What's new

England [269 & 391/8d] defeat South Africa [223 & 248] by 189 runs to win 2nd Test; series level 1-1

DOMINIC SIBLEY led the way with a career best innings and every chance of converting it into a maiden Test match century as England ground their way towards an invincible position on day three of the second Test match against the Standard Bank Proteas at Newlands on Sunday.

England closed the day on 218/4 for an overall lead of 264 runs with one of the four wickets being that of night watchman Dom Bess who departed for a pair in the match.

Sibley finished the day on 85 (222 balls, 13 fours), having shared stands of 73 for the second wicket with Joe Denly and 116 for the third with Joe Root (61 off 98 balls, 7 fours). This was a huge improvement on Sibley’s previous career best of 29 in the previous Test match at SuperSport Park.

What would have been even more important for the tourists was the fact that their top order put up by far their most convincing batting display for a long time, leaving Root with really only one issue being the timing of his declaration, assuming the Proteas don’t make a major breakthrough with the second new ball which becomes available almost immediately on the fourth morning.

There is plenty of time left in the match and the one thought at the back of Root’s mind will be whether the pitch has become flatter and easier for survival or whether England have just bowled better in the match than their South African counterparts.

It was a backfoot day for the Proteas who only managed to add 8 runs to their total for the last two wickets, both taken by Jimmy Anderson who took the 28th fifer of his international career to finish with 5/40 in 19 overs. It gave England an important lead of 46 runs.

Thereafter, attrition was the name of the game as the England batsmen attempted grind down the Protea attack that got little assistance out of the conditions to offer any encouragement.

It was another good day for the Sunfoil Education Trust (SET) that gained a further R151 000 from the boundaries and sixes hit and wickets taken by the two teams, bringing the cumulative total for the series to R411 000.
 
Abit harsh, this is his 4th test match

he is a good prospect, but just talking about his bowling performance. he bowled very full and there was no reason safricans should have been put under pressure by him.

think leach is better than him
 
he is a good prospect, but just talking about his bowling performance. he bowled very full and there was no reason safricans should have been put under pressure by him.

think leach is better than him

Not at all, leach is way overrated, he was decent before but since he had to remodel his action due to beingvsuspect he's not the same, like I've said before moin ali is England's best spinner by a distance , hes rightfully taking his time to return to the long format as ecb took away his test contract, now hes a man in demand in 5he short formats and has no restrictions, check his test stats as a allrounder, there pretty decent
 
Not at all, leach is way overrated, he was decent before but since he had to remodel his action due to beingvsuspect he's not the same, like I've said before moin ali is England's best spinner by a distance , hes rightfully taking his time to return to the long format as ecb took away his test contract, now hes a man in demand in 5he short formats and has no restrictions, check his test stats as a allrounder, there pretty decent

Leach averages 29, Moeen 36. I think Moeen will come back for next tour of the Subcontinent.
 
Play for tomorrow? - Sibley get his ton, Stokes and Buttler smash it leaving SA 350 to win, declare with 45 overs to go, leaving 135 overs to get SA out.
 
Leach averages 29, Moeen 36. I think Moeen will come back for next tour of the Subcontinent.

Come on rob, ok then moin 14 50's and 5 test hundreds with the bat, 180 test wickets, 5 fifers, and a tenfer,

Il be surprised if he does, hes not taken it lightly that England discarded his central test contract, and he clearly feels he gets used as the scapegoat when others also don't perform
 
South Africa missed a big chance of going 2-0. If England manage to win this one, I think England can draw the series or even win it.
 
England is winning this game. Bat first, get a total of 275+ in first inning and your probability of winning goes up to 60%+. Amongst competitive teams in the last 8 years, those are the stats.

Said this when England was 10/0 in the 1st inning. England is a highly accomplished team, any team with a gem of a player like Ben Stokes will anyway win more matches than they loose abroad so all they needed was a little bit of luck, which came through in form of toss and from there on it was a no brainer.
 
Come on rob, ok then moin 14 50's and 5 test hundreds with the bat, 180 test wickets, 5 fifers, and a tenfer,

Il be surprised if he does, hes not taken it lightly that England discarded his central test contract, and he clearly feels he gets used as the scapegoat when others also don't perform

Ah, but you were talking about spinning not batting.

I think Moeen could come back as a test #6 and second spinner. He lost his central contact because his game completely collapsed. He is young enough to return. But he isn’t a front rank spinner in tests, so he will have to bat in the top six, which he is capable of doing. A middle order of Root / Stokes / Moeen / Foakes works for me.
 
