What do you think minority’s should do in such situations? Whatever we say will be misconstrued by BJP. Only the non BJP Hindu’s and their voices are effective against this divisive politics of BJP.
What do you think minority’s should do in such situations? Whatever we say will be misconstrued by BJP. Only the non BJP Hindu’s and their voices are effective against this divisive politics of BJP.
Ok here it goes:
1. A Muslim's view will not be taken seriously as compared to a fellow Hindu saying it.
Why so?
2 reasons.
Reason 1 - Humans by nature create segregations and define outsiders in EVERY single environment. Among Indians, Hindus will consider Muslims as outsiders.... among Hindus, Brahmins will consider non Brahmins as outsiders....among Brahmins, one sub-cate will consider other as outsider...then there are sub-sub caste divisions too. This is a natural division. Since BJP has created a Hindu vs Muslim situation, that itself reduces the validity of a Muslim's view in the eyes of an average Hindu who make up 80% of the population.
Reason 2 - Validate what they see and feel. An average Muslim is more religious than an average Hindus...plus an average Muslim doesn't speak out against his religion as often as an average Hindu. This again is intelligently used by BJP to project that Muslims are united...Hindus aren't...and they bring in an EVEN more powerful weapon...our TRUE enemies are not just Muslims who are united but also the so called "secular" Hindus who support these Muslims for everything.
So in this way, not only are Muslims' views automatically deemed biased....but it also weakens the case of those Hindus speaking out.
So with one arrow, they kill 2 birds.
Here’s the way out imho:
2. Simply do not fall trap into being the characters that they present you as.
A quick backstory first:
A couple of days back, one of my friends (USA Tam Brahm - non religious dude) posted on his FB wall lambasting Rajnikanth for his comments on CAA-NRC. Another guy (Tam Brahm) started posting in support of it and soon a comment war ensued. This other guy (instead of debating the points) quickly started openly abusing Muslims in a weird long rant. My friend deleted his hate posts and moved on.
Later that day, me and my friend had a chat and I asked him why he used words like “fascist” “bigot” so much in his replies (which were otherwise pretty logical).
My friend what’s the big deal...even New York times described it that way. I asked him “isn’t that why guys like Trump get elected” and he saw the point.
There are 2 lessons here for all of us (Hindus and Muslims) opposing the moves by BJP:
Lesson 1 - We can’t persuade the evangelicals. These are people who hold an extreme view (could be for any reason - sometimes due to hate). They are NOT likely to budge at all. Forums are filled with such people on both sides. NOBODY is changing anybody’s views here. It’s all about point scoring. But in the outside world, there are MILLIONS of people who are not on either side. Our appeal must be directed at them.
Lesson 2 - When you use words like bigot, racist, fascist, communal, anti national….you are labelling people and FORCING them to conform to your views before they have even made up their mind. If that comes BEFORE a bond is formed, it creates a resistance which makes them non receptive to what you have to say...and in many cases, hate you for trying to make them feel so bad. When the bond is formed, the us vs them works beautifully like in the case of BJP - support us if you LOVE our nation --- don’t let anti nationals and anti hindus win.
Which brings us to the point...what do minorities (and other Hindus) need to do?
a. Avoid being the characters that you are presented as.
The presentation is that anti CAA-NRC supporters are biased (protecting their religious mates), anti- Hindu, anti-BJP, etc. Foaming in the mouth types.When someone rants and raves and uses terms like bigot, fascist, anti Muslim, this and that in every damn sentence, you are playing into the hands of BJP.The moment you stop being the character that people PERCEIVE you as, it acts as a pattern interrupt and NOW people are more open to listening to your views.
b. Identify the subtle differences in the debate and acknowledge the good parts of it.
This makes you seem reasonable. CAA is a good move in the end (prosecuted Hindus get saved by it) but it’s the CAA-NRC combo that is the problem. The focus should ALWAYS be on CAA-NRC and not CAA. Debating technicalities of CAA is ok but the move itself can’t be opposed as its a needed thing (just that people don’t trust BJP intentions lol).
c. Talk about this issue from a concerned citizen...as opposed to a concerned Muslim.
Talk about the affected parties (poor Muslims) rather than Muslims overall. For minorities, it’s better they stay clear of making this a direct Hindu vs Muslim debate cos the existing perception won’t help them. Also its easy for things to take a dark turn. Instead focusing on the necessity and executional ability of an all India exercise makes more sense imho.
Doing all this won’t sway anyone who is fully on the opposite spectrum but it will make SOOO many others reflect on it.
Case in point…one of the BIGGEST reasons these protests gained so much traction and there are soo many social media comments against the govt is because NO party was directly involved in this (indirectly sure). It was a protest by students which made it HARD for BJP to twist it around. And now, people who never even uttered anything against BJP have started talking about it. Not saying people have been completely swayed but there is a marked shift in public perception.
The same way….some things in the protests got out of hand which gave BJP enough ammunition to fight back and make use of it in the elections. So it goes both ways and that’s why the messaging and management of these protests have to be done very very carefully.
Imagine for one sec..if Congress (of today) was at the forefront of this from Day 1. Things would be so different. BJP would have had SOO much fun destroying them.
---
As much as things are bad now…..the game can change.
BJP might be the OBVIOUS winner in 2024 elections but a lot can happen between now and then.
The usual stuff needs to be there (marketable leader, proper campaign strategy, etc) but it will all come down to positioning….and BJP has given the opposition enough to work with.
The question is whether we can use the opportunities.
Maybe in another post later on, I will detail it out.
This post has gotten wayyy too long already haha.