What's new

West Indies v Pakistan | 1st Test | Sabina Park, Kingston | Apr 21-25, 2017 | Day 4

Are you gonna ask the same question of Babar Azam, Younis Khan and Asad Shafiq whose SRs read 35, 42 and 32 ?

Yup, all need to be asked the same question. Were they batting to set up a possible test match win or batting out a draw? Are you ever going to question Misbah's tactics as a captain or are you going to blindly defend his every move?
 
Just stopped watching the match but I hope Misbah ups the rate a little. The pitch has dried out and with almost a day gone to rain, Pak don't have enough time.
 
Yup, all need to be asked the same question. Were they batting to set up a possible test match win or batting out a draw? Are you ever going to question Misbah's tactics as a captain or are you going to blindly defend his every move?

The whole team is one paced. Too many grinders and nudgers, which explains why we were caught out in Australia against a very aggressive batting unit.

I have criticised him many times but the double standards and hypocrisy is amazing here. If you're worried about the scoring rate, show some intellectual honesty and criticise Babar, Shafiq and YK's SRs instead of parroting what everyone else is saying.
 
Half through Yasir's innings Misbah got his act together.

He started taking more of the strike, putting away the poor ball and looking to keep the scoreboard moving over.

C'mon skipper! Let's get a 100 now!
 
Windies need a better Test match spinner than Bishoo. Don't be fooled by his Dubai spell when we slogged our wickets away.

WI pitches are generally spin-friendly and I accept he hasn't had great support from his other bowlers over the years, but a 42 bowling avg at home isn't good enough.
 
Misbah is like water in a desert. Priceless. This guy has done so much for Pakistan its nigh on ridiculous. Another superb knock for Pakistan when required.
 
Mashallah Abbas has looked pretty solid apart from when the ball has done something crazy which is very understandable for a number 11 on debut.
 
Although he has shown good defense, his run making ability is still questionable as he has a average of 7 in First Class, we should promote him gradually if he gets some success.

Surviving is more important once your team's eight down.
 
The whole team is one paced. Too many grinders and nudgers, which explains why we were caught out in Australia against a very aggressive batting unit.

I have criticised him many times but the double standards and hypocrisy is amazing here. If you're worried about the scoring rate, show some intellectual honesty and criticise Babar, Shafiq and YK's SRs instead of parroting what everyone else is saying.

Let's stop assuming things please. I've criticized Babar and YK when they were out in the middle, you can check Day 3's match thread. I haven't been as active on these commentary threads as I've exams to study for, and only post when I'm on a little break. I agree that the hate Misbah cops around here is unwarranted and exaggerated, but that being said, nobody is above criticism, not even Misbah.

My concerns were more regarding Misbah the captain and what his tactics really are. He's looked quite lackadaisical in the field over the past couple of series, and so I wonder whether his heads in it or not. Anyways, he's nearing a hundred, let's hope he gets it so I can get back to studying. :shezzy
 
Let's stop assuming things please. I've criticized Babar and YK when they were out in the middle, you can check Day 3's match thread. I haven't been as active on these commentary threads as I've exams to study for, and only post when I'm on a little break. I agree that the hate Misbah cops around here is unwarranted and exaggerated, but that being said, nobody is above criticism, not even Misbah.

My concerns were more regarding Misbah the captain and what his tactics really are. He's looked quite lackadaisical in the field over the past couple of series, and so I wonder whether his heads in it or not. Anyways, he's nearing a hundred, let's hope he gets it so I can get back to studying. :shezzy

Fair enough !
 
What a de ja vu this is :)) but so typical, Misbah will be left stranded
 
Back
Top