Said this when England was 10/0 in the 1st inning. England is a highly accomplished team, any team with a gem of a player like Ben Stokes will anyway win more matches than they loose abroad so all they needed was a little bit of luck, which came through in form of toss and from there on it was a no brainer.

Stokes is overrated on this board. He is a good batsman but not a great one, a superlative catcher and an ok bowler. I’d put him at third best England allrounder of my life, after Botham and Greig.
 
Stokes is overrated on this board. He is a good batsman but not a great one, a superlative catcher and an ok bowler. I’d put him at third best England allrounder of my life, after Botham and Greig.

He may not be a great batsman or bowler but as an overall package combined with his fighting spirit, does put him on a different pedestal IMO. My view might be biased because I am a massive Stokes' fan but his achievements in the last few years, including world cup final performance, makes him a champion cricketer. We would have won the first test at edgbaston last year as Kohli looked unstoppable with only 40-50 more runs to get but Stokes got him out and changed the entire match on its head. I think he has owned several such moments and hence lot of respect for him.
 
Stokes is overrated on this board. He is a good batsman but not a great one, a superlative catcher and an ok bowler. I’d put him at third best England allrounder of my life, after Botham and Greig.

I for one have never put stokes in bothams class, that is completely riddicilous at the moment to think that
 
Ah, but you were talking about spinning not batting.

I think Moeen could come back as a test #6 and second spinner. He lost his central contact because his game completely collapsed. He is young enough to return. But he isn’t a front rank spinner in tests, so he will have to bat in the top six, which he is capable of doing. A middle order of Root / Stokes / Moeen / Foakes works for me.

Rob we don't have a lead spinner, swann was the only one I saw of genuine top class and maybe Phil tuffnel, what we have now is what we have and theirs certainly no l3ad spinner even root knows this, in recent tests root had absolute no confidence in leach he was bowling himself over him
 
England will win this game. Don't see South Africa chasing down this score. Pitch will get more difficult to bat on.
 
Good day for England , Anderson bowling like that is always a great sight. England definitely ahead and their lead already looks intimidating with more batting to come.
 
Both India and Australia are head and shoulders better than 3rd team downwards

England can beat australia honestly. why dint they pick curran and pope in the ashes? At home I mean. England can beat Aussies at home.

away is questionable as many aren't comfortable with bounce.

maybe with archer, stones, broad it could be interesting? but australia will be favourites ofcourse.
 
Leach averages 29, Moeen 36. I think Moeen will come back for next tour of the Subcontinent.

Come on rob, ok then moin 14 50's and 5 test hundreds with the bat, 180 test wickets, 5 fifers, and a tenfer,

Il be surprised if he does, hes not taken it lightly that England discarded his central test contract, and he clearly feels he gets used as the scapegoat when others also don't perform

Leach has something that Moeen doesn’t have - courage.

And I am not talking about Moeen’s life as a son of a Pakistani immigrant and how he fought to become an international cricketer. We have heard that story a dozen times. I am talking about their international careers.

Moeen has been given more than ample opportunities to cement himself but he couldn’t. His chicken-hearted performances and severe bottling in the last year or so across all formats was disgusting. He clearly does not deserve to wear the England shirt any time soon.

Leach’s resilient effort to support Stokes during his legendary innings in the Ashes was remarkable. You can be certain that if it was Moeen, he would have thrown his wicket away under pressure.

Anyway, it is indeed true that Swann has not been replaced yet. He was the best Test spinner in the world at a time when Ajmal could have won Olympic gold for javelin throw. In addition, he was a handy batsman and an excellent slip catcher, as well as a vocal leader in the dressing-room.
 
RSA 223
ENG 269, 219/4 (80.2) CRR: 2.73
Day 4: 1st Session - England lead by 265 runs

Runs continue to pile up vs SA.
 
Stokes has gone off like a rocket this morning. I think Roooooooot has given him license to slog.
 
Oops, what a de Kock-up!

Sibley into the nervous nineties as Stokes blazes away.
 
Stokes is such a great player. Sibley also nearing hundred. Things looking bad for SA.
 
Sibley!!!!!!!!!!

A decent opening partnership is forming for the first time since Strauss retired.
 
Aww, thought Stokes was going to get a super fast ton there. Took all pressure off Sibley though.

Just shows how top order runs are important. Stokes can come in with a ready made platform instead of trying to build one.

