. They are even building their social media presence around this whole concept to have any significance. It's child bride this...love jihad that....all it does is ram the religon of Islam in my face wherever I turn, and as everyone knows I have had an aversion to scruffy bearded fellows since joining these boards.
 
Stewie said:
Prove it to us that cows are scared to Hindus.

Also how is it a secular state if you impose your beliefs on others? its sacred to you, don't kill it. why should I have to live by your beliefs?
Click to expand...
This secular state also prohibits its people from drawing cartoons of islamic holy figures. Will you apply the same logic, that why should others live by your beliefs?
 
Champ_Pal said:
Says tons of Hindus who have no caste. They just identify of caste. Ever heard of Arya Samaj?

Its the Government that wants to know everyone's caste for various reasons.
Click to expand...
Actually govt also doesn't want to know everyones caste. They are happy to put every caste in general category as long as it is not SC and OBC.
 
Champ_Pal said:
You are asking tough questions.
Click to expand...
Problem is that he comes when it is my time to sleep ( I sleep early and wake up by 4:30 am). Mostly he avoids answering me. Sometimes very rarely he feels confident and replies but again stops answering.
 
Stewie said:
Can you prove it?

Just like you guys ask us to prove everything that supposedly impacts you guys, can you prove without reasonable doubt that cows are not supposed to be slaughtered in Hinduism?
Click to expand...
The hymn 8.3. 25 of the Hindu scripture Atharvaveda (~1200–1500 BCE) condemns all killings of men, cattle, and horses, and prays to god Agni to punish those who kill. Prithu chasing Prithvi, who is in the form of a cow. Prithu milked the cow to generate crops for humans.
 
Still nobody been able to produce the HINDU religious text which prohibits slaughtering of cow?? I think I won't get its answer till eternity
 
The Bald Eagle said:
Still nobody been able to produce the HINDU religious text which prohibits slaughtering of cow?? I think I won't get its answer till eternity
Click to expand...
Multiple verses in Vedas, Bhagwat Purana and Mahabharata. Plus Lord Krishna, protector of cows.

The verse which doesn't exist, is the one which says cow slaughter and its consumption is a religious fard for muslims.
 
Ok then what is Manusmriti Chapter no 5, Verse 40 which allows consumption of cow meat?
Champ_Pal said:
The hymn 8.3. 25 of the Hindu scripture Atharvaveda (~1200–1500 BCE) condemns all killings of men, cattle, and horses, and prays to god Agni to punish those who kill. Prithu chasing Prithvi, who is in the form of a cow. Prithu milked the cow to generate crops for humans.
Click to expand...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

daytrader
‘The word Hindu is Arabic. Why don’t they throw it out?’ - Prominent historian Irfan Habib
Replies
50
Views
2K
guard
G
SpiritOf1903
Bollywood is obsessed with Pakistan. We’d be flattered if it weren’t so nasty Fatima Bhutto
2
Replies
81
Views
5K
Bhaijaan
Bhaijaan
MenInG
Why Indian Hindutva supporters back Israel on Gaza bombing
13 14 15
Replies
1K
Views
22K
FearlessRoar
FearlessRoar
MenInG
Is it ok for religious figures to indulge in commercial activities to earn money?
Replies
0
Views
688
MenInG
MenInG
M
What knowledge does one need to properly discuss the concepts of God, revelation and creation?
Replies
48
Views
3K
ManFan
ManFan
Back
Top