What's new

Does Jasprit Bumrah have a legal action?

If Bumrah is not getting tested because of BCCI mafia, why do you expect the tests to come positive. He'll come out clean because of the same mafia.

Just suffer already. Lol
 
QOTW winner here 👏

They need to get him in the labs at lboro asap, I will personally facilitate the test, me old uni :yk3

Look what Murali had to go through to convince the world of his hyper-extension, the scrutiny was next level especially in Australia; I wonder why the Aussies are a lot quieter this time round from the media & players….
 
That comparion from fox with cummins action was pretty damning. His elbow bends and straightens quite a lot. That angle looks over 15 degrees.
 
This does seem like the chicken and egg problem though.

If Bumrah is indeed throwing and is not being called because of BCCI controlling ICC then why would you ask him to be tested?

IF he is negative, its BCCI is controlling ICC to get that result.

Why the test then?

Lets just assume he is throwing javelins like Nadeem.

To be fair, he loses to Nadeem in throwing as well.
 
he is playing cricket since last 8 years or so.. he would have been reported earlier if his action wasnt clear
 
he is playing cricket since last 8 years or so.. he would have been reported earlier if his action wasnt clear

Till now, no one has actually given a constructive reason on why Ian Pont's thorough analysis on Bumrah's action is wrong and why his action is indeed illegal. Says everything we need to know. All bark no bite.
 
he is playing cricket since last 8 years or so.. he would have been reported earlier if his action wasnt clear
8 years ago, had any other bowler played with that action they would have been called immediately and sent to a lab for analysis...

Yet fast forward 8 years and we're now being told that you can distinguish between chucking and hyperextension just by looking at tv footage and listening to Pont, Bishop and Fleming....

Also, just for the record Hyperextension does not absolve a bowler from chucking. Someone with this disability (or ability) can do both and in fact labelling it as just hyperextension can actually legitimise bowlers from adding a few "chucks' into the mix and allow them to go under the radar...

It's actually common sense...
 
Lol there's nothing "constructive" about calling someone a chucker even after actual fast bowling experts explaining clearly why he's not.

Only crybabies in this whole thing are the Pakistanis who have been moaning nonstop since he owned their team twice and single handedly won us the T20 WC while they have to watch their bowlers surrender to the likes of Afghanistan and USA. The heartburn must be insane.

Only memories I have of bumrah are of him bottling the CT final and Fakhar being his daddy.

His action to the naked eye does look suspect, plenty of cricket fans have said it.

You think Pakistanis are really bothered about a couple of T20 games 🤣, you seem to continually bring it up.

Fans only remember the big games, finals etc. Not group games or knockout games

Plenty of fans brought up the suspect action when he 1st started playing

But you cry babies, want to make out as though it's only been a recent thing

Please carry on being a snowflake, just like all the other 🤡 from across the border you seem to think on a Pakistani Cricket forum we are going worship your players, when you and so many others behave in such a childish manner?

Never mind testing bumrahs bowling, PP should age test all Indian fans on here as most of you act like 4 or 5 year olds
 
8 years ago, had any other bowler played with that action they would have been called immediately and sent to a lab for analysis...

Yet fast forward 8 years and we're now being told that you can distinguish between chucking and hyperextension just by looking at tv footage and listening to Pont, Bishop and Fleming....

Also, just for the record Hyperextension does not absolve a bowler from chucking. Someone with this disability (or ability) can do both and in fact labelling it as just hyperextension can actually legitimise bowlers from adding a few "chucks' into the mix and allow them to go under the radar...

It's actually common sense...
Brilliant explanation, be prepared to be called a jealous Pakistani or indophobic by the toddlers on this forum
 
The likes of Umesh Yadav, Shami, Isanti Sharma were fine fast bowlers without a dodgy action.

Teams like Australia will continue to churn out players like Starc, Cummins, Hazelwood. Pakistan will always be able generate decent fast bowlers at the very least. Pakistani diet in general is better than Bangladeshi and Indians.

Question is, can India continue to generate Bumrah level of bowlers? One thing is certain, Indian management loves their Avesh, Mukesh, Harshal(no disrespect to them) over likes of Umran, Maynak, etc.
 
Only memories I have of bumrah are of him bottling the CT final and Fakhar being his daddy.

