What's new

India vs England | 4th ODI | 23rd January, 2013 - Mohali

Status
Not open for further replies.
Who deserves what, and why?

Finn,he always does that n hasnt stopped.I think he should be stopped from bowling after 2 warnings

in T20WC they were taking batsmen's runs away due to that
 
Finn,he always does that n hasnt stopped.I think he should be stopped from bowling after 2 warnings

in T20WC they were taking batsmen's runs away due to that

Stopped from bowling? :/ Why?

It's not like it scuffs up the pitch or affects the game.
 
Finn,he always does that n hasnt stopped.I think he should be stopped from bowling after 2 warnings

in T20WC they were taking batsmen's runs away due to that

I think they definitely need to finalise the rules, it's happened a few time this series and not been called a deadball. As for taking home off after 2 warnings why should you do that? It's not dangerous nor does it damage the pitch.
 
Stopped from bowling? :/ Why?

It's not like it scuffs up the pitch or affects the game.

it disrupts the batsmen's concentration and sometimes stops play unnecessarily.should get it sorted imo or be punished
 
Finn,he always does that n hasnt stopped.I think he should be stopped from bowling after 2 warnings

in T20WC they were taking batsmen's runs away due to that

I think they definitely need to finalise the rules, it's happened a few time this series and not been called a deadball. As for taking him off after 2 warnings why should you do that? It's not dangerous nor does it damage the pitch.
 
maybe not stopped,but defintely needs to be punished in some way.it needs to be a deterrent
 
it disrupts the batsmen's concentration and sometimes stops play unnecessarily.should get it sorted imo or be punished

Bowler's concentration and the general flow of play are also disrupted when the batsman is complaining about sightscreen (sometimes half way through a delivery - Gauti is really bad for it). The fielding side and the game are also hindered by drinks and new gloves and other time-wasting tactics used by the 12th man. Should a batsman lose his wicket after '2 warnings' for these?

Be fair.
 
True, I would like to see some sort of deterrent to Dhonis's incessant and Unnecesary glove/bat changing!
 
Bowler's concentration and the general flow of play are also disrupted when the batsman is complaining about sightscreen (sometimes half way through a delivery - Gauti is really bad for it). The fielding side and the game are also hindered by drinks and new gloves and other time-wasting tactics used by the 12th man. Should a batsman lose his wicket after '2 warnings' for these?

Be fair.

okay,I agree I overreacted,but it defintely needs to be stopped somehow
 
Didn't Finn/Strauss have a massive whinge when it happened against Smith at Headingley?

The Poms're worse than us in that regard.
 
I can clearly recall this Lankan bowler called Farweez Maharoof (might have got the spelling wrong) who also had this problem of knocking the stumps down, except that he used to do it with his hands during the follow through, not the knee.
 
Didn't Finn/Strauss have a massive whinge when it happened against Smith at Headingley?

The Poms're worse than us in that regard.

In fairness Graeme Smith complaints caused a new law to be introduced because until then I had never seen a deadball being given for such an occurrence. Mind you I'd never seen a bowler knock the stumps over as often as Finn
 
50 to get. This game is over.

Only the South Africans can envision a loss from this point on.

Should have played a fifth test to try and level the series, the English are no good when they come out here and play LoIs.
 
Tim: "For the sake of ramming the nail in the coffin in this series, can someone please get Dernbach to bowl another couple of overs. It should see the Indians home, and we can all get on with some work!"
 
Dhoni just making sure Dernbach will be back for game #5.

Mind you, I think he'd have come back anyway.
 
Gameon: "Cheers to Dernbach, he's done it...what good deliveries couldn't do, a Dernbach delivery does."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top