Not taking anything away from misbah. I rate him. He was great for Pakistan in general. For test cricket.
But Pakistan were number 1 for like 2 weeks max.
Misbah had chuckers + an All time great and the same players who were flopping in odi somehow miraculously did wonders in UAE test like ahmed shehzad, Azhar Ali and Asad shafiq.
He isn't as great as people think he is.
He's an okay batter for Test who has played a few gems and was always a terrific onfield captain in every format.
But the guy is genuinely clueless on how to build a team. His personal decisions related to Dropping UA and Afridi for ct 2013 were a huge slap in the face when a couple of months later afridi would diamanté WI with career best figures while in ct 2013 pakistan lost to WI and before CT barely scrapped by Scotland and Ireland.
Same slap in the face for him stubbornly stating jamshed > Sarfi in wc 2015, and that sarfi your best run getter against australia in odi is not good enough and jamshed and shafiq are better? He didn't even take shafiq at the end lol.
Similarly his coaching stint is riddled with moronic decisions such as Shehzad and UA fir t20, Rizwan as opener, chacha as premium finisher, Going back to Azhar Ali for Test captaincy etc etc.
Ontop of which a crapola record in test putside UAE.
Luck + Salman butt evil nostalgia factor to test rank no 1 has overrated this beyond belief.
He's an okay test bat, Terrific onfield captain in all formats and a crapola team manager who got lucky that the crapola players in odi happened to miraculously work averaging 40+ in test.