His action to the naked eye does look suspect, plenty of cricket fans have said it.

You think Pakistanis are really bothered about a couple of T20 games 🤣, you seem to continually bring it up.

Fans only remember the big games, finals etc. Not group games or knockout games

Plenty of fans brought up the suspect action when he 1st started playing

But you cry babies, want to make out as though it's only been a recent thing

Please carry on being a snowflake, just like all the other 🤡 from across the border you seem to think on a Pakistani Cricket forum we are going worship your players, when you and so many others behave in such a childish manner?

Never mind testing bumrahs bowling, PP should age test all Indian fans on here as most of you act like 4 or 5 year olds


Lol here comes all the toys out of the pram. Just as i expected. :yk


"pLeNtY oF cRicKet fAnS hAvE sAiD iT" LMAO. Pakistani fans do not count for all the non Indian cricket fans in the world. They're pretty much the only ones who have been crying non stop about Bumrah's action ever since he became their daddy at the last two world cup games. Cherry on top...he won India a world cup single handedly while entire pakistan has just one WC in the whole 21st century.. :ROFLMAO:

Can completely understand the pain. Please continue with the rona dhona..
 
Lol here comes all the toys out of the pram. Just as i expected. :yk


"pLeNtY oF cRicKet fAnS hAvE sAiD iT" LMAO. Pakistani fans do not count for all the non Indian cricket fans in the world. They're pretty much the only ones who have been crying non stop about Bumrah's action ever since he became their daddy at the last two world cup games. Cherry on top...he won India a world cup single handedly while entire pakistan has just one WC in the whole 21st century.. :ROFLMAO:

Can completely understand the pain. Please continue with the rona dhona..

Only toys out of pram were the ones 90,000 Indians were throwing after bumrah and india bottled a world cup final at home. I heard you went out and smashed tvs and burnt effergies of your cricket gods. Imagine bottling a world cup final in front of your own fans with so called best thrower in world cricket
 
For the uninitiated, if you want to understand the whole reason behind the Pakistani bitter meltdown over Bumrah, id suggest you to go check the "Burman vs Hasan Ali" thread here on this site.

Most were calling him a one year wonder and that he was inferior bowler to Hasan Ali in all aspects and that he was just an injury away from becoming Ashok dinda. Now that he's at the top of world after 8 years, they have no other option than to resort to coping mechanisms and seethe. :ROFLMAO:
 
Only toys out of pram were the ones 90,000 Indians were throwing after bumrah and india bottled a world cup final at home. I heard you went out and smashed tvs and burnt effergies of your cricket gods. Imagine bottling a world cup final in front of your own fans with so called best thrower in world cricket

Wow so your best comeback is "you guys lost a world cup final".

Really sick burn man.. :yk

We won the very next big tournament while you had to see your mediocrities getting kicked out by H1B Indians. Seethe! :ROFLMAO:
 
He is as legal as Akhtar.

Hyper extension.
Akhtar was tested and cleared.Bumrah should be tested too.Akhtar’s arms are very long and flexible.Bumrah gets his pace from his elbow which has hyper extension of 35 degrees.They at point of delivery his extension is within 15 degrees so it is legal but he may be bowling many illegal balls.It is best to test him.
 
no1. chucker in world .. cheater.. if he was pakistan player... he would have been banned by baby pcb itself .. take his stats lightly
 
His action looks suspicious to the naked eye and we all know that if ICC weren’t BCCI’s pet, Bumrah would have been reported years ago.

One thing is for sure though is that Bumrah has the ugliest action of all time. How anyone can be a fan of that guy is beyond me.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Because they don't even know about the Rules .

When 99% expert's said Bumrah action is clean but no bumrah need to be tested because they think so.

:kp

Not even pakistani Cricketers have raised questions on Bumrahs action.
 
They don't even read the rules.

View attachment 148973

Hyper extension isn't counted as chucking.

Watch people ignore this post conveniently and continue on their with their wailing ceremony. :ROFLMAO:

Ofcourse it'd be comical to expect genuity from these lot when we consider the fact that these lame arguments come from a place of bitterness and insecurity instead of reason.
 
Its going to be tasty come the English Summer when this chucker Tours England. I'll definitely be there at Old Trafford and at the Oval with Full on pleasantries directed at Bumrahs Greatness when his arm turns over!
 
