Brother, all these Western Bloc, Eastern Bloc examples are fine but they are not relevant in this case as our stance is not principled.
We are not saying we will not play against Pakistan.
What we are saying is -
1. We will not play with them in bilateral engagement as they send insurgents and instigate sessiocionist movement in Kashmir.
2. However, when in comes to ICC events, we will forget all the above and play with them wholeheartedly.
1. I think you are confusing calibrated stance with absolute stance. India never said they will play with them wholeheartedly. India/BCCI has always maintained they are contract bound by ICC to play with Pakistan. They only have two options either to play with Pakistan or to forfeit the points. GoI has made it's stance clear that under current circumstances ICT will not travel to Pakistan and if that means forfeiting the points so be it. Now that ICC/PCB have found the latter option untenable, so they are prostrating in front of BCCI to get them to come to Pakistan or play hybrid mode. Not sure what part of this stance is confusing. If you say ICT should no longer play cricket with Pakistan and forfeit the points, I agree with you. But that is not the stance of GoI. BCCI is the first world dominating institute to emerge out of India. GoI does have a clue how to utilize that sort of power, which is why Modi is now being blamed for pusillanimity.
3. Not only we will play with them but treat that game as extra special, intentionally ask ICC to put us in same group so that we get a guaranteed game, have reserved day only for that match, postpone opening ceremony of the world cup and host it prior to this game only, our media channels like Aaj Tak doing bhangra in studio by calling it as 'Maha muqabla', doing bhai chara with Pakistani channels in cross border shows, Star Sports calls it as greatest rivalry etc etc.
4. Then when this game and Euphoria gets over, we start thinking about soldiers and martyrs from next day.
I am not sure if BCCI asking ICC to do it or ICC is doing it out of it's accord. But lets accept your argument on face value. We have a section of society which suffers from inferiority complex or as
@rpant_gabba correctly calls it Nehru/Gandhi virus. So they will try to portray pipe dreams of India-Pakistan solidarity or milk it commercially. After all the pressure of winning the game is because Indians and Pakistanis are not particularly fond of each other and they replace battle field with cricket field.
If I have to summarize our stance in this saga it is as follows:
We will not play with Pakistan normally but will play with Pakistan in ICC events but will not play if that ICC event is in Pakistan but will play as long as it is in any other country but want Pakistan to be in India for all ICC events but don't want them in India for bilateral cricket
We are contract bound by ICC to play them in ICC events. As much as you like to think, getting PCB out of ICC is not a cake walk and I am assuming/hoping it is an escalatory ladder, which is an action GoI will take at subsequent levels. . You might ask why not, I might say good question and the only guess is GoI is inept at using that level of power.
Yeh kaisa mazaak chal raha hai yaar??
To paraphrase Arthur Clarke: "Koi bhi calibrated policy, anpadh ko, mazaak lagti hain".
Just writing that I am laughing in disgust and you think boards like ECB/ACB don't in closed rooms in this never ending sub continent politics?
I was watching Sports Tak after we won the WT20 and Vikrant Gupta was present in press box for the finals. He was saying every ICC board member were rooting for SA in that game. The same members whose pockets are filled with money generated by Bcci. So it is high time to reflect what we are doing that is so wrong that is making us so hated in cricket world.
USA is hated and feared in equal amounts. Business conglomerates are hated and feared in equal amount. If you are not ready to be hated, you will never be a super power. I know you will quote me Raghuram Rajan and ask "Why do we need to be a super power" at which point, I will raise my hands in the air.
Our stance need to be principled.
No... our stance needs to satisfy our principles and our interests. In an ideal world the external principles and our interests are aligned, but when they are not perfectly aligned, we need a calibrated policy like GoI has.
By pulling out a team in the middle of a test series by giving covid excuse when we had a great chance of winning it and fly them to play IPL in Dubai only to complete that remaining test one year later...you think other boards will not laugh?
I am not sure it was a Covid excuse, since a lot of our players were down with Covid afair.
It has nothing to with inferiority complex, patriotism etc. I am very patriotic and people who have read my posts in TP section knows this too. However, I always call spade a spade and BCCI is polluting this game of cricket with their hypocrisy and innocent Indians 24*7 defending that in social media as if their life depends on it. LMAO
I am not sure who called you unpatriotic. afaik, no one, and I repeat no one, has the power to pass judgement on your patriotism. You call a spade, if you see or believe it is a spade. You are not the authority on what the spade looks like. If you feel BCCI is polluting the game of cricket, you are free to believe so. But to point out that "BCCI bad because ECB/CA is laughing at us with disgust" reeks of inferiority complex.