England can declare any time now.
 
Six for Sibley! Playing more expansively now he has his ton.

Six for Buttler.

Declare, Root......
 
Fantastic knock by sibely, absolute brilliant, will do him a world of good against a quality attack backed up by stokes
 
butler may be a good choice on flat tracks like this., but pitches like centurion are where foakes should come in.
 
Leach has something that Moeen doesn’t have - courage.

And I am not talking about Moeen’s life as a son of a Pakistani immigrant and how he fought to become an international cricketer. We have heard that story a dozen times. I am talking about their international careers.

Moeen has been given more than ample opportunities to cement himself but he couldn’t. His chicken-hearted performances and severe bottling in the last year or so across all formats was disgusting. He clearly does not deserve to wear the England shirt any time soon.

Leach’s resilient effort to support Stokes during his legendary innings in the Ashes was remarkable. You can be certain that if it was Moeen, he would have thrown his wicket away under pressure.

Anyway, it is indeed true that Swann has not been replaced yet. He was the best Test spinner in the world at a time when Ajmal could have won Olympic gold for javelin throw. In addition, he was a handy batsman and an excellent slip catcher, as well as a vocal leader in the dressing-room.

Steady on. Moeen has stood up for England many times. Scored two tons in India. Taken a tenfer. He is experiencing a confidence loss. It takes a very special person to stay on the international cricket treadmill and not burn out. He will be back on the next Subcontinent tour, I am sure.
 
England score 157 in the morning session.

Declare. Now.
 
Broad will wreck havoc, hope dom can build his confidence further and attack the bats with catching positions
 
if burns was not injured then the opening partnership would have been over 200

Possibly, burns is class, reminds me of the tough characters in the mould of Collingwood, greame Smith, javed miandad, nothing flamboyant but very tough
 
Yes, just a pitty Rory burns out for a while as he was really stamping his authority over one of the opening slots

Yes. He will come straight back in the English summer, unless Crawley plays a blinder in the next two tests.
 
Yes. He will come straight back in the English summer, unless Crawley plays a blinder in the next two tests.

Yes no doubt about his place, if Crawley plays really well then he could challenge denley even though hes looking good, we got to remember over the last few series these England bats have faces some gun attacks
 
Broad giving it a tonk. I think England will declare as Jimmy has no pads on.
 
RSA 223
ENG 269, 391/8 (111.0) CRR: 3.52
Day 4: 2nd Session - England lead by 437 runs
 
At last. 438 the target. Should have declared at lunch.

133* off 311 balls for Sibley, proper crease occupation, exactly what England need. Long may it continue.
 
Last edited:
Sibley remains unmoved. Eng have finally unearthed a proper test opening pair.

they have the potential to be better then strauss and cook
 
come on anderson, another five fer.

his haters will be confused

me. I am a big Anderson hater. I still won't be convinced because I know he is a SENA bully and sub continent fodder.

in saying that he is ridiculously good in favourable conditions. Better than boult and maybe even philander.
 
Sibley remains unmoved. Eng have finally unearthed a proper test opening pair.

they have the potential to be better then strauss and cook

More than fifty-three test centuries? Let's walk before we run.
 
me. I am a big Anderson hater. I still won't be convinced because I know he is a SENA bully and sub continent fodder.

in saying that he is ridiculously good in favourable conditions. Better than boult and maybe even philander.

Not really as he has not been great in SA, NZ and Australia. But he is brilliant in WI and UAE.
 
me. I am a big Anderson hater. I still won't be convinced because I know he is a SENA bully and sub continent fodder.

in saying that he is ridiculously good in favourable conditions. Better than boult and maybe even philander.

thats true

but he has two man of the match awards in india. has a better record than steyn in the UAE. Has a five fer in sri lanka. before 2016, he was not that bad in the subcontinent, most fans act like he is the worst bowler of all time in subcontinent, which is not true. in the 2016 series he was labeleld as a goose in subcontinent

after 32 even steyn was ineffective in subcontinent and got barely got a wicket in either india or sri lanka in about 4-5 tests

not saying he is the best, but he doesnt deserve that much hate from indian fans
 
ENG 269, 391/8 decl
RSA 223, 36/0 (12.4) CRR: 2.84
Day 4: 2nd Session - South Africa need 402 runs

Good start for SA but a very long way to go
 
me. I am a big Anderson hater. I still won't be convinced because I know he is a SENA bully and sub continent fodder.

in saying that he is ridiculously good in favourable conditions. Better than boult and maybe even philander.

