topspin
Test Debutant
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2018
- Runs
- 14,348
- Post of the Week
- 1
Martinelli is a good talent but I feel he gets overrated a lot. He doesn’t have high footballing IQ & lacks composure. Unfortunately, it is rare to improve these aspects with experience because you either have it or you don’t.
Martinelli would never develop into a number 9 & although his explosive pace & energy on the wings makes him a difficult prospect to defend against, you cannot really start with him & have Trossard warm the bench.
The only thing Martinelli has over him is pace & it is not everything, especially when Trossard is miles ahead of him when it comes to passing, dribbling, first touch, decision-making etc.
Martinelli is a poor man’s Rashford. He will always go hot & cold. He is one of those players that I would be happy to see Arteta make a profit on & replace with a superior player in a year or so if he does not take his game to the next level which I feel he will not.
I think that's very harsh on Martinelli. I don't think there is actually much in it between these two.
Rashford has been better recently. As an England fan, I'm glad he's finally living up to his potential because he's been let down by poor coaches at Utd in OGS and RR.
Martinelli however has been superior over the last 2 years. Rashford has rejuvenated under ETH and has now his his peak. The Brazilian is just 21 years old and is 4 years younger than Rashford. They are at different stages of their careers but the difference between them is debatable. I'd argue Martinelli has a higher ceiling.
There aren't many players better than the duo in the left wing forward position. Mbappe and Vinicius Jnr are the only ones that come to mind.
Last edited: