What's new

Australia (131/3) defeat India (136/9) by 7 wickets via the DLS method in the first ODI to go 1-0 up in the 3-match series

Which side will win the first ODI?


  • Total voters
    9
  • Poll closed .

The Bald Eagle

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 25, 2023
Runs
22,113
Can India end years of frustration on Aussie soil when the two titans clash in Perth for the 1st ODI of the 2025 series? Australia have ruled their home in recent times - the last time India won an ODI series in Australia was in 2018-19 when they took that three-match rubber 2-1. Since then, the Aussies have generally held sway in home conditions. Now, India come in with the air of change - Shubman Gill starts his stint as ODI captain, and the return of stalwarts Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli adds much-needed experience to India’s top order. Their recent performances, especially in the Champions Trophy, have shown they can bring consistency under pressure, and their pace attack - Mohammed Siraj, Arshdeep Singh, and Prasidh Krishna looks ready to rip into Australia’s batters early in the innings. On the other hand, the hosts will feel the pinch with Pat Cummins still recovering from a back injury, while Cameron Green has been ruled out of the series and key names like Alex Carey, Josh Inglis, and Adam Zampa are unavailable for the opener, leaving some gaps to fill. Marnus Labuschagne, drafted in as Green’s replacement after a prolific domestic run, will look to anchor the innings, while the onus will be on Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh, and Matthew Short to lead from the front with their attacking approach.

Despite the absentees, Australia still possess a threatening pace attack with Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood spearheading the new ball assault and Nathan Ellis adding deceptive variations at the death. With both first-choice keepers sidelined, Josh Philippe has a golden opportunity to prove his credentials behind the stumps and with the bat. Perth’s fast, bouncy wicket demands respect. Whoever survives the new ball and navigates early movement will likely dominate. With history, momentum, and pride on the line, expect high intensity, early fireworks, and plenty of drama in this opener - a match that could set the series on fire.

Squads
India: Rohit Sharma, Shubman Gill(c), Virat Kohli, Shreyas Iyer, Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul(w), Axar Patel, Kuldeep Yadav, Harshit Rana, Arshdeep Singh, Mohammed Siraj, Washington Sundar, Nitish Kumar Reddy, Dhruv Jurel, Prasidh Krishna

Australia: Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh(c), Marnus Labuschagne, Matthew Short, Matt Renshaw, Mitchell Owen, Josh Philippe(w), Cooper Connolly, Mitchell Starc, Xavier Bartlett, Josh Hazlewood, Ben Dwarshuis, Nathan Ellis, Matthew Kuhnemann

=======

All posters, please take note of the following guidelines for match threads on PakPassion:

1. No personal insults at other posters, players, officials, coaching staff, etc.

2. No making fun of players', officials', or coaching staff's names.

3. Do not add any references to media, their social media, or post any pictures or screenshots from other sports websites.

4. Stick to commenting on this match. There is no need to bring other countries into the match discussion, as there are plenty of other threads where those discussions can be added.
 
Rohit and Kohli played their last test in Australia. Hope they play their last ODI in Australia and call it quits. India's bench strength is too strong to still keep these 2 guys. ALso India has opportunity to groom next gen pacers. Siraj is there purely for experience. Oflate he doesn't play ODIs. So a total rookie bowling unit. Two washed up oldies. KL Rahul should also be replaced on Pant is back. Jadeja and Shami may never play another one dayer again.
 
Rohit and Kohli played their last test in Australia. Hope they play their last ODI in Australia and call it quits.
It seems already there were disturbances between Gill and Rohit. Rohit seems to be struggling outside off in nets as per videos and reports. I think Rohit will get booted out with in 4 or 5 odis at max.I will prefer jurel in place of kl.jurel is clutch player. Pant wasn't preferred over kl in ct. Gambhir views Pant as test specialist only.
 
Australia missing any players?
Bunch of them for Aus.

With Sharma and Kohli playing, Jaiswal sitting in the bench, Bumrah nowhere near Australian shores, Ind. also fielding their B team.

Fail to see the purpose of this whole tour. Of course other than CA filling it's coffers with Ind. $$$.
 
Bunch of them for Aus.

With Sharma and Kohli playing, Jaiswal sitting in the bench, Bumrah nowhere near Australian shores, Ind. also fielding their B team.

Fail to see the purpose of this whole tour. Of course other than CA filling it's coffers with Ind. $$$.
These tours are valuable if fyou play your bench players. Having said that star players are needed for money
 
Bunch of them for Aus.

