What's new

England v India | Only T20I | Sept 7, 2014 | Birmingham

Status
Not open for further replies.
Only T20... thought it would have been 3 or 2 at least.

England T20 side is pretty average, India should chase the total, cant see England putting anything above 150 though not sure how this pitch is, someone needs to play a Finch innings for England to get a good total.
 
Wonder why Dhoni needs to pay this totally inconsequential game. Should have given a chance to Sanju.

And we have picked the exact same squad as ODIs and decided to play 3 spinners! What a terrible team selection.
 
England Team
AD Hales, JJ Roy, MM Ali, JE Root, EJG Morgan*, JC Buttler†, RS Bopara, CR Woakes, JC Tredwell, ST Finn, HF Gurney

India Team
S Dhawan, AM Rahane, V Kohli, AT Rayudu, SK Raina, MS Dhoni*†, RA Jadeja, R Ashwin, KV Sharma, MM Sharma, Mohammed Shami
 
Jason Roy makes his debut.I think Samson should have been given Atleast one chance
 
Disgusting really. Binny took 6 wickets last time he played in the shorter formats, not good enough for even one game! Umesh Yadav gets one chance, dropped. Dhawal gets one chance, dropped.

CSKite Mohit Sharma gets dropped but comes back immediately.
 
Only T20... thought it would have been 3 or 2 at least.

England T20 side is pretty average, India should chase the total, cant see England putting anything above 150 though not sure how this pitch is, someone needs to play a Finch innings for England to get a good total.
BCCI and the players dont care about T20I's.We have played least no. of T20I among top 8 teams.
 
Guys anyone using TataSky here?

For Star Sports it says no signal.

Other channels are coming. Only sport channels are showing no signal.
 
Everyone gets a rest at some stage but not Dhoni despite having an injury! Sounds very insecure on part of Dhoni
 
Why isn't james taylor playing? He could be englands next big thing along side root.
 
The best thing about t20s is that i can watch them wholly irrespective of the teams playing.
 
good to see Karan Sharma playing :)

However would have liked to see Samson and Binny too.Playing Rayudu in T20 is most idiotic
 
Wasim Akram on Star Sports :"The reason Pakistan are consistent in T20's because there is no thinking involved."
 
Disgusting really. Binny took 6 wickets last time he played in the shorter formats, not good enough for even one game! Umesh Yadav gets one chance, dropped. Dhawal gets one chance, dropped.

CSKite Mohit Sharma gets dropped but comes back immediately.

Mohit was injured,not dropped.much better than Yadav atleast
 
Safe to say Dhoni has not picked Umesh Yada to save himself from getting injured further.

Must be the first time a team has picked 3 specialist spinners in a T20 in England
 
Safe to say Dhoni has not picked Umesh Yada to save himself from getting injured further.

Must be the first time a team has picked 3 specialist spinners in a T20 in England

yeah his pathetic ODI record amd pathetic performance in last ODI has nothing to do with it :19:
 
Now another CSK hero to bowl. Last time Mohit Sharma took a wicket in any form against a top 8 side was way back in April 2014 in te T20 WC
 
Now another CSK hero to bowl. Last time Mohit Sharma took a wicket in any form against a top 8 side was way back in April 2014 in te T20 WC

he was there taking wickets in BD while fast bowler Yadav was getting spanked by BD batsmen in bowler friendly conditions
 
Dhoni gave Umesh Yadav 6 overs in the last game in 4 freaking spells.

There is no defense for Dhoni reg Yadav.
 
he was there taking wickets in BD while fast bowler Yadav was getting spanked by BD batsmen in bowler friendly conditions

Yep all he has is a grand total of one wicket against a top 8 side in 6-7 ODIs and a couple in T20s. Such a threatening bowler
 
Umm, why isn't BK playing ?
And I think India should give T20 captaincy to Raina. Will give them chances to try young keepers like Samson in this format.
 
Dhoni gave Umesh Yadav 6 overs in the last game in 4 freaking spells.