Fox sports are coming up with new technology every hour to help umpires to call him for chucking.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0032.jpeg
    IMG_0032.jpeg
    4.1 MB · Views: 14
Fox sports are coming up with new technology every hour to help umpires to call him for chucking.
I am watching it live...no where they have alluded of chucking. They are showing this side on action for all the bowlers.

Looks like Pakistani fans like yourself are not able to digest the success of Bumrah. Focus on the reverse swing that Klassen accused on your team.
 
Isha Guha taking veiled digs at his action. Fox bringing in a new tech everyday to expose the straightening. Hilarious.
 
Isha Guha taking veiled digs at his action. Fox bringing in a new tech everyday to expose the straightening. Hilarious.
So you are lying in the match thread and here as well.

She never took any dig...I am watching it live. She just said that hyperextension is the reason why he is so effective.

Stop lying. Lets be honest, you lot are jealous just bcoz he overshadowned all those overhyped ball tampering phhaaast bowlers from Pakistan.
 
So you are lying in the match thread and here as well.

She never took any dig...I am watching it live. She just said that hyperextension is the reason why he is so effective.

Stop lying. Lets be honest, you lot are jealous just bcoz he overshadowned all those overhyped ball tampering phhaaast bowlers from Pakistan.
Lol she asked Kerry if he had his protractor after seeing the angle. Are you slow?
 
Lol she asked Kerry if he had his protractor after seeing the angle. Are you slow?
LOL that was because Shastri was comparing the bending of the legs between Akashdeep and Bumrah's delivery strides. Stop trying to fool someone who is watching the game live. Same Isa Guha was hyping up Bumrah as best fast bowler in the world whole series. Give it a rest as it appears to me that you are unable to digest the success of Bumrah and how he surpassed all those ex ball tampering ex great fast bowlers from Pakistan.

Btw, read this


Man I have never seen more insecure bunch than Pakistanis. I am not even fan of Bumrah but great to see he has absolutely cause panic attack among Pakistani fans.

:misbah
 
100% doesnt chuck
His action on naked eye looks like chucking but when you show it down you can see the hypertension. I don't get the fuss, if you see from the front angle and not the side angle his arm keeps straight.
 
His action on naked eye looks like chucking but when you show it down you can see the hypertension. I don't get the fuss, if you see from the front angle and not the side angle his arm keeps straight.
You are right. Naked eye might trick us that he is chucking but hyperextension has been his weapon so far. All this fuss should come to an end now.
 
Coping theories from a certain section of fans knows no limits. Its either opposition being paid, fixing, ipl contract, Bumrah action, whatever. Sky is the limit for their creativity.

Don't they feel embarrassed with these consipracy theories and victim card.
 
So let's once again sum up the current situation.

Experts claim Bumrah has hyperextension from tv analysis.
These same experts must have watched hours and hours of video footage to conclude that no delivery is chucked and that it's all down to hyper extension.

Others think he throws the occasional delivery whilst some think he throws the majority of his deliveries

He won't be called or tested properly and, without a statement clarifying the situation from the ICC, only bowlers that appear to throw, without proof that it is hyperextension or not, will be sent for tests.

In the event of any doubt as to whether it is chucking or hyperextension the umpires will be guided by the match referee who in turn are guided by Ian Pont, Ian Bishop or even Ian Beale from East Enders...
 
Because they don't even know about the Rules .

When 99% expert's said Bumrah action is clean but no bumrah need to be tested because they think so.

:kp
he was banned 2 times by 2 umpires in ranji trophy .. bcci rescued him..so 99% ppl saying illegal sction .. only 1% ppl saying legal
 
It's a sad time when PAK posters in their ignorance keep questioning an elite bowler with a perfect action like Bumrah .

But then again, it's understandable considering how impotent their own bowlers are despite being actual chuckers and tampered
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So let's once again sum up the current situation.

Experts claim Bumrah has hyperextension from tv analysis.
These same experts must have watched hours and hours of video footage to conclude that no delivery is chucked and that it's all down to hyper extension.

Others think he throws the occasional delivery whilst some think he throws the majority of his deliveries

He won't be called or tested properly and, without a statement clarifying the situation from the ICC, only bowlers that appear to throw, without proof that it is hyperextension or not, will be sent for tests.