With Sharma and Kohli playing, Jaiswal sitting in the bench, Bumrah nowhere near Australian shores, Ind. also fielding their B team.

Fail to see the purpose of this whole tour. Of course other than CA filling it's coffers with Ind. $$$.
How is it B team? India won the CT with this team
 
These tours are valuable if fyou play your bench players. Having said that star players are needed for money
Playing bench is good. But past it, not so much.

Ind. is playing players who should not be in the team. Sharma, Kohli, Rahul should not be in the team. Let alone in the playing eleven.

Siraj too. Not saying he is not good enough. But he is a test bowler and should be kept that way. Rest him up. Ind. play a lot of tests and he needs to be looked after.
 
How is it B team? India won the CT with this team
But this is not UAE. India had 3 spinners. In Australia you don't need spinners. INdia's fast bowling unit is very inexperienced. ALso India's most important component is Hardik Pandya. HE is missing too. Prasidh, Arshdeep, Rana are inexperienced in this format. Even Siraj was sidelined from ODI set up. Now he is back since Bumrah is not playing also Shami is probably dropped forever.
 
Aus cares about ODIs only right before World Cup. I remember in 2019 they were like #6 teams for major part before tournament began. They went to Semi in 2019. Had they beaten Eng, they would've easily beaten NZ as well.
 
But this is not UAE. India had 3 spinners. In Australia you don't need spinners. INdia's fast bowling unit is very inexperienced. ALso India's most important component is Hardik Pandya. HE is missing too. Prasidh, Arshdeep, Rana are inexperienced in this format. Even Siraj was sidelined from ODI set up. Now he is back since Bumrah is not playing also Shami is probably dropped forever.
Pandya is the only player that's missing. It's a full-strength Indian team.
 
Pandya is the only player that's missing. It's a full-strength Indian team.
Shami was there. Jadeja was there. Sundar hasn't exactly played enough ODIs. It is a different matter INdia can send a completely different unit outside this squad and compete. But i won't say they are not missing anyone. Right now INdia has no death bowling. no new ball bowling. You can literally target any pacer in this line up.
 
Having undercooked Kohli and Rohit itself is a big minus.
I don't understand this team. Couple of has been (Sharma, Kohli), one on the cusp of has been (Rahul). Pacers that have only a couple of ODI's between them.

I only see liabilities for the most part.

With Aus. also missing some key people, will the people really tune in? I mean outside the nostalgia of Sharma, Kohli return.
 
Looks like the game will be not be completed due to weather

Not a smart move to have a cricket series in Australia in the mid of October
 
Biggest mistake India is making is not having any young paceman in the squad. For this tour becoz of Aus bouncy wickets, i can understand india see prasidh as some kind of ishant type guy who pounds into the pitch and generally keeps things tight but sitll he is not Ishant by any count, Siraj gets bashed in odi's nowadays unless he gets reverse, Arshdeep is a 120kmph trundler - his best format is t20's in ODI's he will get owned unless there is swing on offer, no swing and ODI format -he's toast.
why did't we - looking at the future bring at least 2 young quicks out? wasted series - imho seeing the same old same old halwa indian pace bowling attack
 
Biggest mistake India is making is not having any young paceman in the squad. For this tour becoz of Aus bouncy wickets, i can understand india see prasidh as some kind of ishant type guy who pounds into the pitch and generally keeps things tight but sitll he is not Ishant by any count, Siraj gets bashed in odi's nowadays unless he gets reverse, Arshdeep is a 120kmph trundler - his best format is t20's in ODI's he will get owned unless there is swing on offer, no swing and ODI format -he's toast.
why did't we - looking at the future bring at least 2 young quicks out? wasted series - imho seeing the same old same old halwa indian pace bowling attack
Arshdeep is a T20 bowler. Prasidh and Siraj are more test bowlers. Rana is not really good at anything. Weakest bowling unit for ODIs.
 