There is no defense for Dhoni reg Yadav.

thats a pathetic excuse.Everybody knew we need a death bowler so Yadav would have got overs there if he did well

Here's how our two death bowlers Shami and Umesh got spells

Umesh :

1st spell : 3 overs (with new ball)
2nd : 1(in middle overs)
3rd :1(conceded 13)
4th : 1(conceded 12)

Shami :

1st spell : 4 overs(without new ball)
2nd : 1 over(before batting PP)
3rd : 5 overs (but conceded 6,6,5,6,11 in those overs)

if he went for 13 and 12 like Yadav,he might not have got overs too.


So both were treated pretty equally.Infact Yadav got better as he got new ball despite much inferior record)
 
thats a pathetic excuse.Everybody knew we need a death bowler so Yadav would have got overs there if he did well

Here's how our two death bowlers Shami and Umesh got spells

Umesh :

1st spell : 3 overs (with new ball)
2nd : 1(in middle overs)
3rd :1(conceded 13)
4th : 1(conceded 12)

Shami :

1st spell : 4 overs(without new ball)
2nd : 1 over(before batting PP)
3rd : 5 overs (but conceded 6,6,5,6,11 in those overs)

if he went for 13 and 12 like Yadav,he might not have got overs too.


So both were treated pretty equally.Infact Yadav got better as he got new ball despite much inferior record)

BK averages 65 since 2013(or something like that).Still got a consistent run.
 
Stop the press, Mohit Sharma has a wicket against a top 8 side, a very rare event
 
Sharma in ODIs minus the minnows - 5 ODIs, 1 wicket @ 212, ER of 7+, earth shattering numbers :))

atleast he didnt get smashed by same minnows in bowler friendly conditions where even Binny did well.

also these must be just 5-6 ODIs,Yadav has got 30 ODIs now and his performances are still poor
 
thats a pathetic excuse.Everybody knew we need a death bowler so Yadav would have got overs there if he did well

Here's how our two death bowlers Shami and Umesh got spells

Umesh :

1st spell : 3 overs (with new ball)
2nd : 1(in middle overs)
3rd :1(conceded 13)
4th : 1(conceded 12)

Shami :

1st spell : 4 overs(without new ball)
2nd : 1 over(before batting PP)
3rd : 5 overs (but conceded 6,6,5,6,11 in those overs)

if he went for 13 and 12 like Yadav,he might not have got overs too.


So both were treated pretty equally.Infact Yadav got better as he got new ball despite much inferior record)

Yeah. One guy gets 3 overs in spell 1 and 1 over spells while other guy gets 4 and 5 over spells (spell 1 and 3).

Equal treatment only.

Dhoni treats pacers badly but Umesh got a real bad deal.

Pacers get into rhytm to bowl well.
 
BK averages 65 since 2013(or something like that).Still got a consistent run.

because he had done well earlier.and his ER is always good

his averages are 33 and 45 for 2013 and 2014 :13:
 
Last edited:
Poor Moeen gave a catch to go back to pavillion otherwise he might cry because he is being booed at home.
 
Yeah. One guy gets 3 overs in spell 1 and 1 over spells while other guy gets 4 and 5 over spells (spell 1 and 3).

Equal treatment only.

Dhoni treats pacers badly but Umesh got a real bad deal.

Pacers get into rhytm to bowl well.

Shami bowled first over of his 3rd spell for 5 runs instead of 13,so obviously he'll get more.

Plus Yadav got new ball
 
England what are you doing, this is the flattest you would get but still 2 down :faceplam:
 
Eng should save a few wickets for last 5 overs. With spinners bowling, even 75-80 runs are easily possible.
 
Shami bowled first over of his 3rd spell for 5 runs instead of 13,so obviously he'll get more.

Plus Yadav got new ball

By this yardstick, if a pacer goes for runs, they should get spells like this.

Pacers (especially erratic but wicket taking ones like Umesh) need spells.

If you can't give them proper spells, you are pretty much wasting everyone's time playing them.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top