In the event of any doubt as to whether it is chucking or hyperextension the umpires will be guided by the match referee who in turn are guided by Ian Pont, Ian Bishop or even Ian Beale from East Enders...
Dont bad mouth the respected Ian Beale please…
 
he was banned 2 times by 2 umpires in ranji trophy .. bcci rescued him..so 99% ppl saying illegal sction .. only 1% ppl saying legal
Lol he was never banned . stop spreading false information.

Keep crying :kp :dw
 
It's a sad time when PAK posters in their ignorance keep questioning an elite bowler with a perfect action like Bumrah .

But then again, it's understandable considering how impotent their own bowlers are despite being actual chuckers and tampered

I think it's high time some posters start using their brains and actually try and change the context rather then the usual "oh look, salty Pakistani fans"...

If you/they actually open their eyes and read you/they will see that this thread was opened in 2016, many years before Bumrah was hailed as some all time great Asian fast bowler soon to be the most super duper bowler that has ever graced a cricket field....
 
lol what is this Fox-this Fox-that some are quoting.

The veiled attempt is to suggest that an Aussie channel has done a study on Bumrah's action and are putting the evidence out there hahaha.
 
lol what is this Fox-this Fox-that some are quoting.

The veiled attempt is to suggest that an Aussie channel has done a study on Bumrah's action and are putting the evidence out there hahaha.

I saw one on Starc alone earlier today while his wife was on air :dhoni
This is their desperation. I have watched the entire coverage in fox and they were doing that x ray analysis on side on action even for Australian bowlers. Pakistanis think everyone is deluded like them. Funny thing is Sarfaraz Nawaz calling Shaheen Afridi a chucker, Klassen is accusing them of ball tampering, experts like Ian Pont and Ian Bishop have clearly explained Bumrah's hyperextension, heck ex Pakistani experts like Rashid Latif etc has called Bumrah's action is clean but they will still accuse Bumrah out of pure jealousy and desperation. This desperation creeps from the fact that Bumrah has outshined every single Pakistani bowler in their cricket history. This is the crux of the matter...doesn't matter how much they try to hide it. There was a thread where @Buffet exposed it with proper stats and figures. So they couldn't dispute it there and now taking the easier route of accusing him of illegal action.
 
Abbas' effort ball has looked like an absolute chuck in this match. Compared to that godlike clean bowling action of Bumrah. But since he is a typically impotent Pakistani trundler , nobody even bothers to look. That's the difference.
 
Its going to be tasty come the English Summer when this chucker Tours England. I'll definitely be there at Old Trafford and at the Oval with Full on pleasantries directed at Bumrahs Greatness when his arm turns over!
But bumrah is a nice guy lol
And Atherton and Hussain already hail him as like one of the best ever.
 
But bumrah is a nice guy lol
And Atherton and Hussain already hail him as like one of the best ever.

Whst do you expect from Hussain. Born and bred in Madras. I'm not sure Atherton would have hailed him as one of the best ever when he clearly isn't.
 
Whst do you expect from Hussain. Born and bred in Madras. I'm not sure Atherton would have hailed him as one of the best ever when he clearly isn't.
In the interview he did. So did bumble.

He is definitely top 10 all time right now. But he needs to get to around 300 wickets then yes.
 
That's what bothers the pakistanis.
i will repeat again. bumrah is the best bowler ever from asia. not even wasim is ahead. only longevity wise thats it. impact wise he has already beaten wasim black and blue.

it should irk them. and it will keep hurting them for a long time.
 
People can have their own views and there is no way a bowler can be judged on those views. Until or unless the umpire reports him, there is no way Bumrah is gonna get tested but that could end the whole debate for sure.
 
This is their desperation. I have watched the entire coverage in fox and they were doing that x ray analysis on side on action even for Australian bowlers. Pakistanis think everyone is deluded like them. Funny thing is Sarfaraz Nawaz calling Shaheen Afridi a chucker, Klassen is accusing them of ball tampering, experts like Ian Pont and Ian Bishop have clearly explained Bumrah's hyperextension, heck ex Pakistani experts like Rashid Latif etc has called Bumrah's action is clean but they will still accuse Bumrah out of pure jealousy and desperation. This desperation creeps from the fact that Bumrah has outshined every single Pakistani bowler in their cricket history. This is the crux of the matter...doesn't matter how much they try to hide it. There was a thread where @Buffet exposed it with proper stats and figures. So they couldn't dispute it there and now taking the easier route of accusing him of illegal action.
I'd put Wasim Akram a notch above him at this point. But yeah, he's blown away most of the others.
 