Australia have won the toss and have opted to field

Teams:

India (Playing XI): Rohit Sharma, Shubman Gill(c), Virat Kohli, Shreyas Iyer, KL Rahul(w), Axar Patel, Washington Sundar, Nitish Kumar Reddy, Harshit Rana, Mohammed Siraj, Arshdeep Singh

Australia (Playing XI): Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh(c), Matthew Short, Josh Philippe(w), Matt Renshaw, Cooper Connolly, Mitchell Owen, Mitchell Starc, Nathan Ellis, Matthew Kuhnemann, Josh Hazlewood
 
Arshdeep is a T20 bowler. Prasidh and Siraj are more test bowlers. Rana is not really good at anything. Weakest bowling unit for ODIs.
in other words - since we are now battign first - unless we get 400 + we are toast on ice with this pop gun halwa pace attack
 
Can India end years of frustration on Aussie soil when the two titans clash in Perth for the 1st ODI of the 2025 series? Australia have ruled their home in recent times - the last time India won an ODI series in Australia was in 2018-19 when they took that three-match rubber 2-1. Since then, the Aussies have generally held sway in home conditions. Now, India come in with the air of change - Shubman Gill starts his stint as ODI captain, and the return of stalwarts Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli adds much-needed experience to India’s top order. Their recent performances, especially in the Champions Trophy, have shown they can bring consistency under pressure, and their pace attack - Mohammed Siraj, Arshdeep Singh, and Prasidh Krishna looks ready to rip into Australia’s batters early in the innings. On the other hand, the hosts will feel the pinch with Pat Cummins still recovering from a back injury, while Cameron Green has been ruled out of the series and key names like Alex Carey, Josh Inglis, and Adam Zampa are unavailable for the opener, leaving some gaps to fill. Marnus Labuschagne, drafted in as Green’s replacement after a prolific domestic run, will look to anchor the innings, while the onus will be on Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh, and Matthew Short to lead from the front with their attacking approach.

Despite the absentees, Australia still possess a threatening pace attack with Mitchell Starc and Josh Hazlewood spearheading the new ball assault and Nathan Ellis adding deceptive variations at the death. With both first-choice keepers sidelined, Josh Philippe has a golden opportunity to prove his credentials behind the stumps and with the bat. Perth’s fast, bouncy wicket demands respect. Whoever survives the new ball and navigates early movement will likely dominate. With history, momentum, and pride on the line, expect high intensity, early fireworks, and plenty of drama in this opener - a match that could set the series on fire.

Squads
India: Rohit Sharma, Shubman Gill(c), Virat Kohli, Shreyas Iyer, Yashasvi Jaiswal, KL Rahul(w), Axar Patel, Kuldeep Yadav, Harshit Rana, Arshdeep Singh, Mohammed Siraj, Washington Sundar, Nitish Kumar Reddy, Dhruv Jurel, Prasidh Krishna

Australia: Travis Head, Mitchell Marsh(c), Marnus Labuschagne, Matthew Short, Matt Renshaw, Mitchell Owen, Josh Philippe(w), Cooper Connolly, Mitchell Starc, Xavier Bartlett, Josh Hazlewood, Ben Dwarshuis, Nathan Ellis, Matthew Kuhnemann

=======

All posters, please take note of the following guidelines for match threads on PakPassion:

1. No personal insults at other posters, players, officials, coaching staff, etc.

2. No making fun of players', officials', or coaching staff's names.

3. Do not add any references to media, their social media, or post any pictures or screenshots from other sports websites.

4. Stick to commenting on this match. There is no need to bring other countries into the match discussion, as there are plenty of other threads where those discussions can be added.
'Years of Frustration' - nice one :)... :dhoni
 
Biggest mistake India is making is not having any young paceman in the squad. For this tour becoz of Aus bouncy wickets, i can understand india see prasidh as some kind of ishant type guy who pounds into the pitch and generally keeps things tight but sitll he is not Ishant by any count, Siraj gets bashed in odi's nowadays unless he gets reverse, Arshdeep is a 120kmph trundler - his best format is t20's in ODI's he will get owned unless there is swing on offer, no swing and ODI format -he's toast.
why did't we - looking at the future bring at least 2 young quicks out? wasted series - imho seeing the same old same old halwa indian pace bowling attack
If Arshdeep is not good in OD , then he should be poorer in 20 20.
 
Rohit silencing critics like me :dw

He still has 1 or 2 yrs of good cricket left. But do not want him playing next WC. India needs to invest in future.
 
At Optus big runs can be scored at the back end if wickets in hand . Problem is teams lose plenty of wickets at the top . That’s why so far the scores are low for the 3ODI’s in this venue. If India can keep wickets in hand on this can score big .

:kp
 
He is an ODI great for sure. He should retire before ruining his career average.

Indian batsmen do not know when to retire.
I don't think he will last that long. This series will more or less decide is future. Last time he was out of depth in test series both in India and Australia.
 
Rohit will find real tough to go on ultra aggressive or hackish mode.he has to grind out now with his non-existent footwork.gone
 
Back
Top