How can you say this, Anderson end of yesterday's play said he missed the hard graft of test match cricket for the last 5-6 months through injury, this is a guy whose in his 150th test match, the guy is a role model for any upcoming fast bowlers, how can any one watching or playing not get inspiration from this
 
Last edited:
bess is doing the same job as he did 1st innings, safrica blocking his innocuous deliveries instead of scoring runs off them
 
bess is doing the same job as he did 1st innings, safrica blocking his innocuous deliveries instead of scoring runs off them

Inexperienced at this level, h3s actually inexperienced at first class level but hes a tough cricketer and eill improve
 
How can you say this, Anderson end of yesterday's play said he missed the hard graft of test match cricket for the last 5-6 months through injury, this is a guy whose in his 150th test match, the guy is a role model for any upcoming fast bowlers, how can any one watching or playing not get inspiration from this

yes boss. he is good. Just not a complete bowler like steyn etc.

what I mean isbge needs helpful wickets.
 
Last edited:
no what that was an edge. elgar is unlucky.

eng have quite a number of spin options when they tour the subcontinent
 
but denly still deserved that wicket, he is looking the most threatening on a day 4 pitch
 
port elizabeth pitch in the 3rd test match spins alot more then this pitch.

will eng drop bess for acher? i dont think so
 
If SAF survives another 17 overs, should ECB consider that it’s a drawn Test? Obviously there will be a direct result here unless it rains, because this is scheduled as a 5 day Test. I was talking from the spirit of cricket .......
 
Last edited:
port elizabeth pitch in the 3rd test match spins alot more then this pitch.

will eng drop bess for acher? i dont think so

Really? I knew St. George’s Park is the most seemer friendly track there along with centurion, while J’burg is bouncy.
 
Steyn following the game it seems (or even watching it live) ....

<blockquote class="twitter-tweet" data-partner="tweetdeck"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">Anyone else notice Jimmy’s run up to be a little longer? <br>I’ve been away at BBL so I’m little behind. Has he mentioned why? <a href="https://t.co/WqaB7tc40D">pic.twitter.com/WqaB7tc40D</a></p>— Dale Steyn (@DaleSteyn62) <a href="https://twitter.com/DaleSteyn62/status/1214157757122842624?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 6, 2020</a></blockquote>
<script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
 
pieter malan looks much better than markram, who would gotten out within the first 10 overs
 
Stokes bowling 145+ each delivery.

When did he become this fast?
 
ENG 269, 391/8 decl
RSA 223, 113/1 (47.4) CRR: 2.37
Day 4: 3rd Session - South Africa need 325 runs

Good fight this!
 
ENG 269 & 391/8d

SA: 223 & 123/2

South Africa require another 314 runs with 8 wickets

Hamza just out for 18.
 
Sa can only draw from here which seems unlikely. Tommorow will be a good test for Dom Bess
 
Class performance from Sibley. This match is set up wonderfully. As a note, if this was a 4-day match, England would still be 1-0 down. Yet another reason to ignore that stupid idea.
 
Monday, 06 January 2020

BEN STOKES launched a memorable blitz on the Standard Bank Proteas to effectively take any chance of a home win out of the equation on day four of the second Test match at Newlands on Monday.

The England’s all-rounder’s onslaught was as unorthodox as it was effective as he shared a partnership of 92 with Dom Sibley and contributed 72 off the runs scored off just 47 balls with 7 fours and 3 sixes.

His 50 came off 34 balls (5 fours and 2 sixes) with only the legendary Sir Ian Botham having scored faster half-centuries in Test cricket for England.

His innings rather overshadowed the maiden century from Sibley who finished unbeaten on 133 (311 balls, 19 fours and a six) but which also played an important role as he laid the foundation for the all-out attack that followed both from Stokes and Jos Buttler.

When Joe Root did declare half an hour after lunch, he left the Proteas with a world record target of 438 in a minimum of 146 overs and although the number 438 has happy memories for the Proteas and their fans it is not really a practical proposition.

The Proteas made a steady start to their reply with Pieter Malan and Dominic Elgar putting on 71 for the first wicket – the first half-century opening partnership for the Proteas in almost a year.

There was a further stand of 52 between Malan and Zubayr Hamza for the second wicket but the Proteas were still left needing a further 312 for victory on the final day with 8 wickets in hand.
 
Back
Top