I wonder what bumrah have done if he would have bowled in 80-90’s bowling friendly era when there wasn’t as good bats as now they have developed and no analysis of bowlers was available in 90’s many mediocre bowlers made their carrier using bottel caps and ball tampering if bumrah had all those privilege he would have bowler equivalent of don bradman still he is in ranks of Mcgrath and malcom marshall easily top 5 bowler all time . Deal with the fact he’s far ahead to wasim and waqar that guy who all through out his career took wickets of taileners of minnow nation ,He would’ve even destroyed by today’s tailenders they arent naive with bat unlikes previous generation free walking wickets, Waqar isn’t even fit to tie shoe laces of bumrah deal with it and stop crying. He’s in league of mcgrath ,marshall,hadleee and steyn.
 
Bumrah is an exceptional bowler, undoubtedly the best among the current lot. There’s Bumrah, and then there’s the rest. However, let’s not get carried away and start placing him ahead to legends like Akram, McGrath, and Ambrose.

As for his action, it’s perfectly fine.
 
Amazing how Indian fans all of a sudden are experts about hyper extension after all the names they used to call shoaib
Hyperextension was not the issue with Shoaib. The issue was he used to chuck, at times willfully. Even Ajmal was better than Akhtar in this regard, because he was at least consistent whereas Akhtar did it when things got rough.
 
Bumrah is an exceptional bowler, undoubtedly the best among the current lot. There’s Bumrah, and then there’s the rest. However, let’s not get carried away and start placing him ahead to legends like Akram, McGrath, and Ambrose.

As for his action, it’s perfectly fine.
He’s strike rate and wickets in sena countries makes him comparable to mcgrath and malcom marshall even he’s better stat but we aren’t saying he’s ahead but he’s only comparable to McGrath ,steyn ,marshall And as far as wasim he’s daylight ahead of wasim akram
 
He’s strike rate and wickets in sena countries makes him comparable to mcgrath and malcom marshall even he’s better stat but we aren’t saying he’s ahead but he’s only comparable to McGrath ,steyn ,marshall And as far as wasim he’s daylight ahead of wasim akram

No. He is not comparable.

It is because this era has weaker batters thanks to T20 leagues. Bumrah has the luxury to face many T20 hacks. Legends from the past didn't have that luxury.
 
He’s strike rate and wickets in sena countries makes him comparable to mcgrath and malcom marshall even he’s better stat but we aren’t saying he’s ahead but he’s only comparable to McGrath ,steyn ,marshall And as far as wasim he’s daylight ahead of wasim akram

Daylight ahead of Wasim Akram? Brilliant! I’m sure Wasim himself just packed up his legacy and called it a day after hearing your expert verdict. Groundbreaking stuff!
 
Bumrah is an exceptional bowler, undoubtedly the best among the current lot. There’s Bumrah, and then there’s the rest. However, let’s not get carried away and start placing him ahead to legends like Akram, McGrath, and Ambrose.

As for his action, it’s perfectly fine.
Akram doesn't belong in that tier. A tier lower.
 
I see some posters here only read what is convenient to them and ignore the fact that this thread was set up in 2016

That’s an important point actually given his raised profile now, his fans can’t use the argument that his critics have something against him when his action was called out long before he became India’s premier bowler. If he was from any other country, his action would have had a look at least.
 
You don't have to compare to past legends. Competition is fierce even among current lot. Rabada, Cummins, Hazelwood, Anderson. Even someone like Chris Wokes is pretty good, and these guys even knows how to bat.
 
That’s an important point actually given his raised profile now, his fans can’t use the argument that his critics have something against him when his action was called out long before he became India’s premier bowler. If he was from any other country, his action would have had a look at least.

100pct.
But these people will continue to bury their heads and use Pakistan and their "supposed" saltiness as a mask.

Bumrah shoukd be tested and that's the only logical outcome in all this
 
Back
Top