What's new

England v Pakistan | 3rd Test | Birmingham | Aug 3-7, 2016 | Day 1

What the hell what if he gave it out lbw?? How do we know he gave it out caught?
 
I think, PAK is heading for their 1st innings target for day 1 - 270/8. May be 15/20 runs more, but it could be all-out today as well. Still 16 overs left & the 2nd new ball awaiting.

However, after English tour, Mickey has to solve the 5th bowler problem - PAK simply can't bowl 30 overs with Ysir on Day 1. Also, Sohail has already bowled 20, has to bowl another 5. I think, in UAE, PAK can play with 4 bowlers because 2 spinners should bowl 130+ overs, but any where outside, depending on wicket, one of Nawaz or Yamin has to play. Banking on MoHa probably is not going to work going forward, while Azhar is not interested to improve his leg-spin.

Eight down - or is it out-side leg?
 
Oh i understand. Umpire gave it out caught. But not lbw. Had he given it lbw it wouldve been out since umpires call was for leg before.
 
Guys try to understand. If he gave it leg before then it would have been out...
 
Maybe I'm seeing things but I thought the ball hit the glove - knuckle/finger part ?
 
Guys it wasnt LBW since the umpire didnt give it out LBW. This has happened before as well so no need to cry.
 
aliasad1998 said:
Oh i understand. Umpire gave it out caught. But not lbw. Had he given it lbw it wouldve been out since umpires call was for leg before.
Click to expand...
But what if he didn't give it lbw thinking that it hit the bat first ?

Sent from my SM-N750 using Tapatalk
 
DRS Fail.

That was either LBW or Caught. May not be LBW as only a small portion of ball is barely grazing the leg stump.

Should have been out Caught at least.

I am confused.
 
aliasad1998 said:
Guys it wasnt LBW since the umpire didnt give it out LBW. This has happened before as well so no need to cry.
Click to expand...
I hv nvr seen it happening before .. can u plzzz quote any instance ?

Sent from my SM-N750 using Tapatalk
 
aliasad1998 said:
Guys it wasnt LBW since the umpire didnt give it out LBW. This has happened before as well so no need to cry.
Click to expand...
A) it hit the glove B) he was originally given out, so unless the umpire had conclusive evidence, he couldn't overturn the decision.
 
Dharmasena was not even aware that the decision was given because of the glove. He was just checking the bat,
that is plain stupid.
 
Drs system should be adjusted. I think azhar caught the catch to cover the all bases. Umpire has given someone out so all decisions should apply but I understand the decision that was give with Moen now.
 
Red Devil said:
A) it hit the glove B) he was originally given out, so unless the umpire had conclusive evidence, he couldn't overturn the decision.
Click to expand...

In terms of the LBW he was originally given not out LBW therefore the umpire needs conclusive evidence (no umpires call) to overturn it.
 
Its Moen's day.

If he stays for another hour, he will get close to 100.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Red Devil said:
A) it hit the glove B) he was originally given out, so unless the umpire had conclusive evidence, he couldn't overturn the decision.
Click to expand...

I agree with A. But with B, this has happened before. If the u pire had given it leg before and not caught then umpires call would have been out. Im 100 percent sure. The umpire gave it caught.
 
Guys I just saw the replay again on very slow motion sky. - it's 100% hit the glove !!!!


Bizzare and ridiculous decision by 3rd umpire !!
 
By each day, I do praise BCCI for not using DRS, which creates more confusion & frustration among players. And this'll continue, till it's kept with players.

Take out the DRS from players - give it to field Umpire. If he is confused, he can ask his partner/3rd Umpire for confirmation.
 
HitWicket said:
In terms of the LBW he was originally given not out LBW therefore the umpire needs conclusive evidence (no umpires call) to overturn it.
Click to expand...

Exactly but if people are saying it hit the glove then wth is Dharmasena doing
 
MMHS said:
By each day, I do praise BCCI for not using DRS, which creates more confusion & frustration among players. And this'll continue, till it's kept with players.

Take out the DRS from players - give it to field Umpire. If he is confused, he can ask his partner/3rd Umpire for confirmation.
Click to expand...

DRS should be there to eliminate howlers.

Close calls should stay with on-field umpire.
 
Poor from Misbah.

Get Amir or Sohail Khan and Broad will not last more than 6 deliveries.
 
Just had a very quick rewatch, I don't see any mark on the glove on front on hotspot which would presumably be the perfect angle?
 
New ball is 4 overs away... So we should get 10 overs with new ball today.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Cricket Warrior
Pakistan reach 73/3 at stumps in the 1st innings of the 3rd Test against England
10 11 12
Replies
935
Views
18K
Nasty Naz
N
BouncerGuy
England (183/7) beat Pakistan (160) by 23 runs in the 2nd T20I to go up 1-0 in the 4-match T20I series
12 13 14
Replies
1K
Views
19K
Ali T
A
Cricket Warrior
Pakistan reach 259/5 at stumps on Day 1 of the second Test against England
10 11 12
Replies
889
Views
23K
Major
Major
Cricket Warrior
England struggle at 24/3 in their second innings at stumps on Day 2 of the third Test against Pakistan
8 9 10
Replies
797
Views
17K
batandballbattle
B
BouncerGuy
England (226/3) defeat West Indies (222/6) by 7 wickets in the 3rd T20I to narrow the deficit to 2-1
Replies
27
Views
1K
Suleiman
Suleiman
Back
Top